The Big Question: Is Scotland ready for independence, and if so what form will it take?

Why are we asking this now?

The Scottish Government, led by First Minister Alex Salmond, yesterday published a glossy 176-page White Paper entitled Your Scotland, Your Voice, looking at a range of possible changes to the country's constitutional status within the United Kingdom. As an ardent nationalist, Mr Salmond was making good on his long-held commitment to bring forward legislation that could pave the way for independence from Westminster through a national referendum.



What exactly is he proposing?

The Scottish National Party (SNP) has laid out four possible choices, only three of which it envisages would feature on a future referendum ballot paper. The first would see the electorate asked to vote for no change. The status quo would see the Holyrood Parliament continue to operate under the terms of the 1998 Scotland Act brought in following the "yes" vote in the referendum on devolution of the previous year. It gave Scots powers to make their own laws and vary income tax rates (a power that remains as yet unused – the first since the Act of Union).

The second proposal is being described as "devolution max" or "independence lite", depending on your standpoint. This would see future Scottish governments given still greater control over their own affairs. Responsibility for broadcasting, benefits and the vast majority of tax collection would be handed over. While Scotland would remain within the United Kingdom, keep the pound and continue to be guided by Westminster on matters of foreign affairs, it would give an unprecedented degree of autonomy. The third option would see Scotland become a sovereign state with full independence from the rest of the UK and total control over its affairs.



And the fourth scenario?

The other option laid out in the White Paper, but which would not form part of a referendum question under Mr Salmond's plans, would be adopting the recommendations of the Calman Commission. The body was set up in 2007 to review the devolution process 10 years after the establishment of a Scottish Parliament and came up with 24 recommendations, the most radical of which would give MSPs much greater tax-setting powers and the government authority to borrow money for capital investment and infrastructure. It also envisaged handing over power in controversial areas such as airgun legislation, drink driving and elections.

What happens now?

These are uncharted waters and no one can really be sure how this push for independence will play out in the long term. Many matters are up in the air, not least a forthcoming election for a new Westminster government. But if the SNP get their way, a referendum Bill could be published by early next year and Scottish voters might find themselves going to the polls within a matter of months after that.



How likely is that?

Highly unlikely. The first problem Mr Salmond faces is getting his Bill through Holyrood. The parliamentary maths are stacked against him. The minority SNP has 47 seats – just one more than Labour – and is reliant on the votes of the two independence-supporting Greens. It would need the support of 16 other members to gain a majority. Labour, the Conservatives and the Liberal Democrats are all committed to the Union and have backed the findings of the Calman Commission, albeit with varying degrees of enthusiasm.

Then even if the necessary votes can be accrued to pave the way for a referendum there is the small matter of public opinion. Polls have shown that full-blown support for a referendum continues to hover below the 30 per cent mark while the most recent survey found only one in five now back independence, the second lowest level of support since the SNP came to power in 2007.



Then why launch the White Paper?

Mr Salmond is an astute political operator and never to be underestimated. In one sense this is the realisation of his political ambition and the fulfilment of a covenant he has held with nationalist supporters stretching back years. The SNP has spent all its its energies since clinching power in 2007 trying to convince voters it is capable of governing and has enjoyed a long honeymoon on the back of some populist policies, even changing its name from the weak-sounding Scottish Executive to the more powerful Scottish Government.

But some of the gloss might be coming off and the recession has badly hit optimism in Scotland, which continues to perform badly compared to the rest of the UK. The SNP failed to snatch by-election victory in Gordon Brown's backyard of Glenrothes and was comfortably rejected again at Glasgow North East this autumn. A recent poll suggested Labour are now ahead of the SNP in voting intentions for both Westminster and Holyrood.

Of course it could be that Mr Salmond achieves his goal of increasing his seats at Westminster next year from seven to 20, potentially giving him a much greater say should there be a hung Parliament following next year's general election.

He could use the main parties' opposition to a referendum to galvanise support for the SNP in 2011 in the Scottish Parliament elections, when he could justifiably point to the democratic deficit if a fiercely Unionist Tory government is in power in Westminster with few or even no seats north of the border. Especially if Scotland is feeling the pain of George Osborne's plans to balance the budget and slash public spending. There are still votes in a radical mandate to tackle the enduring problems of drugs, alcoholism, poor health and hopelessness endured by at least two generations of Scots under both Westminster and New Labour's devolution.



What other obstacles to independence remain?

The independence argument was badly undermined during the economic crisis as critics recalled Mr Salmond's grand talk of an "economic arc of prosperity from Dublin to Reykjavik" that would include a sovereign Scotland. Iceland and Ireland were nearly wiped out by the financial crisis. Scotland's financial services didn't do much better and its biggest company, the Royal Bank of Scotland, was only saved as a result of billions of pounds of British taxpayers' money being poured in to nationalise the banking giant by the pro-Union Labour Prime Minister Gordon Brown.

North Sea oil and gas revenues, once the foundation stone for resurgent nationalist sentiment in the 1970s, are now waning and subject to worrying levels of price volatility. Meanwhile many in Scotland remain painfully aware that they benefit from an extra £1,600 a head of public spending under the Barnett Formula, the system which works out the regional share of Treasury cash, compared to elsewhere in the UK .

Finally, even if Mr Salmond's long-term plan were to come together, Holyrood is powerless to declare unilateral independence from the rest of the UK even with the backing of a "yes" vote in a referendum. Westminster would be under no obligation to honour a vote backing "devolution max" either, though there would be considerable pressure to do so. David Cameron has blown cold even on the relatively benign suggestions contained within the Calman report and he is unlikely to prove receptive to SNP negotiations on full withdrawal from the union – especially if that compromises the British nuclear deterrent, Trident, currently based in Scotland.

