Profile Books £9.99
What Darwin Got Wrong, By Jerry Fodor and Massimo Piattelli-Palmarini
Survival of the fittest...or just lucky?
Sunday 13 March 2011
This is a sustained, sophisticated assault on the central principle of Darwinism: that natural selection is the main driving force behind evolution.
It should be said immediately that there's no comfort for creationists here: the authors don't dispute the fact of evolution. They also don't dispute that natural selection occurs, but they argue that it cannot be the main explanation for the evolution of species. ("We think of natural selection as tuning the piano, not composing the melodies.")
The argument is in three parts. First, the authors analyse six similarities between natural selection and behaviourism. Behaviourism is now discredited as a theory of learning, so maybe natural selection should be too? (This is the least convincing part.) They then consider biological constraints: ontogeny limits the way that genes can express themselves as phenotypes; chemistry rules out certain kinds of mutation. In other words, mutations are not random. The third part is a conceptual attack on natural selection: how do we know which phenotypes were selected for, and which are "free riders" (that is, concomitants of phenotypes which were selected for)? To make such a distinction one must ascribe purpose to natural selection, which it doesn't have.
No replacement candidate for natural selection is offered. The authors suggest that multiple forces might drive evolution. I wasn't convinced by the argument, but I was stimulated and perplexed.
Books And it is whizzpopping!
MusicThey're running their own restaurants
Arts & Ents blogs
- 1 Kenya President Uhuru Kenyatta clashes with President Obama on LGBT equality: ‘Gay rights is really a non-issue’
- 2 Public anger after French sunbather beaten up by gang for wearing a bikini in Reims park
- 3 Mers outbreak: Manchester Royal Infirmary A&E closes over suspected cases
- 4 Jon Snow alive? New Game of Thrones toy line suggests he's not among the dead
- 5 Denmark bans kosher and halal slaughter as minister says ‘animal rights come before religion’
True Detective season 2, episode 6, 'Church in Ruins' review: Tension mounts just as time is running out
Chief Keef's 'Stop the Violence' hologram performance shut down by police
Listen! Beowulf opening line misinterpreted for 200 years
Jon Snow alive? New Game of Thrones toy line suggests he's not among the dead
I Am Cait reviews round-up: A fake, forced, boring reality TV series despite earnest intentions to help promote trans issues
The 9 charts that show the 'left-wing' policies of Jeremy Corbyn the public actually agrees with
Labour leadership contender Jeremy Corbyn says 'we can learn a great deal from Karl Marx'
The last thing Labour needs is a leader like Jeremy Corbyn who people want to vote for
What the Labour party could look like under Jeremy Corbyn
I am the Jeremy Corbyn supporter that many will tell you doesn't exist
Public anger after French sunbather beaten up by gang for wearing a bikini in Reims park