Proms CITY OF BIRMINGHAM SYMPHONY ORCHESTRA / SIR SIMON RATTLE Royal Albert Hall, London / BBC Radio 3
Writer and broadcaster Edward Seckerson is Chief Classical Music and Opera Critic for The Independent. He wrote and presented the long-running BBC Radio 3 series Stage & Screen, in which he interviewed many of the most prominent writers and stars of musical theatre. He appears regularly on BBC Radio 3 and 4. On television, he has commentated a number of times at the Cardiff Singer of the World competition. He has published books on Mahler and the conductor Michael Tilson Thomas, and has been on Gramophone Magazine's review panel for many years. Edward presented the 2007 series of the Radio 4 music quiz Counterpoint. He has interviewed everyone from Leonard Bernstein to Liza Minelli; from Paul McCartney to Pavarotti: from Julie Andrews to Jessye Norman.
Monday 31 July 1995
Mahler's Sixth Symphony. And so the terrible ordeal began again. Nowhere in the history of Western music does man strive so high, only to be brought so low. I like Donald Mitchell's assertion that, after Strauss's Death and Transfiguration, Mahler's finale might be entitled Death and Extinction. Rattle has been this way before - many times. He's lived and died this symphony for nearly two decades now. And perhaps he has journeyed far enough in time and space from Mahler's own superstitions to be able to reinstate the third and final hammer blow.
To hear it in situ, sounding disturbingly as though another crack had just appeared in our universe, is to understand why Mahler deleted it. Rattle's percussionist turned it into a threefold ritual: a black cloth ceremoniously laid down on the sound-box, the hammer raised and swung like a vengeful Thor. Mahler's acute sense of the grotesque was duly satisfied. And, in response, the CBSO brass resoundingly laid bare his blackest counterpoint.
It was, in a word, stupendous. There isn't a note of text here that Rattle hasn't digested, re-evaluated, understood - the musical reasons, revelations, revolutions. The evolution of Alma's theme - the first movement's second subject, sung in the strings, shouted in unison clarinets (bells raised high over the music-stands), embellished in descanting horns (the entire first movement development is about the aspirations of this theme) - was never clearer or more poignant. Its final bid for the ascendancy in that great climactic chord of the coda (like a giant suspension heard in slow motion) was truly all-consuming. But then, everywhere harmonies were newly revealed, textures re-opened, colours re-primed (what galaxy does that opening paragraph of the finale come from?).
There remains one contentious issue: the ordering of the middle movements. Evidence exists to suggest that Mahler did revert to his original ordering - Scherzo-Andante - before his death. But Rattle remains unshakeable in his belief that Andante-Scherzo is the right musical sequence and, as ever, his arguments (centred on harmonic structure) are compelling. I happen not to agree. To take that terrible plunge from the first movement's triumphant A major back into the minor, to have to surrender once more to a distorted mirror-image of the first movement's dogged march, is to experience one of the most daring and uncompromising instances of sustained terrorism in all music. Could it be that Mahler simply lost his nerve prior to the premiere? I must say that, as Rattle's violins eased their way into the consoling opening measures of the Andante, I felt a little as though - for once, and once only - we'd been let off the hook.
Review: Imaginative storytelling returns with vigourfilm
Bannatyne leaves Dragon's DenTV
Arts & Ents blogs
- 2 Loom bands: Bids for dress made from colourful rubber pass £170,000 on eBay
- 3 Why I'm on the brink of burning my Israeli passport
- 4 L'Oreal cuts ties with Belgium supporter Axelle Despiegelaere after hunting trip photographs
- 5 The true Gaza back-story that the Israelis aren’t telling this week
Sustained immigration has not harmed Britons' employment, say government advisers
War is war: Why I stand with Israel
7/7 memorial defaced on anniversary of 2005 attacks with ‘Blair lied thousands died’ graffiti
Australia facing international condemnation after turning around Sri Lankans at sea
Even when it brutalises one of its own teenage citizens, America is helpless against Israel
Socialist Worker called to apologise over ‘vile’ article saying Eton schoolboy Horatio Chapple's death is ‘reason to save the polar bears’