Should we keep our secrets?

The American approach satisfied the right to know and allows for the correction of mistakes

WHAT RECORDS should the Security Service, or MI5 as it is often called, keep for eventual release into the public domain? This question, important on constitutional grounds as well as historical, is being looked at afresh by a committee of which I am a member.

Actually we have a rather grand title: the Lord Chancellor's Advisory Council on Public Records. Our normal task is to police the working of the "30-year Rule" under which government records are made available for inspection at the Public Record Office when they are 30 years old.

Now we have been asked by the Home Secretary, Jack Straw, to review the criteria which the Service currently applies in deciding whether files which would otherwise be destroyed should be kept on grounds of historical significance. We would welcome submissions from those with an interest in the subject; it is important to know what people think.

The point about MI5 is that it works primarily in the United Kingdom. Its current work is to investigate terrorism (especially in Northern Ireland), to protect the UK against espionage by foreign intelligence agencies, to help counter the proliferation of weapons of mass destruction and to support the police in the fight against serious crime. However, the part of its remit that raises the most acute problems for the historic record has been its work against so-called subversive organisations of the extreme left or extreme right which, often working behind a respectable facade, were thought to be trying to undermine parliamentary democracy.

This accounted for a major part of the Security Service's activities between 1948, the start of the Cold War, and 1990 when the Soviet Union collapsed. That is why, although anti-subversion work is no longer undertaken, the service holds 290,000 files relating to individuals, among them it is supposed, folders for "Straw, Jack: president of the National Union of Students" and "Mandelson, Peter: trades union official".

The first problem which confronts us is the service's instinctive reluctance to put anything at all into the public domain. Thus the only files which are available at the Public Record Office cover the period from its foundation in 1909 to 1919.

They are, apparently, very bland. However by the millennium it is hoped that material covering the inter-war years and the Second World War will have been released. In short, MI5 will have improved from keeping its files closed for 80 years to a mere 55 years.

Moreover, the service periodically destroys files on a massive scale. This happened following both world wars and again in the early 1990s. The result is that it has preserved about 60 per cent of its records, whereas the Foreign Office, for instance, keeps about 80 per cent of its files and the Cabinet Office and 10 Downing Street retain almost everything. The saving grace is that MI5 has at least preserved its registers, so it will be possible one day to know what was once available if now lost.

The Advisory Council will have to evaluate MI5's arguments for non-disclosure. Like all intelligence services, it feels an absolute duty to protect the identity of its agents or informers. And it sees this duty as extending for long after the agent has ceased working for the Service and possibly after his or her death if family members remain vulnerable. For operational reasons, it keeps the identities of its staff secret, except that in recent years the name of the director general has been published.

It also argues that premature release can put innocent people in a dubious light. And it wants to keep its techniques under wraps because suspects are generally unaware, even if they assume that they are being watched, of how unwittingly they let slip incriminating information. Espionage is like archaeology, putting together fragments to form an impression of the whole.

The question for us is whether these perfectly reasonable considerations are being applied too cautiously in relation to the purpose of disclosure, which is to allow historians and members of the public to understand in a reasonably timely way how the organisation was managed, financed, structured and operated; how it influenced and was influenced by the social, economic and physical culture of which it was part; how decisions were taken and what those decisions were and how they were applied.

The second big question is what retention and disclosure policy is appropriate for the service's huge holding of files on British people, on us. There is substantial and justifiable interest in the interaction between a secret service and the citizen; equally, however, it is scarcely conceivable that personal files could be released during the lifetime of the subject.

Of the 290,000 personal files extant, all but 20,000 of them are closed in the sense that while Security Service officers may consult them, no further enquiries are undertaken on their subjects. Many of these will contain limited information - that "X" is or was a member of, say, the Communist Party together with the proof. No further action will have been taken and there will be thus no private or intrusive information on the file.

There are two ways to go. There is the example of the United States where you may apply to a "freedom of information" officer at the FBI or CIA and ask whether there is a file on you. Subject to safeguards for current investigations, you will be told "yes" or "no" and if the answer is "yes" you will be informed how many pages it comprises, how much is classified and how much you may examine if you so desire. And there is a right of appeal to see the classified material. This approach has two virtues - it satisfies a democratic right to know whether there is a file and it allows for the correction of mistakes and misapprehensions.

The alternative way is to ask what should be known of MI5's investigation of UK citizens from the point of view of the historic record. On whom did the service have files? What sort of people were targets? How did it operate against those targets? What did the files contain? Was the information accurate? What did the service do with what it learnt?

Then, having established the questions, the next consideration would be whether keeping a sample of files would be sufficient to enable authoritative answers to be given. If the answer were in the affirmative, then a policy, perhaps less haphazard than the present arrangements, albeit opposite to the American system, could be proposed.

So far as personal files are concerned, they would only be kept for operational reasons, or for the historic record, or for meeting complaints made to the Security Service Tribunal. If none of these considerations pertained, then the file would be destroyed.

In other words, the argument here is that destruction may be a safeguard for individual liberties. That is perhaps the most difficult question which the Advisory Council, sitting under the chairmanship of the Master of the Rolls, Lord Woolf, will have to decide.

