Penguin, £25

The New Penguin Book of English Folk Songs, Edited by Steve Roud and Julia Bishop

Does this expert guide to a musical heritage throw out the mystery along with the myths?

The first Penguin Book of English Folk Songs appeared in 1959, under the editorship of Ralph Vaughan Williams and AL Lloyd, and has been a resource for generations of singers who have continued the folk tradition - or at least revived it. For throughout the short history of folk scholarship – from the moment Cecil Sharp overheard a gardener, John England, sing "Seeds of Love" – opinion has been that the tradition, like Pan, is dead, and we have only the dying embers to tend. The same was said in 1959, when Bob Copper and Peter Kennedy travelled the country to record still-surviving source singers. And it is said today, despite the fact that acclaimed young singer and collector Sam Lee has spent the last six years recording Traveller and Romany source singers largely unknown to the "folk community".

More than half a century after the first Penguin book, the folklorist Steve Roud, with musicologist Julia Bishop, has edited a new, handsome hardback of more than 500 pages and 151 songs, with sheet music and notes. It is in ten thematic parts – opening with soldiers and sailors, and proceeding through songs of love, lust, work, animals, nonsense, death, crime, and religion. There are only a handful of crossovers with the first book, so it is a companion rather than successor, though there is a stronger emphasis on the Broadside Ballads – songs that emerged into print through the 18th and 19th centuries – rather than the older and more mysterious songs.

Steve Roud is famous for his digitised song database, The Roud Index. He has written acclaimed books on superstition and folklore, in which he demonstrates that numerous "ancient" customs were Victorian creations. A similar approach figures in his notes here. For Roud, more or less all origins point to a song's first printed appearance. Beyond that lies fancy and wishful thinking.

This makes sense with Broadside Ballads, and songs associated with specific battles, heroes or criminals, but it is reductivist when it comes to the preliterate, mythic and folkloric elements of the tradition. How we connect to that buried matter dictates how we listen to it, sing it, and value it. It is arguable that some songs were sung long before they were written down, and that their origins remain a beautiful mystery.

Take "Barbara Allen", one of the most popular. Its earliest printed mention is in Pepys, and from this, Roud avers that here lies its origin. But can we assign written origins to an oral form? Especially with a song as familiar-strange as "Barbara Allen"? At its core is the unexplained cruelty of the woman, the weakness of the man, and the vegetal immortality for them both, as "the rose and the briar" . Its mystery suits personal interpretation more than definitive analysis.

While it is a wonderful resource of knowledge and scholarship, the book ignores the role of the Romany and Traveller singers. Having heard, on a recent song-collecting trip with Sam Lee, an 84-year-old Romany singer recite "Barbara Allen" with a verse I've never heard before, about tears in a golden bowl, experience suggests that belief in a textual origin for traditional songs is as much a leap of faith as those neo-pagan interpretations of "John Barleycorn" Roud scorns. Luckily, the songs are here to inhabit and make one's own, for with the tradition, it's not only where it comes from but what you do with it that counts.

Arts & Entertainment
Picture of innocence: Ricky Gervais and Karl Pilkington in ‘Derek’
TV
Arts & Entertainment
William Shakespeare's influence on English culture is still strongly felt today, from his plays on stage to words we use everyday
books50 Shakespeare phrases still in use, to mark the bard's 450th birthday
Arts & Entertainment
The next wig thing: 'Drag Queens of London'
TV
Arts & Entertainment
Bear Grylls’ latest television show has been labelled sexist by female survival experts

TV
Arts & Entertainment
Leonardo DiCaprio (left) could team up with British director Danny Boyle for the Steve Jobs (right) biopic
film
VIDEO
Arts & Entertainment
A stranger calls: Martin Freeman in ‘Fargo’
TV

Arts & Entertainment
Rush hour: shoppers go sale crazy in Barkers, Kensington
film
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition iPad app?
Arts & Entertainment
Juliette Binoche and Ralph Fiennes play Catherine and Heathcliff in Pete Kosminsky's 1992 movie adaptation of Wuthering Heights
booksGoogle Doodle celebrates Charlotte Brontë's 198th birthday
Arts & Entertainment
Robin Thicke with his Official Number 1 Award for 'Blurred Lines', the most downloaded track in UK music history
Music
Arts & Entertainment
Rory Kinnear in his Olivier-winning role as Iago in Othello
Theatre
Arts & Entertainment
Maisie Williams of Game of Thrones now
tvMajor roles that grow with their child actors are helping them to steal the show on TV
Arts & Entertainment
Who laughs lass: Jenny Collier on stage
ComedyCollier was once told there were "too many women" on bill
Arts & Entertainment
Ian Anderson, the leader of British rock band Jethro Tull, (right) and British guitar player Martin Barre (left) perform on stage
music

