Album: Schubert, Die Schone Mullerin, (Orchid Classics)

Click to follow
The Independent Culture

James Gilchrist and Anna Tilbrook’s reading of Schubert’s earlier song cycle is more conventional than Padmore and Lewis’s Winterreise.

There’s a touching simplicity to Gilchrist’s delivery, though his tenor flutters under pressure and Tilbrook’s delicate, subtle accompaniment is too low in the mix. Most problematic is the lack of suspense: the jealous outburst of “Der Jäger” comes out of the blue, and though “Eifersucht und Stolz” and the “liebe/böse Farbe” songs are riveting, the narrator’s neurosis is revealed too late.