The ex factor: '50 Ways to Leave Your Lover'
When the Bush Theatre asked people to share their worst break-up experiences, it was inundated with replies. Now those stories have become a play, '50 Ways to Leave Your Lover'. Alice Jones finds out what became of the broken-hearted
Wednesday, 16 July 2008
GETTY IMAGES
Love and hate: '50 Ways to Leave Your Lover' relives the public's stories of heartbreak, from the cringeworthy to the poignant
It's not you, it's me. Or perhaps it's not me, it is you. Or, if you're feeling really mean, it's not me, it's your face. There are myriad ways to break up with someone but, as Rosalind Capulet, the forgotten, erstwhile love interest of Romeo, reminds us at the beginning of 50 Ways to Leave Your Lover, "there's not a good way, is there? I mean, there are better ways than sleeping with your cousin Juliet and then dying in an accidental suicide pact but, generally speaking, it's never pretty, is it?"
Undaunted, the Bush Theatre is currently wallowing in the ugly side of dating as it stages a series of 50 break-ups in as many minutes. Ranging from the flippant one-line kiss-off to the tender conclusion of a quarter-century of marriage, these tales from the dumping ground have more than just heartbreak in common: they have all been plucked from real life. Working on the principle that the truth is often stranger than fiction, for the last year audiences at the Bush Theatre have been encouraged to share their best (or worst) relationship splits anonymously over email. And they haven't disappointed, willingly sharing their tales of romantic woe in the name of art. Who was the cad who dumped his lady via his Facebook status? Or the girl who was charmed by the love token of a teddy bear, only to discover that it growled, "you're dumped. And I want my CDs back" when she squeezed its tummy?
These and many other jaw-dropping jilting emails (of which some of the best are reprinted in the box opposite) were then seized upon and stitched together by a crack team of young playwrights from the Bush's stable, including two writers for E4's Skins, Lucy Kirkwood (whose Tinderbox was produced at the theatre earlier this year) and Ben Schiffer. The collaborative result is 50 Ways to Leave Your Lover, a kind of Bayeux Tapestry of broken hearts. Having taken the emotional melodramas of its audience, it offers them a cathartic "closure" – whether it's weeping with grief or, more often than not, hilarity – in the anonymity of a darkened theatre.
Among the 50 blows delivered, the much-loved/hated clichés ("Let's just be friends", "I'm not ready for a relationship" etc) naturally crop up, but there are also some spectacularly inventive excuses for waving goodbye. Who, for example, could argue with the following? "Yeah, I see a future for us, but it's more a global warming and climate catastrophe sort of vision. So I'm going take some preventative measures. For the sake of the planet."
In the pursuit of freedom, it seems that every possible approach has been taken – the angry, the cowardly, the blunt, the conceited, the sexual, the gentle, the organised – and every emotion plumbed, from unbridled joy to mildly unhinged sorrow. Then there are the victims, including a love-crazed arsonist, a sexually confused girlfriend with a gymslip fetish and a poetry-spouting drip with a penchant for self-immolation. The playwrights have also interspersed several recurring characters into the swiftly moving action, including a couple whose relationship is built on frequent bust-ups and a soft-hearted guy who can't get his words out – as well as the redacted break-up scenes of some famous lovers from the annals of history – from Cathy and Heathcliff ("He's just got a bit more money than you. Nice house. Other side of the moor...") to Jean-Paul Sartre and Simone de Beauvoir ("the one theeng I am certain of is that NATHING eez certain, Simone. Nat even LAV.").
"We quickly realised that we wanted it to be a fun show, one that you could laugh with and that was affirming in some way, rather than depressing," says Anthea Williams, the director. "It's not just a sketch show, it develops and is a good mixture of funny, ridiculous, real and tragic."
