Faith & Reason: A religious traffic jam in Stamford Hill
The destruction of the Tower of Babel is, in our time, a deconstruction of the literalism that dogs modern views of religion. But what if diversity is a blessing rather than a burden?
Saturday 24 July 1999
Through the eyes of a guilty bystander, taught by the Jesuits to love their neighbour, Stamford Hill seems like religious pluralism on wheels. But apart from irritating traffic jams, in which the Hasidim's Volvos become beached like a shoal of stranded whales, what is the significance of this daily experience of religious diversity? Or, to be more theological, what does God mean by having all these religions bumping into each other with claims to be true that are clearly incompatible? Initiatives like the World Faiths Development Dialogue that seeks to combat global poverty and discuss a common inter-faith vision for human development suggest one possibility. But they rather prescind from the basic theological question.
One response to the "problem" - that is now mercifully relegated to narrow fundamentalist circles - is that this variety of religions is a man-made disaster brought on by sin; other religions are simply false. Yet a God who pretends to want everyone to be saved, and then decrees that "outside the Church there is no salvation", cannot be a God of love. The decree is, for example, a little hard on folks in Saudi Arabia. And what of all the generations who lived before the birth of Christ deprived of the means? By claiming that there is only one true religion this position simply does away with the "problem" of diversity altogether. Everything else is basically idolatry or ignorance.
Another answer, often well-intentioned but mildly offensive, is that religions are all much of a muchness. This is sometimes expressed in the argument that the core of all religions is the same; only the expression of the core truth is different. The mushy relativism that flourishes around this premise is justifiably condemned by the Vatican. For example, what Christians mean by "the Mystical Body of Christ" is not the same as what Muslims mean by the Umma. These ideas about "religious community" derive from different historical traditions in which they have a contextual meaning and different resonances. Their reduction to some common - essential and abstract - proposition out of the context of a lived faith produces vacuous nonsense for Christians and Muslims alike.
The Australian Catholic philosopher Max Charlesworth, in an essay entitled "The Diversity of Revelations", points a path between such extremes. He analyses two versions of a "Third Way". The first holds that by following their own spiritual path and truths people of different religious traditions are indeed saved or achieve enlightenment "though what is valuable in those traditions can be found in a much fuller and richer and explicit way in Christianity". The Jesuit theologian Karl Rahner's unfortunate phrase for such people in 1961 was "anonymous Christians". Not surprisingly this earned him some brickbats, though somewhat unfairly, since he was writing for a Christian audience, trying to move the debate forward into a fuller understanding of God's grace. He was largely successful and his views are not too distant from those of Pope John Paul II.
But Charlesworth thinks this will not do, since it measures all other religions in relation only to Christianity. It fails to acknowledge that God has "revealed aspects of `the divine' in other religious systems" and that authentic religious values, not found perhaps in Christianity, are found in other religions. The point that he wants to underline is that religious diversity has a positive meaning. The fullness of God's revelation will only be known when all the "revelations" found in the variety of the world religions "are brought together in some way and the jigsaw is completed".
The difficulty with his version of a "third way" is that it both allows the different world religions to assume their privileged status for their believers and does not allow any one revelation to claim itself as an exhaustive expression or revelation of God. So it may not satisfy anyone. It will be too radical for Rome, which fights shy of a "many paths to God" approach. And by allowing, say, Christianity or Islam to present itself for its believers as the paradigmatic way to God - though not the only way - it may also offend liberal sensibilities.
This would be a pity. Perhaps the French philosopher Jacques Derrida is right that God's "deconstruction" of the Tower of Babel is the story of the "deconstruction of the vain hope for literal and universal unity of meaning". We have to make do with fragmented stories. But in Stamford Hill we negotiate the post-modern fragments daily. It is incumbent on all religious leaders in a pluralist society to work out a simple practical model of how this might be done and thought about.
So I would be happy to recite the end of Max Charlesworth's creed: " I believe that religious diversity is in some sense willed by `God' and has its own intrinsic meaning and purpose and is not merely the result of sin and ignorance. I believe that respect for, openness to, and dialogue with, other religious traditions, must be part of any authentic religious tradition." Amen to that.
Final Top Gear reviewTV
Arts & Ents blogs
- 1 Nathan Collier: Montana man inspired by same-sex marriage ruling requests right to wed two wives
- 2 People all over the world are getting semicolon tattoos to draw attention to mental health
- 3 Van driver who comforted Clark Carlisle and called 999 after suicide attempt dies age 24
- 4 James Blunt was special guest on the highest-rating Top Gear episode ever
- 5 The biggest first date turnoff has been revealed
Nathan Collier: Montana man inspired by same-sex marriage ruling requests right to wed two wives
Greece crisis: IMF was pushed around by Angela Merkel and Nicholas Sarkozy – and now it is being humiliated
'I wish the BBC would stop calling it Islamic State' – David Cameron unleashes frustration at broadcaster
Forget little green men – aliens will look like humans, says Cambridge University evolution expert
Girl, 7, stares down hate preacher at Ohio festival with pro-LGBT rainbow flag gesture
Sickness and disability benefits could be reduced by £30 a week as part of £12bn welfare cuts