Nature

Mostly Cloudy with Showers 14° London Hi 15°C / Lo 8°C

Tiny warbler at risk from longer African migration

European breeding ranges shifting northwards as temperatures rise

By Michael McCarthy, Environment Editor

The white throat may face an added 300 miles to its migration from Africa to Europe by the end of the century

PA

The white throat may face an added 300 miles to its migration from Africa to Europe by the end of the century

They are some of the world's most remarkable and improbable journeys – vast odysseys across desert, mountain and sea by creatures often no bigger than a Mars bar. But the annual flights of Europe's migratory birds to and from sub-Saharan Africa are set to get even longer.

Climate change, shifting the breeding range of many European bird species northwards, is likely to lengthen the migrants' marathon journeys substantially, in some cases by hundreds of miles, a new scientific study predicts. The added distance is likely to make what are already hazardous and chancey long-distance flights even more risky, with possible fatal consequences for many birds.

One example is one of Britain's most charming summer visitors, the whitethroat, a small bouncy warbler pouring into Britain by the thousands right now after journeying from its winter quarters in the Sahel, the arid zone south of the Sahara. The whitethroat may face another 300 miles or more on the average length of its Africa to Europe trip by the end of this century. This added distance would be a considerable threat, said Stephen Willis of Durham University, leader of the research team which produced the study.

The researchers have carried out the first examination of how global warming may, by the end of the century, affect the "climate space" of European breeding birds on their wintering grounds in Africa – the climate space being the climatic range in which they can comfortably exist. This is a follow-up to a study last year, extensively reported in The Independent, which showed that many birds' climate space in Europe would shift towards the north as temperatures rose.

But the new study shows that for the bird group studied – the Sylvia family of warblers, of which the whitethroat (Sylvia communis) is one – the African climate space does not move in some cases, while the European one does, meaning that the migratory journey gets longer.

A staggering 5 billion birds of nearly 200 species are estimated to migrate to Europe and Asia from Africa every spring, with some weighing less than 10g undertaking the voyages between the two continents to find food and suitable climate. Their journeys may be 4,000 miles long, or in the case of birds such as the swallow, which migrates from South Africa, as many as 6,000 miles.

To travel such immense distances the birds have to put on large amounts of weight as fat; they even shrink the size of some of their internal organs to become more fuel efficient. Some species must even double their weight. They also need a miraculous sense of navigation, and a lot of luck to survive drought, predators and hunters.

"From 2071 to 2100, nine out of the 17 species we looked at are projected to face longer migrations, particularly birds that cross the Sahara desert," said Dr Willis. "This is bad news for birds like the whitethroat."

Professor Rhys Green, of Cambridge University and the RSPB, another of the researchers, said: "These tiny birds make amazing journeys, pushing themselves to the limits of endurance. Anything that makes those journeys longer or more dependent on rare and vulnerable pit-stop habitats used for refuelling on migration could mean the difference between life and death."

African odyssey: Warblers' marathon journeys

Three more of the warbler species face increased distances on their migratory journeys from sub-Saharan Africa as long as, or longer than, those faced by the whitethroat, the study shows. These are birds of central and southern Europe which are not often found in Britain.

* The first is the subalpine warbler, Sylvia cantillans, a very pretty songbird with an orange breast set off by a white "moustache" which is found in southern Europe, especially around the Mediterranean coast. It faces an average increase in its journey of about 470 miles.

* The second is the orphean warbler, Sylvia hortensis, which looks rather like a larger version of the blackcap familiar to English bird lovers, which has a very similar range to the subalpine. It faces an increase in its journey of about 340 miles.

* The third is the barred warbler, Sylvia nisoria, a fairly inconspicuous bird of an ashy grey-brown colour, which migrates to breed in central and eastern Europe. It faces an average increase in its annual journeys of nearly 600 miles.

The researchers only studied 17 bird species in total and it is quite possible that many more migrants to Europe from Africa may face longer annual journeys.

Post a Comment

View all comments that have been posted about this article.

Offensive or abusive comments will be removed and your IP logged and may be used to prevent further submission. In submitting a comment to the site, you agree to be bound by the Independent Minds Terms of Service.

Comments

Change in Whitethroat breeding range
[info]ridingonadonkey wrote:
Wednesday, 15 April 2009 at 07:48 am (UTC)
Could you tell me for what reasons the climactic range of a warbler will 'shift northward'?
[info]ridingonadonkey wrote:
Wednesday, 15 April 2009 at 07:50 am (UTC)
Could you tell me what are the reasons for the change in warbler breeding range?

Is it a higher temperature in Africa? A lower temperature in the 'north'?

What is the north? Past the Warford Gap?
More Computer Modelling Nonsense
[info]calum100 wrote:
Wednesday, 15 April 2009 at 09:48 am (UTC)
This is study is solely based on a computer climate model that is notorious for making alarmist claims. There are no actual field data to back up these claims. It is an exercise in virtual science.

It would appear that this research group are in direct competition with RyanAir on who can dump their flying passengers furthest from their required destination.


Duh
[info]bobav wrote:
Wednesday, 15 April 2009 at 11:16 am (UTC)
I live in the area in which the last large flocks of passenger pigeons were decimated by hunting, clear cut logging and incursion into mass nesting habitat by other human activity and population growth (the birds, while nesting, were too "messy"). The birds, like the great white pine and hardwood forests, were largely consdered to be in endless supply and human use was not thought to be a serious threat. Even while the final large flocks of the birds were obviously waning there were still those bent on contradicting what was obvious. "Prove it" they insisted while they paid more and more to fill their plates with the little things, or watched the timber burn in the Chicago fire... or "they'll just flying elsewhere".... Well, the birds are gone forever and the forests, in many areas, have yet to recover, and due to the nature of human attempts to replant, for lumbering purposes if nothing else, the forests are often diseased or so species thin that they are rather sterile. So demand proof all you want and deny the obvious for what good it will do you, You'll probably be dead by the time these birds are gone and you, and perhaps them, won't be missed. Or perhaps the question is: who will be missed more?
We love bird more then humans I guess.
[info]famulla wrote:
Wednesday, 15 April 2009 at 01:50 pm (UTC)
Tiny warbler at risk from longer African migration
I read about one lady eating snails and she stated these were low in calories and good for the hearts. Then she talked of the first lady and Clinton on the hairstyle and more. Then one man in Kenya ate the python. What a story in these papers to day. Can we have better new? As soon as the bird lovers come to know of these, these will go to the laboratory and ask the RSPCA to look into these.
We love bird more then humans I guess.
I thank you
Firozali A. Mulla

Article Archive

Day In a Page

Sun | Mon | Tue | Wed | Thu | Fri | Sat

Select date