Coalition claim on circuses contradicts official advice
The Coalition’s claim that it can not ban wild animals in circuses because of a potential legal challenge under human rights legislation contradicts previous official advice given to ministers,
The Independent can reveal today.
Animal welfare minister Jim Paice provoked laughter among MPs last week by suggesting lions, tigers and other animals would have to stay performing tricks in the big top because circuses could mount a case under the 1998 Human Rights Act.
A risk assessment by civil servants for the previous Labour administration in December 2009 explicitly gave a ban a clear run under the Act. The document - which has been removed from the Department for the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Defra) - stated: “There are no human rights issues raised by these proposals.”
Meanwhile the European Commission has intervened to cast doubt on a second piece of legislation cited by Defra as the vehicle for a possible court challenge.
In a blog on its website, the European Commission in London wrote: “Comments made by UK officials “that a total ban on wild animals in circuses might well be seen as disproportionate under the EU Services Directive ……” are interesting.
“The EU rules ensure services can be easily provided across borders. But there are of course valid reasons for exceptions to the rules and restrictions are allowed.”
The statement - headed “What a circus...” - added that Commission officials were “standing ready to discuss the matter with the UK government.”
The disclosures are a fresh embarrassment to Defra ministers, who have been accused of incompetence and misinformation over their U-turn on their previously supported plan for a ban on wild animals in circuses.
For months this year they said they were “minded” to introduce a ban before abruptly changing tack earlier this month, after Downing Street apparently intervened to veto the plan.
The Environment Secretary Caroline Spelman and Mr Paice told the Commons three times they could not proceed with a ban because of an ongoing court case against a ban in place in Austria.
An animal welfare group and The Independent quickly established there was no case in Austria and legal challenges to the Austrian ban introduced in 2005 were thrown out by the European Commission in 2006 and the European Ombudsman in 2010. The European Commission has made clear that banning wild animals from circuses is a matter for individual member states.
In an emergency statement to the Commons last week, Mr Paice admitted that Defra had misled the Commons but insisted that a court challenge was imminent.
He told the chamber: “The very strong legal advice that we have received, which is consistent with the case being prepared against Austria, is that a total ban on wild animals in circuses might well be seen as disproportionate action under the European Union Services Directive and under our own Human Rights Act 1998 [laughter from MPs]”
Mary Creagh, shadow environment secretary, said last night that the Government’s legal case against a ban had been “demolished”.
She said: “As I said in the Commons on Thursday, a ban can be brought in using Labour’s Animal Welfare Act and there are no implications for human rights. Defra Ministers are just making it up as they go along.”
MPs have demanded Defra publish its “very strong legal advice.”
Animal welfare organisations are hoping to emulate the row Defra’s proposed forests sell-off, which was abandoned earlier this year.
More than 23,000 people - supported by the RSPCA and the British Veterinary Association - have signed The Independent’s online petition calling for a ban. The target is being raised to 30,000 signatures.
To sign, visit independent.co.uk/circusanimals
Greenland’s dark snow may start global warming ‘feedback loop’
The ugliest animals on earth: Blobfish, axolotl and proboscis monkey battle it out to be named least attractive beast
India's hidden climate change catastrophe
Animal Extinction - the greatest threat to mankind
Climate change means rate of growth of trees has gone up by 77%
- 1 Hilary Mantel 'should be investigated by police' over Margaret Thatcher assassination story, says Lord Bell
- 2 Stamford Hill council removes 'unacceptable' posters telling women which side of the road to walk down
- 3 Kim Kardashian 'nude pictures' leaked on 4chan weeks after Jennifer Lawrence 'The Fappening' scandal
- 4 Alex Salmond: 'The rocks would melt with the sun before I'd ever set foot in the House of Lords'
- 5 Free U2 album: How the most generous giveaway in music history turned into a PR disaster
Scottish independence referendum: A nation divided against itself
Scottish referendum results: Cross-party consensus collapses amid Tory-Labour spat on the 'English question'
Scottish independence: David Cameron is becoming the 'George Bush of Britain'
Russia freezes Ukraine into submission: Kiev admits country doesn't have enough fuel for winter
Plebgate MP Andrew Mitchell called officer a 'little s**t', claim court documents 'exposing ex-Chief Whip's 'record of abusing police'
Archbishop of Canterbury admits doubts about existence of God
£70000 - £80000 per annum: Ashdown Group: Group Head of Marketing and Communic...
Negotiable: Randstad Education Manchester: Level 3 Nursery Nurse required for ...
Negotiable: Randstad Education Manchester: L3 Nursery Nurses urgently required...
Negotiable: Randstad Education Manchester: We have a number of schools based S...