Music: The rhythm kings
Drum and bass are at the heart of popular music and for 20 years Sly Dunbar and Robbie Shakespeare have been acknowledged the best. But who are their own favourites?
Friday 12 March 1999
Since then, they've manifested in a variety of guises: as members of Black Uhuru; as producers (they were behind Chaka Demus & Pliers' string of pop-reggae hits a few years back); as hired guns for artists from Grace Jones to Ian Dury; and as artists in their own right with a series of dubbed-out rhythm orgies culminating in their current Strip to the Bone, a dense, hallucinatory team-up with remix terrorist Howie B. As Black Uhuru lead singer Michael Rose used to chant, "Robbie Shakespeare hit you when you're near, Sly Dunbar hit you from afar".
Sly Dunbar defines "groove" as "a wicked, wicked drumbeat. If they can dance off of that, you add a bass to concrete it, to shape it into a song. If that a gwan, everything all right. A little guitar, a little keyboard ting pon it, like making a cake: different tastes to make it perfect".
So it seemed a reasonable notion to ask the Rhythm Killers who they regard as the champs in their field. Their nominations go something like this.
Motown rhythm section
James Jamerson (bass), Benny Benjamin (drums)
Robbie: Everything wha' dem do, the groove was right. Not really ever a bad song come out, everything was wicked, wicked, wicked.
Sly: If you check all the Motown songs, they always have a memorable bass-line. If you play 10 Motown songs, you remember the bass-lines. Any musical person could sing you the line: you remember the bass-line more than the lyric of the song.
Picks: Jr Walker: "Shotgun"; Temptations: "My Girl"; Miracles: "Get Ready"
Stax rhythm section
Donald `Duck' Dunn, replacing Lewis Steinberg, (bass), Al Jackson Jr (drums)
Sly: Al Jackson was the greatest recording drummer. When they were going to record (Bill Withers') "Ain't No Sunshine", which Booker T (below) produced, they'd just got a drum kit that day at the studio, and he took it out of the box and played it as is. All he did was tighten the snare. Another time he was playing live and the snare drum burst, so he just pulled over a tom-tom and started beating on that. Nobody even knew the snare drum had burst. For a drummer, if the snare goes, it's like everything has gone.
Robbie: Donald "Duck" Dunn was wicked, but I never know 'til lately that he was the one who played for Stax. I don't get to do my reading!
Picks: Booker T & the MGs: "Green Onions", "Time Is Tight'; Wilson Pickett: `In The Midnight Hour.'
Various Atlantic rhythm sections
Primarily Chuck Rainey (bass), Bernard `Pretty' Purdie (drums)
Sly: Bernard Purdie was wicked; he used to do all the (New York) Atlantic sessions with (producers) Jerry Wexler and Arif Mardin.
Robbie: Then there was the Muscle Shoals rhythm section. I don't know their names. I haven't done my research and I feel like a dummy.
Picks: Aretha Franklin: "Rock Steady"; Herbie Mann: Memphis Underground album
Various Channel One and Studio One rhythm sections
Including Boris Gardner (bass), Leroy `Horsemouth' Wallace (bass)
Sly: Credits don't really exist in Jamaica. You come to England and everybody know from word of mouth who played what in Jamaica! Credits started when (producer/bandleader) Bunny Lee put the name of the musicians on the record and it start from there. Somebody come from England and know everyt'ing 'bout every music, who play what on what. We say, "Wha'? Me na know!" Before that it was "backed by the Bunny Lee All-Stars" or "the Joe Gibbs All-Stars". Who is "All-Stars"?
Pick: Heptones: "Why Did You Leave Me To Cry"
Bob Marley & the Wailers
Aston `Family Man' Barrett (bass), Carlton `Carlie' Barrett (drums)
Sly: Carlie had a style like nobody else. He did some things when he played a roll, it was just inside. When they play a wicked song, you know it's a wicked song. So much groove when they played!
Picks: "Duppy Conqueror", "Crazy Baldhead"
Paul McCartney (bass), Ringo Starr (drums)
Sly: Paul McCartney and Ringo Starr, they proved themselves from time. They really have a track record.
Pick: "A Hard Day's Night"
The Rolling Stones
Bill Wyman (bass), Charlie Watts (drums)
Sly: Charlie Watts? Wickedest drummer!
John Entwistle (bass), Keith Moon (drums)
Sly: Keith Moon was great, especially when performing live, yunno. When he died, they never was The Who again.
Robbie: I never know the bass player's name, but I love his style.
Pick: "See Me, Feel Me" (from Tommy, as performed live at Woodstock)
Sly & The Family Stone
Larry Graham (bass), Greg Errico (drums)
Sly: Wicked, man, wicked, man. Awesome. Cosmic.
Pick: "Sing A Simple Song"
George Porter (bass), Joseph `Zigaboo' Modeliste (drums)
Sly: The wickedest rhythm section.
Robbie: When I was young I used to listen to them.
Sly: And I'd think, "How can we copy them?" And nobody could. That rhythm section was so unorthodox - in a class by itself.
James Brown rhythm sections, including Bootsy Collins (bass), Clyde Stubblefield (drums)
Sly: We asked Bootsy to play some funk for us, to play "Sex Machine", and he was playing the guitar part too!
Robbie: Bootsy played guitar for us on "Boops" and the albums Rhythm Killers and Language Barrier.
Pick: "Sex Machine"
Jaco Pastorius (bass), Peter Erskine (drums)
Sly: That's my jazz rhythm section!
Robbie: He did things nobody had ever done on the bass. We were on a tour of Japan and he was on it. You think Jaco would have a fancy bass? One old Fender bass. He was the one who took out the frets, said he couldn't afford a fretless bass.
Sly: Them harmonics things he played, I never heard nobody play. A full song, harmonic style.
And, of course...
Robbie Shakespeare (bass), Sly Dunbar (drums)
Sly: The wickedest Sly & Robbie groove for all time is (Grace Jones's) "Pull Up To The Bumper" and "Boops".
Robbie: A Black Uhuru song, "Fit You Haffe Fit".
Sly: What drummer could play that? Totally different between the snare and the foot drum.
Sly and Robbie's `Strip to the Bone' is out on Palm Pictures
Maisie Williams single-handedly rises to the challengeTV
Arts & Ents blogs
- 1 Saudi preacher who 'raped and tortured' his five -year-old daughter to death is released after paying 'blood money'
- 2 The awkward moment Sarah Palin raised $25,000 for Hillary Clinton's election campaign
- 3 Ball pool for adults opens in London
- 4 Amal Clooney gives excellent response to fashion question at European Court of Human Rights
- 5 Baldness could soon be treated using stem cells, scientists hope
The Jump 2015 line-up: Joey Essex, Mike Tindall, Jodie Kidd and co take to the slopes
Heavy metal producer's corpse to be mutilated by models as per his dying wish
Game of Thrones, season 5: Grey Worm actor Jacob Anderson is all for more male nudity – as long as he can keep his clothes on
Thrill of the chaste: The truth about Gandhi's sex life
Martin Scorsese 'in shock' after death on set of new film Silence
9 reasons Greece's experiment with the radical left is doomed to failure
'We would evict Queen from Buckingham Palace and allocate her council house,' say Greens
Have we reached 'peak food'? Shortages loom as global production rates slow
Greece elections: Syriza and EU on collision course after election win for left-wing party
British grandmother Lindsay Sandiford faces execution by firing squad in Indonesia
Liberal Democrat minister defends comments suggesting immigration causes pub closures