The four-strong cast, two women and two men, including Ralf Little, best known as The Royle Family's resident dogsbody Anthony, will race through the various tricky encounters in a lo-fi production that was originally commissioned for Latitude Festival. The festival, now in its third year, has a burgeoning theatre scene alongside the usual field favourites of music and comedy. Last year the Royal Court presented Shuffle, a group of plays based on the lyrics of pop songs, while the Bush produced five short sketches about jokes. The episodic, largely comic nature of 50 Ways... grew out of the theatre's experience at last year's festival. Capturing the attention of a tent-full of absent-minded, spoilt-for-choice festival-goers is a very different challenge from performing in front of a captive West End audience. "The tents are thrilling because people wander in and out and they're not sure if a performance is beginning or ending," enthuses Josie Rourke, artistic director of the theatre. "The notion was to have, in the space of 50 minutes, lots of very brief scenes around a theme or an idea that was easy to latch on to. It rather suits the idea that people might be coming and going. You can wander in and not feel that you've missed the story and the piece welcomes you."
It's also, as theatres from the Royal Court and the Bush to the National and the RSC are swiftly discovering, a canny and fairly low-risk way of testing out new writing talent in front of a youthful audience. The five up-and-coming writers on 50 Ways... workshopped their script with the master of the dark heart, Neil LaBute (whose current play Fat Pig concerns a man breaking up with his girlfriend because she is overweight), which may account for the blackly comic and searingly, often explicitly so, honest tenor of much of the writing. "It's nice to be able to share anonymously from time to time," says Rourke. "I had 40 years of Catholic education so I absolutely understand the nature of the confessional and how it can be strangely comforting."
For anyone feeling the need to share and have their moment of personal catharsis played out on stage, the email address is still open (info@latitudefestival.co.uk). I might send in the most unfortunate story I know, perpetrated by an old friend who mistakenly sent a text message meant for his housemate – gloating, "I'm going to dump her after pudding" – to his girlfriend, who was sitting across the table from him in the restaurant, blithely polishing off her tiramisu. Needless to say, it wasn't pretty.
'50 Ways to Leave Your Lover' plays at Latitude Festival, Henham Park, Southwold (www.latitudefestival.co.uk), 19 to 20 July, then at The Bush Theatre, London W12 (020-8743 5050), 21 to 26 July
Breaking up is hard to do: from those who know
* "I don't know the details that led to the break-up but there must have been some serious animosity, as when the time came the guy in question took a trip to one of those 'build-your-own-teddy-bear' emporia and set about making a cuddly toy of his own. When he came to the voice box section he chose to record his own message. The end result was a cuddly bear who, when pressed in the stomach, recited 'You're dumped, I want my CDs back'."
* "I decided that enough was enough and so called him and asked him out to 'somewhere quiet' to have a 'chat'. We met at the pre-arranged time and sat in a quiet corner of the pub and I started to tell him about how I was feeling – the relationship isn't going anywhere, kind of thing. But every time I tried to talk workmen started to drill the road outside. I had to shout to get my bloke to hear what I was saying and there were many of those moments when you start raising your voice to be heard and then suddenly the noise stops and you are left shouting and everyone in the vicinity can hear everything you have said. It was totally embarrassing, not only for me, but for him, for all the bar staff and for the one or two people who had gone in there for a quiet drink."
* "A true sign of the times. I was seeing a guy last year. He had one of these high-pressure London jobs and so would disappear for a week or so with no contact, enslaved by his investment bank. I found out that we were no longer an item via Facebook – he'd changed his status to 'single'. It took him a week to get round to telling me. At least I was prepared for it, though."
* "I once dumped a guy who then got very upset. He came round a couple of days later and was crying his heart out as he told me he had gone down to the bottom of the garden to hang himself, but his dad had gone and chopped the tree down. I had to leave the room as tears of laughter were streaming down my face. PS: he is still alive and well and happy with a family."
* "A funny way in which to 'leave your lover' that I have come across is 'Let's have a Kit-Kat. I mean, let's take a break'. Hope you find it as funny as I did."
* "Three days before the wedding... I told her I was gay... It wasn't very nice..."
* "My favourite ever way I got 'left' (so bad, even I had to laugh at the time): my boyfriend of around six months at university rang me (he lived all of 600 yards away) and said, 'I have been looking around campus and I don't think I can be faithful to you anymore.'"
* "At school I was once dumped through a window. He screwed up a piece of paper and dropped it while his mate pointed at me, trying to convey the message 'you're dropped'..."

I once got dumped by someone after she'd been off to something called 'Spring Harvest' with the local Baptist Church.