Arts & Entertainment
Tom Baker who played the Doctor longer than any other actor
tv
Arts & Entertainment
Ken Loach (left) and Mike Leigh who will be going head to head for one of cinema's most coveted prizes at this year's Cannes Film Festival

film
Arts & Entertainment
film

Arts & Entertainment
Don (John Hamm) and Megan (Jessica Paré) Draper are going their separate ways in the final series of ‘Mad Men’
tvReview: The suits are still sharp, but Don Draper has lost his edge
Arts & Entertainment
James Franco and Chris O'Dowd in Of Mice and Men on Broadway
theatre

Review: Of Mice and Men

Arts & Entertainment
art

By opportunistic local hoping to exhibit the work

Arts & Entertainment
Leonardo DiCaprio will star in an adaptation of Michael Punke's thriller 'The Revenant'
film

Fans will be hoping the role finally wins him an Oscar

Arts & Entertainment
Cody and Paul Walker pictured in 2003.
film

Arts & Entertainment
Down to earth: Fern Britton presents 'The Big Allotment Challenge'
TV

Arts & Entertainment
The London Mozart Players is the longest-running chamber orchestra in the UK
musicThreatened orchestra plays on, managed by its own members
Arts & Entertainment
Seeing red: James Dean with Sal Mineo in 'Rebel without a Cause'
film

Arts & Entertainment
TV
Independent
Travel Shop
the manor
Up to 70% off luxury travel
on city breaks Find out more
santorini
Up to 70% off luxury travel
on chic beach resorts Find out more
sardina foodie
Up to 70% off luxury travel
on country retreats Find out more
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition iPad app?

ES Rentals

    Independent Dating
    and  

    By clicking 'Search' you
    are agreeing to our
    Terms of Use.

    Migrants in Britain a decade on: The Poles who brought prosperity

    Migrants in Britain a decade on

    The Poles who brought prosperity
    Philippe Legrain: 'The eurozone crisis has tipped many into disillusionment, despair and extremism - we need a European Spring'

    Philippe Legrain: 'We need a European Spring'

    The eurozone crisis has tipped many into disillusionment, despair and extremism - this radically altered landscape calls for a new kind of politics, argues the economist
    A History of the First World War in 100 moments: A moment of glory on the Western Front for the soldiers of the Raj

    A History of the First World War in 100 moments

    A moment of glory on the Western Front for the soldiers of the Raj
    Judith Owen reveals how husband Harry Shearer - star of This Is Spinal Tap and The Simpsons - helped her music flourish

    Judith Owen: 'How my husband helped my music flourish'

    Her mother's suicide and father's cancer also informed the singer-songwriter's new album, says Pierre Perrone
    The online lifeline: How a housing association's remarkable educational initiative gave hope to tenant battling long-term illness and depression

    Online lifeline: Housing association's educational initiative

    South Yorkshire Housing Association's free training courses gave hope to tenant battling long-term illness and depression
    Face-recognition software: Is this the end of anonymity for all of us?

    Face-recognition software: The end of anonymity?

    The software is already used for military surveillance, by police to identify suspects - and on Facebook
    Train Kick Selfie Guy is set to scoop up to $250,000 thanks to his viral video - so how can you cash in on your candid moments?

    Viral videos: Cashing in on candid moments

    Train Kick Selfie Guy Jared Frank could receive anything between $30,000 to $250,000 for his misfortune - and that's just his cut of advertising revenue from being viewed on YouTube
    The world's fastest elevators - 20 metres per second - are coming soon to China

    World's fastest elevators coming soon to China

    Whatever next? Simon Usborne finds out from Britain's highest authority on the subject
    Cityfathers tackles long-hours culture that causes men to miss out on seeing their children

    Cityfathers tackles long-hours culture

    The organisation is the brainchild of Louisa Symington-Mills, a chief operating officer who set up Citymothers in 2012 - a group that now boasts more than 3,000 members
    Brits who migrate to Costa del Sol more unhappy than those who stay at home

    It's not always fun in the sun: Moving abroad does not guarantee happiness

    Brits who migrate to Costa del Sol more unhappy than those who stay at home
    Migrants in Britain a decade on: They came, they worked, they stayed in Lincolnshire

    Migrants in Britain a decade on

    They came, they worked, they stayed in Lincolnshire
    Chris Addison on swapping politics for pillow talk

    Chris Addison on swapping politics for pillow talk

    The 'Thick of It' favourite thinks the romcom is an 'awful genre'. So why is he happy with a starring role in Sky Living's new Lake District-set series 'Trying Again'?
    Why musicians play into their old age

    Why musicians play into their old age

    Nick Hasted looks at how they are driven by a burning desire to keep on entertaining fans despite risking ridicule
    How can you tell a gentleman?

    How can you tell a gentleman?

    A list of public figures with gallant attributes by Country Life magazine throws a fascinating light on what it means to be a gentleman in the modern world
    Pet a porter: posh pet pampering

    Pet a porter: posh pet pampering

    The duo behind Asos and Achica have launched a new venture offering haute couture to help make furry companions fashionable