London Sinfonietta / Bbc Singers: Birtwistle's 'Neruda Madrigales', Concert Hall, Snape Maltings
Tuesday 21 June 2005
Sir Harrison Birtwistle's demeanour was characteristically humble in a pre-performance talk at the premiere of Neruda Madrigales, his setting of a poem by Pablo Neruda for chorus, woodwind, percussion, and strings. He told us how he had chanced upon a translation of Neruda's "Double Autumn", and, fired by the way the words were laid out like a column on the page, he'd decided to set them to music even before absorbing what they were about. His music would not so much follow the poem, as be "about" it, he explained.
But at the performance, as his voices and instruments built to their first massed blast, one remembered that behind the surface humility lay Napoleonic compositional arrogance. The doom-laden chord that suffused the auditorium set up echoes of Stravinsky's Oedipus Rex and Symphony of Psalms: this was the music of monumental immobility, in elegiac mood.
The sopranos flew high, the basses very low; the briefly heard harp seemed dusky and sinister; occasional solo voices broke through the wall of sound. But even when they did, few words were intelligible: moreover, the alternation between instrumental settings and chorales promised in the programme-note was hard to discern. At just one point - when the text spoke of a tree being felled - music and words came together in a spasm of spectacular violence, but for the most part they formed an undifferentiated miasma.
The piece was most effective when the voices receded into the background and the instruments took over, playing those subtle textural games that are Birtwistle's speciality.
But Neruda's poem is a tour de force, in which ideas and images make their own marvellous music: delivered here as a prelude, first in English then in Spanish, it showed up Birtwistle's piece for the bombast it is. But as his music is routinely supported by promotional exegesis from friendly critics, the bandwagon will roll on. And he'll go on getting devoted performances, as here from the London Sinfonietta and BBC Singers.
The other works in the concert rammed home the limitations of this piece. Each of Stravinsky's Russian Peasant Songs packed more punch in one minute than Birtwistle did in 25. And Monteverdi's searing "Zefiro Torno" reminded us what a real madrigal could do.
To be broadcast on BBC Radio 3 tomorrow at 7.30pm
elephant appealThe first 23 lots in our charity auction have now gone. But there are 22 more still up for grabs
musicPolice chief rejects rappers' claims that his work is as dangerous as law enforcement or military service
comedy'Fresh Meat' star sees off stiff competition from Alan Carr, David Mitchell, Graham Norton, Lee Mack and Sarah Millican to win top prize
Beatles rush out 'bootleg' album to defy EU copyright law
healthJames Bond's alcohol consumption puts him at 'high risk' of cirrhosis, tremors... and impotence
tvSpoiler alert: Find out the result of a heated final show
Harvey Weinstein reveals his secret weapon on-set
Now that an oil trader's drinking has got him sacked, will we all have to make do with an afternoon latte?
Chiwetel Ejiofor and Idris Elba get nods for Best Actor, which no black Brit has ever won
Geoffrey Macnab reviews The Desolation of Smaug - the meat in Peter Jackson's Hobbit sandwich
peopleWhat advice would David Cameron give to his younger self?
Arts & Ents blogs
Jack Whitehall crowned king of British Comedy Awards
The Hobbit: The Desolation Of Smaug review
MasterChef: The Professionals 2013 - Steven Edwards, Adam Handling and Scott Davies are the final three
MasterChef: The Professionals 2013 - Steven Edwards crowned winner
Kanye West is as 'misguided as they come': Ohio police chief rejects rapper's claims that his work is as dangerous as law enforcement or military service
- 1 French café starts charging extra to rude customers
- 2 Sun will 'flip upside down' within weeks, says Nasa
- 3 Australia incest case: Deformed children found in remote farming community after generations of inbreeding
- 4 Physicists discover 'clearest evidence yet' that the Universe is a hologram
- 5 Fox News presenter tells viewers it is a 'fact' that both Jesus and Santa Claus are white
- < Previous
- Next >