She said that she could never love anyone as much as she loved Jesus, and so there was no room for me.
I was devastated, and couldn't listen to 'High' by the Cure for years afterwards, but I had to admit I very much doubt I could have competed with the Son of God. I don't know if they're still together or not, what with the age difference and everything.
Posted by dogsolitude_uk | 17.07.08, 10:58 GMT
I was dumped after 25 years of marriage. I remember my ex-wife
describing her new bloke as ' Mr Wonderful ' I was devastated and months of depression and counselling followed the break-up. Tewlve months later I bought a local paper and read that ' Mr Wonderful ' had been arrested for curb crawling. Who says there is no justice in this world?
Posted by Richard | 17.07.08, 10:30 GMT
I got dumped after five years on the eve of the millenium (31/12/99) but I got all that rubbish about wanting space et al as an excuse when she was simply having an affair.
Posted by DCH | 17.07.08, 08:46 GMT
My first girlfriend dumped me in a mean way. Mind you, we were 16 so pretty young. That said she my first real girlfriend and someone I adored.
"She" broke up with me by going across the road to her friend's house and having her friend call me and do the dumping! Not nice at all and it took me about 10 years to get over!
Posted by Mark | 16.07.08, 23:50 GMT
My first love broke my heart by introducing me as his sister, later explaining there was no more 'us' and he was seeing someone else, I was so shocked and upset I didn't even argue.
When my four year relasionship was going from bad to worse I bought a one way ticket to Spain and emmigrated.
For the first few weeks I spoke with my ex/boyfriend thinking I may return. That was 5 years ago and it was the best investment I ever made. No regrets, he was a twat!
Posted by Bec | 16.07.08, 17:04 GMT
I was 19 and he was 28. I had told him often for the past two months that I was no longer happy with him, but he wasn't listening. My parents came in town to visit and he came over. I chose that time to tell him that it was over. He made like he was going to go to the bathroom but instead dashed into my bedroom, locked the door and proceeded to cry and sob. He stayed in there for hours crying "Why" and "You don't understand how much I love you!" and "You can't do this to me!" etc., through the bedroom door. Meanwhile my parents and I sat around in the living room cringing and wondering when he was ever going to come out and leave. All the while I wondered what I had ever seen in the guy! Definitely the final disgusting straw!
Posted by Chris | 16.07.08, 17:02 GMT
When I went away on a course for work I was somewhat surprised mid week to get a message to call my wife urgently.... As she was pregnant with our 2nd child I called at the next break, where she told me she was leaving me for another man and would be taking our children, savings, bonds, furniture and anything not tied down with her... I got back on the Friday night - she was out all night with her lover and my kids!
When I returned that lonely Saturday night I tried to watch TV - No Tv - so make myself dinner - no cooker - cup of tea? No kettle! so I went to the pub to drown my sorrows - returned to go to sleep - No bed! in the end I slept on the floor with my head on a bean bag!
Posted by Peter | 16.07.08, 16:05 GMT
A common one, at least from my friend, was just to ignore them. Not answer calls, whenever the poor girls cam around he would pretend he wasn't at home. I remember one time there was 4 of us over there, and we all had to be quiet unless she discover that he was at home. We were all trying not to laugh (at him, not her) when she was walking around the flat, banging on the windows.
My worst was to do it on the bus, and leave her crying - yes, I was (and possible still am) a bastard.
Posted by cak | 16.07.08, 14:57 GMT
no offence to roman catholics, but my 20 year marriage was 17 years of protracted break-up, after birth control was not on his agenda.( i had born three lovely children despite severe spinal curvature.
his don huanism really took off. lord byron excuses this serail womanising as the innocent reaction to a repressive catholic education. what happened to free will? or maybe they will find a gene for it now, so that these narcissist hedonists can cop out scientifically!
his debts forced me to go to court five times to save our house, car and furniture from re-possession.
the grand finale was when he forced me to entertain his lover at the christmas table along with our children on pain of no further financial support. foreseeing blood on the wall or my own voluntary retreat to the warneford, the oxford mental hospital , i finally dumped them together!
Posted by Susan | 16.07.08, 11:23 GMT