The Independent Film Forum: 2. The Reader
Our new film forum is your chance to pass judgement on a recent release. Here’s a selection of your views on Kate Winslet’s Oscar-nominated latest
Wednesday 18 February 2009
Cmartini25: Fantastic and moving. It made me change my opinion of Kate Winslet. The storyline grabbed me. The best Holocaust movie? No, ‘Schindler’s List’ gets that prize. But it’s a fantastic story, very well filmed.
Claudiaherwig:The alternating scenes of passion and Hanna’s sudden withdrawals rope you into this brilliant book. Unfortunately, the film doesn’t do it justice. It’s certainly not a bad film; Winslet’s performance is steady and believable and David Kross’s Michael comes quite close to his character in the book. It just felt incomplete.
Cellubefront: Should morality overcome the laws of an era when the imposed order is immoral? Yes, of course! That’s what the Nuremberg trials taught us, didn’t they? The diegetic formulation (a story about Germany told in English) subliminally calls for a trans-national reading whose moral implications are far greater and more painful than the viewer would like them to be.
Sebastian Hayes: The adaptation of the novel fudges the moral issues and turns it into a soap. Hanna’s illiteracy is a total non sequitur, there to get the spectator off the hook. The film should never be applauded – except for Winslet’s performance.
Johndhall:Undeniably moving, but it still comes across as the Holocaust played like ‘Summer of ’42’. Some questions are raised about the line between blind obedience and complicit evil, but it is, in the end, a weepie.
Bill: It has that air of thinking it’s a very good film, an ‘important’ film. But it’s not, it’s pretty ordinary. Ideas about German individuals’ responsibility for what happened during the war weren’t really explored. And the crucial hook about Hanna being too proud to admit she couldn’t read took over, and I just didn’t buy it. The acting is good but not great. And the directing felt safe and ordinary.
Is the comedy album making a comeback?comedy
Arts & Ents blogs
- 1 Secret Cinema: Why were Back to the Future screenings cancelled?
- 2 Christians: The world's most persecuted people
- 3 The secret report that helps Israelis to hide facts
- 4 Thatcher ‘was warned of Tory child sex party claims’
- 5 The Simpsons Family Guy trailer: First look at crossover episode after Comic-Con debut
Secret Cinema: Why were Back to the Future screenings cancelled?
Game of Thrones season 4 blooper reel unveiled at Comic-Con 2014
Fifty Shades of Grey trailer provokes moral backlash from US parenting groups
Best movies on Netflix UK and US: 32 films that will end your endless scrolling
Doctor Who series 8: Watch Peter Capaldi in new ‘Listen!’ teaser trailer
The secret report that helps Israelis to hide facts
A day in the life of Vladimir Putin: The dictator in his labyrinth
Were 'Poor Doors' added to mixed developments so wealthy residents don't have to go in alongside social housing tenants?
Arizona execution lasts two hours as killer Joseph Wood left 'snorting and gasping' for air
Opponents of Israel's military operation in Gaza are the real enemies of Middle Eastern peace
A new Russian revolution: The cracks are starting to appear in Putin’s Kremlin power bloc