Manon Lescaut, Grand Theatre, Leeds
Thursday 30 September 2004
The story of Manon, at least in its familiar operatic versions, is something of a mystery. In Abbé Prévost's original, it is Des Grieux's own tale of romantic obsession with an elusive but irresistibly attractive girl. He projects his passion onto her.
But bring this wraith to the stage, and the magic easily evaporates. She seems weak and vapid. She is torn between her love for Des Grieux and her appetite for wealth and glamour. Even when, in Puccini's version, her lover comes to rescue her from her life of affluent boredom with the elderly Geronte, she dithers over her jewellery and the chance of escape is lost. You almost expect someone to call out: "Leave 'er - she's not werf it."
Last year, Daniel Slater did Massenet's Manon for Opera North. This year, it is Puccini's turn. His Italianate version makes for an exciting evening, but the four acts he took from his army of librettists make an elaborate story even less intelligible. We see nothing of Des Grieux's and Manon's idyll of love together. The first act, in which he abducts her, is followed by the rescue, in which she has already left him in favour of the rich old Geronte. To make sense of this opera, you need to know what happens between the acts.
Slater kept Massenet's version in the 18th century. He sets Puccini's in France at the time of its liberation 60 years ago. This works quite well, and gives the piece an unusual immediacy. The first act takes place not at an inn but at Amiens train station. Lescaut (Christopher Purves), Manon's brother, is still in uniform. Geronte (Brian Bannatyne-Scott), who plans to abduct Manon himself, wears an expensive coat with a fur collar. He looks to have done well out of the occupation. Des Grieux (Hugh Smith) is a big country bumpkin.
In the second act Manon's boredom is immediately apparent. Lescaut has transformed himself into a sporty man about town. She is ogled by Geronte's rich old friends. Of course she misses Des Grieux's youth and ardour. And it is hard to imagine them better conveyed than by Hugh Smith, who is magnificent in the role - passionate, eloquent, but full of variety and sensitivity, the most Italianate singing of the evening.
As Manon, Natalia Dercho looked suitably demure in Act 1, but sounded too mature to be a plausible young girl. Perhaps nerves played a part, for she sounded uncertain in Act 2 as well. By the end, though, she had risen to the tragedy of Manon's miserable deportation and death, and she and Smith did the long duet of the last act splendidly.
Hugh Smith was the evening's vocal star; the other star was in the pit. The orchestra played superbly for its new music director, Richard Farnes, who directed a performance which had clarity and careful balance as well as passion and momentum.
To 8 October (0113-222 6222), then touring to Newcastle, Salford, Leeds again and Nottingham
Robin Thicke admits he didn't write 'Blurred Lines'music
Review: Cilla, ITV TV
Arts & Ents blogs
- 1 Thailand beach murders: Thai PM suggests 'attractive' female tourists cannot expect to be safe wearing bikinis
- 2 Scottish independence: Five reasons Salmond is secretly hoping for a 'No' vote
- 3 Isis plan to 'behead random member of the public' in Sydney thwarted by Australian police
- 4 Scottish independence: Andy Murray backs Yes campaign in eleventh hour decision
- 5 Have you heard about the film Singapore has banned its people from watching? Well, you have now
Laurie Lee's Rosie: What is it like to inspire a writer's work and be immortalised forever on the page?
Metal detectors object to digs by Mackenzie Crook about ‘dysfunctional’ hobby in BBC4's 'Detectorists'
Doctor Who series 8: Time Heist pictures revealed ahead of episode 5
The Walking Dead season 5 air date, trailer and season 4 recap
Star Wars 7 leaked set photo of Adam Driver changes everything
Daniele Watts: Django Unchained actress detained by Los Angeles police after being mistaken for a prostitute
Scottish independence referendum: A nation divided against itself
The political class is doing what Hitler couldn’t – destroying Britain
Scottish independence: Nationalist leader Jim Sillars threatens pro-union companies with 'day of reckoning' after independence
Portuguese academic says British are 'filthy, violent and drunk'
Scottish independence: David Cameron is becoming the 'George Bush of Britain'