Submissions should be made as soon as possible to Tim Padfield, Secretary of the Advisory Council on Public Records, Public Record Office, Kew, Richmond, Surrey TW9 4DU

Suggested Topics
Arts and Entertainment
TV
Arts and Entertainment
Tony breaks into Ian Garrett's yacht and makes a shocking discovery
TVReview: Revelations continue to make this drama a tough watch
Arts and Entertainment

books
Arts and Entertainment
The party's over: Paul Higgins and Stella Gonet in 'Hope' at the Royal Court

theatre
Arts and Entertainment
Brendan O'Carroll as Agnes Brown in the 2014 Mrs Brown's Boys Christmas special

Broadcaster unveils Christmas schedule

TV
PROMOTED VIDEO
Arts and Entertainment
Look out: Broad shoulders take Idris Elba’s DCI John Luther a long way
tvIdris Elba will appear in two special episodes for the BBC next year
Arts and Entertainment
Taylor Swift is dominating album and singles charts worldwide

music
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?
Arts and Entertainment

ebooksNow available in paperback
Arts and Entertainment

ebooks
Arts and Entertainment
Kieron Richardson plays gay character Ste Hay in Channel 4 soap Hollyoaks

tv
Arts and Entertainment
Midge Ure and Sir Bob Geldof outside the Notting Hill recording studios for Band Aid 30

music
Arts and Entertainment
Jake Quickenden and Edwina Currie are joining the I'm A Celebrity...Get Me Out Of Here! camp
tvThe two new contestants will join the 'I'm A Celebrity' camp after Gemma Collins' surprise exit
News
The late Jimmy Ruffin, pictured in 1974
people
News
Northern Uproar, pictured in 1996
people

Jeff Fletcher found fame in 1990s

Arts and Entertainment
A scene from the new Paddington bear review

Review: Paddingtonfilm
Arts and Entertainment
Tony stares at the 'Daddy Big Ears' drawing his abducted son Oliver drew for him in The Missing
tvReview: But we're no closer to the truth in 'The Missing'
Arts and Entertainment
Henry Marsh said he was rather 'pleased' at the nomination
booksHenry Marsh's 'Do No Harm' takes doctors off their pedestal
Arts and Entertainment
All in a day's work: the players in the forthcoming 'Posh People: Inside Tatler'

tv
Arts and Entertainment
Eddie Redmayne plays Stephen Hawking in new biopic The Imitation Game

'At times I thought he was me'

film
Arts and Entertainment

books
Arts and Entertainment
One Direction go Fourth: The boys pose on the cover of their new album Four

Review: One Direction, Four

music
Arts and Entertainment
'Game of Thrones' writer George RR Martin

Review: The World of Ice and Fire

books
Arts and Entertainment
Sean Bean will play 'extraordinary hero' Inspector John Marlott in The Frankenstein Chronicles
tvHow long before he gets killed off?
Arts and Entertainment
Some like it hot: Blaise Bellville

music
Arts and Entertainment
A costume worn by model Kate Moss for the 2013 photograph

art
Arts and Entertainment

music
Latest stories from i100
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?

ES Rentals

    Independent Dating
    and  

    By clicking 'Search' you
    are agreeing to our
    Terms of Use.

    Homeless Veterans Christmas Appeal: Drifting and forgotten - turning lives around for ex-soldiers

    Homeless Veterans Christmas Appeal: Turning lives around for ex-soldiers

    Our partner charities help veterans on the brink – and get them back on their feet
    Putin’s far-right ambition: Think-tank reveals how Russian President is wooing – and funding – populist parties across Europe to gain influence in the EU

    Putin’s far-right ambition

    Think-tank reveals how Russian President is wooing – and funding – populist parties across Europe to gain influence in the EU
    Tove Jansson's Moominland: What was the inspiration for Finland's most famous family?

    Escape to Moominland

    What was the inspiration for Finland's most famous family?
    Nightclubbing with Richard Young: The story behind his latest book of celebrity photographs

    24-Hour party person

    Photographer Richard Young has been snapping celebrities at play for 40 years. As his latest book is released, he reveals that it wasn’t all fun and games
    Michelle Obama's school dinners: America’s children have a message for the First Lady

    A taste for rebellion

    US children have started an online protest against Michelle Obama’s drive for healthy school meals by posting photos of their lunches
    Colouring books for adults: How the French are going crazy for Crayolas

    Colouring books for adults

    How the French are going crazy for Crayolas
    Jack Thorne's play 'Hope': What would you do as a local politician faced with an impossible choice of cuts?

    What would you do as a local politician faced with an impossible choice of cuts?

    Playwright Jack Thorne's latest work 'Hope' poses the question to audiences
    Ed Harcourt on Romeo Beckham and life as a court composer at Burberry

    Call me Ed Mozart

    Paloma Faith, Lana del Ray... Romeo Beckham. Ed Harcourt has proved that he can write for them all. But it took a personal crisis to turn him from indie star to writer-for-hire
    10 best stocking fillers for foodies

    Festive treats: 10 best stocking fillers for foodies

    From boozy milk to wasabi, give the food-lover in your life some extra-special, unusual treats to wake up to on Christmas morning
    Phil Hughes head injury: He had one weakness – it has come back to haunt him

    Phil Hughes had one weakness – it has come back to haunt him

    Prolific opener had world at his feet until Harmison and Flintoff bounced him
    'I have an age of attraction that starts as low as four': How do you deal with a paedophile who has never committed a crime?

    'I am a paedophile'

    Is our approach to sex offenders helping to create more victims?
    How bad do you have to be to lose a Home Office contract?

    How bad do you have to be to lose a Home Office contract?

    Serco given Yarl’s Wood immigration contract despite ‘vast failings’
    Green Party on the march in Bristol: From a lost deposit to victory

    From a lost deposit to victory

    Green Party on the march in Bristol
    Putting the grot right into Santa's grotto

    Winter blunderlands

    Putting the grot into grotto
    'It just came to us, why not do it naked?' London's first nude free runner captured in breathtaking images across capital

    'It just came to us, why not do it naked?'

    London's first nude free runner captured in breathtaking images across capital