Stay up to date with notifications from The Independent

Notifications can be managed in browser preferences.

Album: Gail Ann Dorsey

I Used to Be..., SAD BUNNY

Andy Gill
Friday 19 November 2004 01:00 GMT
Comments

What a huge disappointment this is. About a decade and a half ago, Gail Ann Dorsey released a brilliant debut album called The Corporate World, which showcased her diverse talents as singer and multi-instrumentalist across a range of styles, in sharp, articulate songs whose titles - "Wasted Country", "Corporate World" - indicated their charged political tenor. When that album and a 1992 follow-up effort failed to ignite popular interest, she retreated to the safety of session and tour work, most recently as David Bowie's long-term bassist. This belated third solo album, sadly, has none of the bite and brilliance of her debut, being comprised instead of mawkish love songs, ponderous piano ballads and personal-growth platitudes ranging from the bluntly clichéd "You've got to stand, you've got to fight" to the just plain risible "I have the spirit of an eagle/ I have the soul of an angel". It's desperately poor, with no trace of a memorable melody, offering instead the kind of funk-lite acc

What a huge disappointment this is. About a decade and a half ago, Gail Ann Dorsey released a brilliant debut album called The Corporate World, which showcased her diverse talents as singer and multi-instrumentalist across a range of styles, in sharp, articulate songs whose titles - "Wasted Country", "Corporate World" - indicated their charged political tenor. When that album and a 1992 follow-up effort failed to ignite popular interest, she retreated to the safety of session and tour work, most recently as David Bowie's long-term bassist. This belated third solo album, sadly, has none of the bite and brilliance of her debut, being comprised instead of mawkish love songs, ponderous piano ballads and personal-growth platitudes ranging from the bluntly clichéd "You've got to stand, you've got to fight" to the just plain risible "I have the spirit of an eagle/ I have the soul of an angel". It's desperately poor, with no trace of a memorable melody, offering instead the kind of funk-lite accompaniment that "proper" musicians end up playing if there's no producer around to marshall their talents. Tracks like "Magical" hint at the expansive, jazzy ruminations favoured by Joni Mitchell - except there's no comparable depth of insight. And frankly, one doubts whether Mitchell would have let a phrase like "a mystic parade of desires" slip through her quality-control net.

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

Comments

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in