Wheels, Etc: Porsche Bike RS

Its most expensive part? The Porsche badge on the front

Click to follow
The Independent Online


Price: £4,999
Weight: 9kg
Frame: Carbon fibre
Groupset: Shimano XTR
Wheels: Crank Brothers 29in
Top speed: Greater than you'd think

The car is dead. Or dying. Or at least declining. We reached "peak car", ~as transport policy wonks call it (see also: peak oil), some time in the past decade, when fewer of us started driving shorter distances, less often. Bad news if your business runs on petrol and four wheels, which is perhaps one reason why car manufacturers, spluttering as they are towards a gloomy horizon, are reviving their links with the bicycle. Ding ding!

When cars rolled on to our roads more than 100 years ago, bike shops began stocking them. In some cases bicycle manufacturers such as Armand Peugeot (who started out making pepper grinders, by the way) thought there might be something in the combustion engine. By the late 1920s Peugeot had cast off its bike arm and, while the name appeared on frames until recently, it was a rare reminder of the entwined histories of the bicycle and the car.

Now the bike is in the ascendant and, in a symbolic reversal, cars are being shifted across showrooms to make way. Last month a BMW dealer opened a full bike shop inside a north London branch. Several manufacturers that have quietly put their names to bikes (even Hummer has dabbled) are now giving them greater prominence. They include Porsche, which this month offers two high-end hybrids. The RS, which I was given to test for a weekend, is striking. Most striking – and I'll get on to its looks – is its price. At £5,000 you might expect an engine and heated seats. It costs more than the sum of its parts, the incongruous Porsche badge up front being its most expensive component.

But it's the carbon-fibre frame that will turn heads. The top tube sweeps in an arc from the headset but its grace is consumed by its girth, which reaches tree-like proportions at its upper end. The forks complete the muscular look and offer enough clearance above the fat Schwable tyres to stick a fist through. It's all beautifully built and put together and finished, but won't please those who seek elegance in bikes.

How does it ride? Quickly. Flighty, responsive and unforgiving, it sometimes feels as if it needs to be reined in like the wild horse of the Porsche logo. But don't expect comfort from the racing saddle or rigid frame as it passes over even tiny bumps. Do expect fun. The RS offers total control and its weight helps it to fly uphill. But, while I enjoyed the spin, I also found it to be deeply flawed. This is a bike with an identity crisis, offering the racing credentials of a road bike (but none of the right bits), the bulk of a mountain bike (but with no suspension or even give) and the semblance of a hybrid (but without the comfort or practicality). It is a missed opportunity for Porsche, which might have complimented the RS's cheaper (still £3,000) sister, the S – a sporty hybrid in aluminium – with a pure road bike as pretty and as refined as its sports cars. Instead we have a fudge for rich people who don't know much about bikes. If the car-bike balance is tipping back towards two wheels, I fear the RS will do little to nudge the scales.