Bamberg Symphony Orchestra/Nott/Tetzlaff, Usher Hall, Edinburgh
Thursday 01 September 2005
The Bamberg Symphony Orchestra is of the latter kind. It would be hard for the players not to respond to the spacious, precise, thrilling gestures of Jonathan Nott. There are no astonishing soloists, no moments of eye-opening magic. But the spontaneity - amounting to a wild abandon in the second movement of Mahler's Fifth Symphony - and the leap and lilt of rhythms, the generous breadth of the cadences, the fire that smoulders and blazes, these come from Nott's lucid imagination.
He has credentials also in modern music. This concert began with Ligeti's Violin Concerto, played by Christian Tetzlaff. It's really a chamber work, using a small group of players for a mixture of iridescence and rhetoric. With its out-of-tune strings, its fishy-sounding ocarinas, it joins galactic mystery to a childlike quality, notably in the second movement, which Tetzlaff began with naive simplicity, trawling a weary melody out of some distant century. Nott and his soloist managed to locate the piece in a unique, undiscovered, expressive space.
You would have thought that the addition of a starry line-up of singers, the following evening, would have given us a truly great experience. But this concert performance of Wagner's Tristan und Isolde was unsatisfactory. Christine Brewer is a great Isolde, and Christian Franz, the Tristan, is an artist of taste and dramatic force, with a mettlesome heroic tenor. Brewer's limitless flow of creamy tone, her supreme mastery of every phrase and range, should have done the trick. But she was inflexible, unvaried, seeming sometimes ill at ease. Franz, on the other hand, was apparently unwell. The tone became increasingly husky. His careful pacing of the role, conserving his voice, eventually left little to enjoy, though his vocal acting in Act III was impressive.
Jane Irwin was a handsome, generous Brangäne who aptly caught Isolde's stormy emotion, John Relyea a noble and tragic Mark, Juha Uusitalo a weighty Kurwenal.
Nott kept the performance moving, especially in self-indulgent numbers such as the great love duet and the Liebestod. There were some exciting moments, typical of Nott, such as the feverish turmoil as Tristan imagined that Isolde was coming to Kareol. But sometimes the singers felt hustled, and the orchestra sounded bored.
With so many excellences, this performance should have added up to something very special. Yet it retained some of the problems of many concert performances; ultimately, it felt like a bundle of top people flown in from all over the world who did not fully meet as a dramatic cast.
GlastonburyWI to make debut appearance at Somerset festival
TV reviewIt has taken seven episodes for Game of Thrones season five to hit its stride
FilmPalme d'Or goes to radical and astonishing film that turns conventional thinking about immigrants on its head
Arts & Ents blogs
- 1 Man on naked bike ride gets ejected after becoming aroused
- 2 Fifa corruption: Europe plots to stage an 'alternative World Cup' in place of Russia 2018
- 3 How much sex should I be having?
- 4 Jaden Smith wears gender fluid dress to high school prom with Hunger Games actress
- 5 Betting company 'refuse to pay' after student wins £1,000 from 50p bet on Roger Federer
The 1975 leave social-media after tweeting cryptic comic strip hinting at break up
Britain's Got Talent 2015 final: Winner Matisse had secret dog double, says owner Jules O'Dwyer
Britain's Got Talent 2015 final: Vote reveals Jules O'Dwyer beat Jamie Raven by just 2% despite using 'stunt dog double'
Top Gear to follow Have I Got News For You format with 'different host for each episode'
Britain's Got Talent final 2015: Ofcom receives 90 complaints about Alesha Dixon and Amanda Holden's 'revealing dresses'
Migrants in Kos: Photos show real tragedy after Brits abroad complain of 'awkward' holidays
British tourists complain that impoverished boat migrants are making holidays 'awkward' in Kos
Michael Gove determined to scrap the Human Rights Act – even if Scotland retains it
Thousands of teenage girls enduring debilitating illnesses after routine school cancer vaccination
Threat to scrap Human Rights Act could see UK follow Nazi example, warns UN official
Why this year's general election was the most unfair in Britain's history