Music

Rain (AM and PM) 7° London Hi 9°C / Lo 7°C

Album: Robbie Williams, Reality Killed the Video Star (EMI)

(Rated 3/ 5 )

Reviewed by Andy Gill

Robbie Williams' albums have increasingly come to focus upon the singer himself, which has consequently made them less and less appealing to those not entirely smitten with his charms.

By 2006's Rudebox, with its songs about Robbie growing up in the Eighties and growing bitter in the Nineties, this was proving counter-productive, the album being regarded as under-performing, commercially. As he observes here in the opening "Morning Sun", "a message to the troubadour: the world don't love you anymore". The song was supposedly written about Michael Jackson shortly after the singer's death, but as Williams noted during his Electric Proms comeback show, "I thought it was about [him], but it's actually about me again".

Certainly, there's no avoiding the obvious self-referentiality of the album title, which puns on producer Trevor Horn's pivotal Buggles hit "Video Killed The Radio Star" to suggest how all-singing, all-dancing video stars like Williams have been supplanted in the pop industry by the rapid turnover of ruthlessly-drilled reality-show contestants – despite their being ultimately traceable to manufactured boy-bands like, well, Take That. And it's hard to read the brief "Somewhere" as anything but an autobiographical reflection on Robbie's lengthy, lonely, lost weekend in the LA wilderness, with its rueful advice to "take your chance in life, go out and find a wife, don't get stuck in the state that I'm in".

But elsewhere on Reality Killed the Video Star, the signs are that the now-married singer has regained his waning zest. Though less experimental than Rudebox, it's more accomplished and generous-spirited. Its predecessor's Pet Shop Boys electropop stylings are restricted to a few tracks such as "Last Days Of Disco" and "Difficult For Weirdos", a reminiscence of the stubborn courage required to glam-up publicly during the New Romantic era, while elsewhere the mainstream musical influences are as tried and tested as the Elton-style plodder "You Know Me" and the Beatle-esque strings draped over "Morning Sun".

Robbie being Robbie, of course, there are a few curiosities disturbing the smooth surfaces conjured up by Horn, not least the fatalistic, twitchy techno single "Bodies", with its references to "decay and entropy" and "bodies in the cemetery" and its choir chanting "Jesus didn't die for you/me" – a line one might have expected in "Blasphemy", the last song Williams co-wrote with Guy Chambers. Here, to a chamber-pop setting of piano, oboe and strings, he trots out a few typically tactless references to senile dementia, the deaf and dumb, and the Great Depression, perhaps to justify the terrible pun "Is it a blast for you? 'Cos it's blasphemy!". Older, then, but wiser...?

Download this: Morning Sun; Bodies; Difficult For Weirdos

Post a Comment

View all comments that have been posted about this article.

Offensive or abusive comments will be removed and your IP logged and may be used to prevent further submission. In submitting a comment to the site, you agree to be bound by the Independent Minds Terms of Service.

Comments

Tom Vjestica
[info]tom_v87 wrote:
Friday, 6 November 2009 at 12:34 am (UTC)
This is the type of album that should be given away free with a 30p paper!
Robbie's decline
[info]ronster1959 wrote:
Saturday, 7 November 2009 at 01:01 am (UTC)
Robbie's return to stardom? Lets employ Trevor Horn and Anne Dudley, both massive stars as producers, arrangers et al in the 1980s. Yes, in the 1980s. Robbie was in his mid teens, enjoying The Lexicon Of Love and Welcome To The Pleasure Dome and now, twenty years later and everything '80s really hot (fashion, for instance), he thought: I'll give Trevor a call. Horn, of course, was thrilled. Together with Dudley and under strict rules from EMI, they sat and pondered over which way to go. A bit of Beatles? Sure. Something Bowie (but, please, not his Berlin period - too risky)? Why not? And do we perhaps have some Guy Chambers leftovers from old albums? Most certainly. Wow, that all sounds like a new album. Forget about being filthy rich and being able to do whatever you want. It's about selling more than last time's 3.6 million concert tickets. It's about being a star. I actually feel bad for Robbie. He's a genuinely nice bloke with a good sense of humour. But after seeing him pretty nervous on Jonathan Ross and hearing about his girl, his desire for kids, his getting back to normal, I just got sick. I fully understand girls who grew up with Robbie were fifteen then and twenty-five now and are starting to desire a family, so from a marketing point of view it makes sense of course. But I'm sure it's not what Robbie wants to do. He wants to be free to do whatever he likes. "Bodies" is easily the most adventurous song on the new album and releasing it as the first single will be the only good thing to be remembered about the album. Four years from now, his target audience (then approaching thirty and dying for a child), will still be talking about "Feel" and "Angels". Sad, but true. My advice: Make your own version of "Metal Machine Music" and wave goodbye to the past. Avanti!

Most popular in Arts & Entertainment

Article Archive

Day In a Page

Sun | Mon | Tue | Wed | Thu | Fri | Sat

Select date