JOHN MURRAY, £12.99. ORDER FOR £11.99 (FREE P&P) ON 0870 079 8897

A Family Daughter By Maile Meloy

Like Saffron's too-perfect breasts, it doesn't feel like the real thing

Maile Meloy's latest Californian saga kicks off with incest, a fatal car accident and plenty of close-ups of Malibu blondes. With its pulpish scenarios and peony-pink cover, A Family Daughter initially keeps its more serious literary credentials under wraps.

If possible, Meloy's new novel should be read in conjunction with her debut, Liars and Saints, short-listed for the 2005 Orange Prize. That bestseller introduced the Santerre family, a tightly knit clan of Hermosa Beach Catholics with love lives as complicated as their family tree. A Family Daughter revisits the Santerres and shares characters and narrative cues, but it is soon clear that the fictional fault-lines are shifting beneath our feet.

In Liars and Saints, granddaughter Abby has a one-night stand with her uncle Jamie, gets pregnant and dies of cancer. In the "sequel", Abby sleeps with her uncle - more than once - doesn't get pregnant, and writes a novel. When we finally clock that Abby's novel is in fact the text of Liars and Saints - a re-imagining of her family's past - Meloy leaves us to ponder the nature of authorial responsibility.

Metafictional games aside, A Family Daughter can stand alone as a sunny slice of Californian gothic. Opening in 1979, it follows Abby through a dysfunctional childhood to adulthood. A child of divorce, she has always been close to her uncle Jamie, a guitar-playing drop-out 12 years her senior. When Abby enrols at college, uncle and niece bow to the inevitable. The many consequences of their illicit union - involving a socialite called Saffron, a Romanian orphan, a renegade Jesuit and a French playboy - are so baroque as to merit several trips to the campus shrink and the local priest.

On many levels, Meloy's attempt to squeeze blockbuster excess into a more elegant literary form is a success. In short, cliff-hanging chapters, she keeps us entertained with vignettes of life on the Pacific rim. The collision of Catholic mumbo-jumbo and Californian flakiness finds perfect expression in Clarissa, Abby's mother, who seeks salvation in love affairs and ends up sleeping with a large sandy woman as a test of faith.

The novel reaches for moments of genuine emotional resonance: the jilted husband facing life alone over a bowl of cereal is as devastating as an Alice Munro miniature. More often than not, however, Meloy's pert prose, like Saffron's too-perfect West Coast breasts, ends up feeling like a substitute for the real thing.

Independent Comment
blog comments powered by Disqus
Career Services

Day In a Page

So long Sarkozy: Inside the tiny town that will topple the French president

Inside the tiny town that will topple Sarkozy

The tiny town of Donzy is France's political weathervane finds John Lichfield.
A class act: Claire Foy on criticism, tumours and embarrassing sex scenes

Claire Foy: Criticism, tumours and embarrassing sex scenes

Her luminous good looks made the actress the star of Little Dorrit and Upstairs Downstairs
A new leaf: Mark Hix sings the praises of spinach

A new leaf: Mark Hix sings the praises of spinach

Spinach is the versatile superfood that will keep you strong and healthy throughout the winter months.
Hollywood ate my novel: Novelists reveal what it’s like to have their book turned into a movie

Hollywood ate my novel

Novelists reveal what it’s like to have their book turned into a movie
How you can force companies to behave themselves

How you can force companies to behave themselves

Buying even a single share in a firm gives you the right to question its practices
Lost in the landscape: Wilderness and wildlife in Australia’s Top End

Wilderness and wildlife in Australia’s Top End

This sparsely populated region is home to creatures that are both fantastic and formidable
48 Hours: Marrakech

48 Hours: Marrakech

From the ancient medina to the Palmeraie, Morocco's Rose City offers a warm escape from the cold of winter.
Bear with Bern for Swiss skiing

Bear with Bern for Swiss skiing

Stephen Wood arrives at the gateway to the Bernese Oberland with plenty of respect for the slopes and the city's ursine inhabitants.
Dawn of the age of wireless medicine

Dawn of the age of wireless medicine

New technology means doctors will soon be able to regulate and monitor drug intake remotely – as long as patients remember to swallow their chips
Pete Doherty: I was a bit unhinged

Pete Doherty: I was a bit unhinged

Former Libertine talks frankly and exclusively about Kate Moss, Amy Winehouse, his baby daughter and why he paints with his own blood
Brown makes £1m since leaving No 10 (but Blair's still the leading earner)

Brown makes £1m since leaving No 10...

... but Blair's still the leading earner
The West Bank's Bobby Sands

The West Bank's Bobby Sands

Khader Adnan's two-month hunger strike has made him a hero among Palestinians outraged by Israel's policy of arbitrary detention
Hey, You've got to hide your drug away

Hey, You've got to hide your drug away

Paul McCartney has given up smoking dope. Simon Usborne charts a career of highs and lows
The 50 Best lights

The 50 Best cheap eats

The top spots for breakfast, lunch and dinner
MI5 helped US in fruitless search for Charlie Chaplin's Communist past

Investigating Charlie Chaplin

MI5 helped US in fruitless search for star's Communist past