Is full independence now the best option for Scotland?

Yes

*Only full independence can give Scotland the powers it needs to build its economy, solve its social problems and carve out a place in the world



*Devolution began a process that will inevitably lead to full sovereignty



*A future Tory government with no Scottish MPs would have no democratic legitimacy north of the border

No

*Public opinion is against it, and so too are the majority of Scotland's politicians



*The Scottish economy is not strong enough to stand alone: witness the bailout of RBS



*Scotland continues to benefit from a generous financial deal out of being part of the UK

j.brown@independent.co.uk

Sport
Luis Suarez and Lionel Messi during Barcelona training in August
footballPete Jenson co-ghost wrote Suarez’s autobiography and reveals how desperate he's been to return
News
newsMcKamey Manor says 'there is no escape until the tour is completed'
Voices
Hunted: A stag lies dead on Jura, where David Cameron holidays and has himself stalked deer
voicesThe Scotland I know is becoming a playground for the rich
News
people
PROMOTED VIDEO
Arts and Entertainment
Architect Frank Gehry is regarded by many as the most important architect of the modern era
arts + entsGehry has declared that 98 per cent of modern architecture is "s**t"
Money
Welcome to tinsel town: retailers such as Selfridges will be Santa's little helpers this Christmas, working hard to persuade shoppers to stock up on gifts
news
Arts and Entertainment
Soul singer Sam Smith cleared up at the Mobo awards this week
newsSam Smith’s Mobo triumph is just the latest example of a trend
News
Laurence Easeman and Russell Brand
people
Sport
Fans of Dulwich Hamlet FC at their ground Champion Hill
footballFans are rejecting the £2,000 season tickets, officious stewarding, and airline-stadium sponsorship
News
Shami Chakrabarti
people
Arts and Entertainment
Benedict Cumberbatch has refused to deny his involvement in the upcoming new Star Wars film
filmBenedict Cumberbatch reignites Star Wars 7 rumours
Sport
football
News
news
Latest stories from i100
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?

Day In a Page

Wilko Johnson, now the bad news: musician splits with manager after police investigate assault claims

Wilko Johnson, now the bad news

Former Dr Feelgood splits with manager after police investigate assault claims
Mark Udall: The Democrat Senator with a fight on his hands ahead of the US midterm elections

Mark Udall: The Democrat Senator with a fight on his hands

The Senator for Colorado is for gay rights, for abortion rights – and in the Republicans’ sights as they threaten to take control of the Senate next month
New discoveries show more contact between far-flung prehistoric humans than had been thought

New discoveries show more contact between far-flung prehistoric humans than had been thought

Evidence found of contact between Easter Islanders and South America
Cerys Matthews reveals how her uncle taped 150 interviews for a biography of Dylan Thomas

Cerys Matthews on Dylan Thomas

The singer reveals how her uncle taped 150 interviews for a biography of the famous Welsh poet
DIY is not fun and we've finally realised this as a nation

Homebase closures: 'DIY is not fun'

Homebase has announced the closure of one in four of its stores. Nick Harding, who never did know his awl from his elbow, is glad to see the back of DIY
The Battle of the Five Armies: Air New Zealand releases new Hobbit-inspired in-flight video

Air New Zealand's wizard in-flight video

The airline has released a new Hobbit-inspired clip dubbed "The most epic safety video ever made"
Pumpkin spice is the flavour of the month - but can you stomach the sweetness?

Pumpkin spice is the flavour of the month

The combination of cinnamon, clove, nutmeg (and no actual pumpkin), now flavours everything from lattes to cream cheese in the US
11 best sonic skincare brushes

11 best sonic skincare brushes

Forget the flannel - take skincare to the next level by using your favourite cleanser with a sonic facial brush
Paul Scholes column: I'm not worried about Manchester United's defence - Chelsea test can be the making of Phil Jones and Marcos Rojo

Paul Scholes column

I'm not worried about Manchester United's defence - Chelsea test can be the making of Jones and Rojo
Frank Warren: Boxing has its problems but in all my time I've never seen a crooked fight

Frank Warren: Boxing has its problems but in all my time I've never seen a crooked fight

While other sports are stalked by corruption, we are an easy target for the critics
Jamie Roberts exclusive interview: 'I'm a man of my word – I'll stay in Paris'

Jamie Roberts: 'I'm a man of my word – I'll stay in Paris'

Wales centre says he’s not coming home but is looking to establish himself at Racing Métro
How could three tourists have been battered within an inch of their lives by a burglar in a plush London hotel?

A crime that reveals London's dark heart

How could three tourists have been battered within an inch of their lives by a burglar in a plush London hotel?
Meet 'Porridge' and 'Vampire': Chinese state TV is offering advice for citizens picking a Western moniker

Lost in translation: Western monikers

Chinese state TV is offering advice for citizens picking a Western moniker. Simon Usborne, who met a 'Porridge' and a 'Vampire' while in China, can see the problem
Handy hacks that make life easier: New book reveals how to rid your inbox of spam, protect your passwords and amplify your iPhone

Handy hacks that make life easier

New book reveals how to rid your email inbox of spam, protect your passwords and amplify your iPhone with a loo-roll
KidZania lets children try their hands at being a firefighter, doctor or factory worker for the day

KidZania: It's a small world

The new 'educational entertainment experience' in London's Shepherd's Bush will allow children to try out the jobs that are usually undertaken by adults, including firefighter, doctor or factory worker