Sony penalised for faking film 'blurbs'

Click to follow
The Independent Culture

Nine months after Sony Pictures was exposed for fabricating favourable reviews for its movie adverts, the studio came in for a critical drubbing yesterday from the legal authorities in Connecticut. After months of negotiations, the studio agreed to pay the state $326,000 (£230,000) in compensation for its unauthorised use of a small Connecticut weekly newspaper as a source of concocted movie blurbs.

"These deceptive ads deserve two thumbs-down," was the verdict of Connecticut's attorney general, Richard Blumenthal. "What Sony did was like having a chef pose as a food critic and then give his own restaurant four stars," James Fleming, the state's consumer protection commissioner said.

In the middle of last year, Sony repeatedly quoted a certain David Manning of the Ridgefield Press in Connecticut. He described Heath Ledger in A Knight's Tale as "this year's hottest new star!" Of Hollow Man, starring Kevin Bacon, he wrote: "One helluva scary ride! The summer's best special effects."

Although there is a Ridgefield Press, it has no film critic called David Manning, and was consulted about the quotations. The director of creative advertising at Sony, who was suspended for a month for his activities along with his direct superior, invented the quotes and came up with the name in honour of a college friend who worked in medical equipment marketing.

The mini-scandal, exposed by chance by a Newsweek reporter investigating promotional blurb, cast light on a number of questionable studio practices. Sony was one of a number of film companies subsequently caught using employees to promote films in audience-reaction video clips.

In Los Angeles, two film-goers were angry enough to file a class action suit against Sony, alleging intentional deception. That case is still pending.