Welcome to the new Independent website. We hope you enjoy it and we value your feedback. Please contact us here.

Christmas details answers

The 1998 Christmas Details showed 16 points of light shining out of a surrounding darkness. Which paintings were they from? Many entries came close to identifying them all, but one devilish detail defeated all but a few: number 5, The Death of Lucretia, by that proto-photo-realist of the Baroque, Guido Cagnacci. It was variously guessed as Correggio, Leonardo, Etty, Courbet and GF Watts - but mostly as "?". Only 10 entrants got it, and they got all the others right as well. A case of champagne goes to Lilian and David Petty of Stockport; and a bottle each to A McKeegan of St Paul's Cray, Kent; Suzy Croft of London, SW11; and William Gallagher of Dublin.

1 Antonella da Messina: St Jerome in his Study (1475), National Gallery, London 2 Jacopo de' Barbari: Portrait of Luca Pacioli (1495), Museo di Capodimonte, Naples 3 Juan Snchez-Cotn: Still Life with Game, Fruit & Vegetables (1602), Prado, Madrid 4 Fra Bartolommeo: Portrait of Savonarola (1497), Museo di San Marco, Florence 5 Guido Cagnacci: The Death of Lucretia (1640), Musee des Beaux-Arts, Lyons 6 Manet: White Peonies with Secateurs (1864), Musee d'Orsay, Paris 7 Velzquez: Old Woman Cooking Eggs (1620), National Gallery of Scotland, Edinburgh 8 Jacques-Louis David: The Oath of the Horatii (1785), Louvre, Paris 9 Cezanne: The Black Clock (1870), Niarchos Collection, Paris 10 Goya: Portrait of Bartolome Sureda (1806), National Gallery of Art, Washington 11 Magritte: The Key of Dreams (1935), Collection Jasper Johns 12 Caravaggio: Narcissus (1598), Galleria del Arte Antica, Rome 13 Georges de la Tour: A Boy Blowing on a Firebrand (1650), Fuji Art Museum, Tokyo 14 Ingres: Portrait of Monsieur Bertin (1832), Louvre, but showing in National Gallery, London 15 Wright of Derby: Two Boys Fighting over a Bladder (1770), Private Collection 16 Picasso: Guernica (1937), Prado, Madrid