Framing Modernism, Estorick Collection, London

Modernism came relatively late to Italy, where photography and architecture became constant companions

News in pictures
News in pictures
On Facebook
Arts & Ents blogs

Shonky: From maths lover to international DJ

Late last year I interviewed Dan Ghenacia and Dyed Soundorom but missing from that interview was the...

Brighton Fringe: The week ahead…

So it seems that Brighton is well and truly swimming in gin, and apparently we can’t stop talking ab...

Lady Gaga corrupting youth, Bieber Fever and other reasons for gig cancellations

Are pop concerts the latest battle ground of moral superiority? Well, with Lady Gaga’s Indonesian co...

No one knows who took the photograph of Ignazio Gardella's tuberculosis dispensary in the Piedmontese town of Alessandria, although the drama of the shot – clouds scudding above the building's gridded façade, the picture's composition cunningly off-balance – suggests someone who knew what he was doing.

The photographer is clearly in love with Gardella's rationalism, his symphony of right angles and planes; in one sense, the image – included in the Estorick Collection's show Framing Modernism – sets out to replicate them. But in another, the anonymous picture does more than merely record. The black-and-white photograph shows Gardella's building as monochrome, no colour distracting from its geometric perfection. Actually, the dispensary's open-work screen was of local umber brick, its walls rendered in yellow plaster. Whoever shot the building wasn't just matching Gardella. In terms of purity, he was outdoing him.

Italy in the 1920s was a place in love with modernity, and with Modernism. The relatively late arrival in the country of Modernist architecture – Gardella's airy design signs up wholeheartedly to the Bauhaus creed of Licht, Luft und Sonne (light, air and sun) – coincided with a revolution in photography. Smaller, quicker cameras allowed their users to interact with buildings in a way that would have been impossible a decade before. By the late 1920s, the affection of photography for architecture had blossomed into love. Buildings joined picnics and wedding parties as a subject for studio photographers and amateurs alike, and image-led architectural magazines opened more or less daily. For the first time in Italian history, style and taste were disseminated principally by photograph.

A question raised by Framing Modernism is the extent to which the aesthetics of photography – the democratic way of seeing afforded by cheaper, more portable cameras – influenced those of the buildings it set out to record. The case of Gardella's dispensary is intriguing. Just as Johann Joachim Winckelmann's mistaken belief that antique marble sculpture had all been white wrote the rules of Neoclassicism – for a century, colour would be seen as a vulgar distraction from purity of form – so photography's monochrome palette left viewers with the impression that Modernism was colourless. To some extent, that belief still holds: witness the squeals of mingled joy and horror that greet the shocking pink structures of the Mexican architect Luis Barragan today. But it is interesting to think that the white-and-grey palette of even so great an architect as Pier Luigi Nervi might have been based, at least in part, on the technical limitations of another medium.

The second part of the show deals with Italian architecture after the Second World War, when the link between camera and building is clear to see. The dramatic underlighting and heroic ordinariness of an anonymous shot of the Cinema Altino in Padua, designed by Quirino de Giorgio and opened in 1951, echoes the look of the Neorealist films playing inside. So, too, does the building's style. Still camera and movie camera are clearly in league, with architecture as their subordinate. Sometimes, the ganging-up of lens and building takes a different form. In Vittorio de Sica's 1953 film, Stazione Termini, the titular Terminal Station's concrete ticket hall acted the movie's stars – Jennifer Jones and Montgomery Clift – off the screen.

But it is the first part of this show that really intrigues, with its suggestion of the newness not just of Italian architecture and photography, but of the compact between them. Here is an exuberant world, exuberantly seen – as you wander through the Estorick's galleries, you find yourself wishing you'd been there. And then dark passages appear among the white.

The sign on that elegant pavilion reads, on inspection, Casa del Fascio (Fascist House); the pavilion is in Eritrea, Italy's brutalised colony. The seaside colonia for workers' children near Pisa – so handsome, so idealistic! – is named for Rosa Maltoni Mussolini, Il Duce's mother. That chic structure in Milan by Ernesto Rogers, cousin of Richard, is a memorial to Italy's deported Jews, among them Rogers' architectural partner, Gian Luigi Banfi, who perished, at 35, in Mauthausen. So, too, did Giuseppe Pagano, Jew, architect, pilot and editor of the hugely influential Casabella magazine. Pagano's vertiginous shot of the 1940 stadium in Florence is full of a flyer's excitement at the promise of the new and Modern; a promise which – like Pagano himself – would soon fall, tragically, to earth.

London N1 (020-7704 9522) to 21 Jun

Independent Comment
blog comments powered by Disqus
Career Services

Day In a Page

Grace Dent: Personally, I'd fire bullying teens from a cannon and relocate the 'feral' kids to Chipping Norton

Grace Dent

Personally, I'd fire bullying teens from a cannon and relocate the 'feral' kids to Chipping Norton
Hollywood's former holiday destination of choice to vanish from tourist map

Falling off the tourist map

California's Salton Sea
Life as a hermit: 'My life is a great adventure'

Life as a hermit

For nearly 30 years, Jake Willams has lived as a hermit in the Scottish wilderness
European egrets move to Somerset – for the weather

Herons over here

European egrets move to Somerset – for the weather
Animals left for dead in Indonesian zoos

Zoos of death

Animals left for dead in Indonesian zoos
Millions of Asians watch 'ring of fire' eclipse

Ring of fire eclipse

The annular eclipse in pictures
Bee Gees star Robin Gibb - A Life in Pictures

A Life in Pictures

Bee Gees star Robin Gibb
Antelope first seen 20 years ago is on brink of extinction

Endangered animals

The good news and the bad news
Second best day of his life? Zuckerberg surprises friends with secret wedding

Second best day of his life?

Zuckerberg surprises friends with secret wedding
Laurie Penny: In the age of camera phones the message is that protesters are watching police too

Occupy in the age of the camera phone

In Chicago, you can't see the cops for the cameras
Exclusive extract: How Cameron tried to evade Murdoch's embrace

Exclusive book extract

How Cameron tried to evade Murdoch's embrace
Pathetic fantasist or Nazi spy? The mysterious Mrs O'Grady

Pathetic fantasist or Nazi spy? The mysterious Mrs O'Grady

She was the only British woman sentenced to death for treason during the Second World War. Now, a new book revisits her bizarre case
Introducing the wellderly

Introducing the wellderly

Growing numbers of the over-65s want to keep working, volunteer or go on gap years
Penny Junor: 'I'm absolutely not a friend of Prince Charles'

Penny Junor interview

'I'm absolutely not a friend of Prince Charles'
Joe Strummer: The angry young man who grew up

Joe Strummer

How to remember the punk hero?