Where a heretic prescribes, Nature derides
This isn't to say that the exercise is entirely pointless, just that it's worth keeping in mind that television is an unscientific medium. It can be a brilliant explicator of secure truths, but it doesn't really have the time to slog through the detailed figures and procedures that constitute the dull, heroic work of verification. So Heretics (BBC 2), a new series which examines the cases of scientists who have challenged orthodox opinion and suffered for it, is unlikely to do more than alert us to some problems.
The first case history was that of Jacques Benveniste, a French immunologist with an excellent reputation - until he claimed that he had experimental proof of the principles of homeopathy. The journal Nature, which has a literal power of imprimatur when it comes to scientific theories, took a dim view of this. They eventually agreed to publish his paper on the condition that they were allowed to review the laboratory's work.
In something of an own-goal, John Maddox, Nature's editor, appointed a journalist specialising in scientific fraud, the Amazing Randi, a magician turned hoax-buster, and himself to oversee the experiments. When it comes to homeopathy, I'll help you pile the wood around the stake and then lend you my Zippo to light it, but even I would have to concede that this line-up didn't look very much like impartial peer review. They found, unsurprisingly, that Benveniste's conclusions were mistaken and that his researchers had found what they wanted to find - a touch pot and kettle-ish given the circumstances.
Despite the attacks of French colleagues and threats to his livelihood, Benveniste continued his work, claiming that water has the ability to magnetically 'memorise' the molecular structure of drugs, even after billionfold dilutions. He also claims to have 'potentized' water down a wire ('One day we will get our drugs on the phone,' he said). These extraordinary claims were asserted against a coercive backdrop of bubbling glassware and flickering computer screens, but you couldn't, in the nature of things, be offered anything like scientific proof.
A thought experiment was possible, however. The hypothesis was this: Benveniste is right and has discovered a principle that has destructive consequences not only for much current orthodoxy (including the profits of conventional drug companies) but also for the reputation of his opponents. What might the response look like? Very much like what has happened, I would have thought. Paradigm shifts of this magnitude are as painful as resetting a bone without anaesthetic, and they provoke a belligerent defensiveness from defenders of the status quo.
Some of Benveniste's supporters regard the response to his theories as proof in itself, as if truth could be detected by the allergic reaction it provokes in the Academies. That's nonsense, and I will let my money ride on Dr Maddox and the teams who have been unable to replicate Benveniste's results. But Heretics, while it couldn't prove much, certainly proved that refusing to look isn't going to make any theory go away. Time and money is precious but even so science must suffer fools gladly, just in case, one day, one of the fools is right.
Glastonbury Roger Daltrey and Pete Townshend will perform with Paul Weller as their warm-up act
Arts & Ents blogs
- 1 Katie Hopkins gives rare glimpse of sensitive side with heartfelt open letter to her children penned in case she dies from epilepsy
- 2 Rihanna's Met Gala dress took one Chinese woman 2 years to make, was reduced to omelette meme in 2 seconds
- 3 Top Gear: Jodie Kidd, Philip Glenister and Guy Martin 'in advanced talks' to replace Jeremy Clarkson and co
- 4 Frankie Boyle on Scottish independence: 'In the Interests of Unity, F**k Off'
- 5 Florida couple forced to register as sex offenders for having sex on public beach
Penny Dreadful, series 2 episode 1, review: It is still gloriously silly
Top Gear: Jodie Kidd, Philip Glenister and Guy Martin 'in advanced talks' to replace Jeremy Clarkson and co
Eurovision 2015: What date and time is the song contest and who are the favourites to win?
How the Other Half Eat, Channel 4 - TV review: Swapping food trolleys shows how food and class are closely connected
Noel Gallagher 'cannot wait' to hear Oasis-inspired One Direction album but rants about 'pointless' Tidal and Spotify
In defence of liberal democracy
General Election 2015: Post-election 'shambles' looms as 70 per cent of voters say SNP 'should not be able to veto UK government policies'
The Rothschild Libel: Why has it taken 200 years for an anti-Semitic slur that emerged from the Battle of Waterloo to be dismissed?
General Election 2015: UK will be 'run for the wealthy and powerful' if Tories retain power, Labour warns
General election live: SNP suspends two members for disrupting Labour rally
Schools forced to act as 'miniature welfare states' with teachers buying underwear and even haircuts for poor pupils