Books: Hell in Wonderland
`Revolting trash' or modern masterpiece? New York novelist A M Homes has brought Lolita into the 1990s and outraged America. Elizabeth Young defends her
Saturday 01 November 1997
From the epigraph, taken naturally from Lewis Carroll - "A stopped clock is right twice a day" - to the heart-breakingly poignant death-rattle of the final sentence, we are seduced into a horrific hall of mirrors where we catch grotesque, lightning glimpses of ourselves and Homes's varied protagonists. They include a dead giant, an insane, incestuous mother who smears her small son's lips with her menstrual blood for lipstick, a gang of suburban teens, and - far away and long ago - a nymphet chasing butterflies in the sun. This is Alice.
Chappy, our paedophile narrator, is the orphan of the giant and a crazy mother. He is spending his twenty-third summer in gaol for the abominable crimes he committed against that 12-year-old Alice. He is the stopped clock with (literally) a looking-glass in his head - splinters from an accident.
The prisoner starts receiving mail from a college girl aged 19, on vacation in suburbia. ("Scars dale", as Chappy writes it). She has, as Chappy translates, an "oddly acquired taste for the freshest of flesh" and lusts after the insouciant crudity, the unselfconscious purity, of a local 12-year-old, Matthew.
Chappy is hooked. Although she is far too old for his tastes (like John Ruskin, he detests pubic hair), he is drawn excitedly into her desire, pursuit and seduction of prey. In fact, he takes over. We read little of her actual letters, written "in the stinted, stilted language of youth". She is one of the "overly undereducated". Pruriently, voyeuristically he refashions her fantasies and invites us, "Herr Reader", to share them.
When she finally writes "And then we did it" his always barely suppressed rage roars out: "I cannot forgive her the imbecilic nature of her communication." And because, to Chappy, lust is indistinguishable from memory, he starts to tumble helplessly down his own rabbit hole, away from the charged, homosexual tension of the gaol and back to his deadly encounter with Alice herself.
The book is stitched so tightly that it would take another one to unpick it. It is this triumph of form that allows Chappy to unravel so completely and accept "after a lifetime of abstinence" the illicit drugs from the Sicko Wing dealer. Always, we are brushed with the softest intertextual wings. They suggest Lewis Carroll's own Alice - begun on the Fourth of July. More important is Vladimir Nabokov, and Chappy's predecessor: Humbert Humbert of Lolita.
As in Lolita, there is the constant dialogue with the reader who is "teased" and made complicit. Also Chappy, like Humbert, is pathetic, sympathetic, funny and clever. A M Homes has said of her elusive narrator, "I think he's deeply crazy. Smart - but not as smart as he thinks he is. He has a certain moral centre." This is where she dives deep.
Through Lolita, Humbert surveyed the crass, gum-chewing commercialisation of 1950s America. So Chappy, through his young correspondent, gazes at and judges the 1990s suburbs. Transgression, rape, corruption and ennui lurk behind the sunlit piles of consumer "toys" in a slack, soulless vista familiar from Homes's previous books.
For Chappy, the relationship sours: "God, they are so annoying when they believe they can think for themselves." The girl's "silly summer's delight", her Matthew, is merely "a rite of passage" before she sails away (to Europe) into adult womanhood. She is not to be compared with him, a "true connoisseur". Chappy damns the emptiness and sterility of America, as did Nabokov before him: "The decay is everywhere."
To him, these teenagers "were fucking because... it was free... because there was nothing else to do, because it was easy... Everything had gone loose and lazy, they'd lost their grip." Chappy is swept after a much more old- fashioned child, wholly unlike the sugar-doped Matthew: Alice herself; delightful, lethal, "the devil".
Delicately, Homes presents a panorama of paedophilia in its cultural and historical context. Its facets flash by as the culture dumbs down (Chappy is white trash compared to Humbert Humbert).
We meet the changing images and expectations of childhood, our deeply savoured repulsion towards its abusers, the gross dichotomy in our attitudes towards woman and boy, man and little girl. And then the infinitely subtle, sadomasochistic nature of such encounters - the zigzag of power and seduction from one to the other and the terrible misreading of signals on both sides that can constitute paedophilia.
Chappy, like Humbert, is something more devious than an unreliable narrator. It takes a very close reading indeed to differentiate between fact and fantasy in his memories, between truth and the self-serving pleadings of a murderous paedophile. That we can still see Chappy as a victim, even throughout the utter agony of what happened to Alice, is a tribute to Homes's genius.
They meet by the waterside - like Poe and his lost Annabel Lee, or Humbert and his first nymphet. Alice at 12 is bewitching, feral, precocious, with poetry written on the soles of all her shoes - including Plath's "Out of the ash I rise with my red hair/And I eat men like air." "She was the one," he writes, "one in a million", recalling his wretchedness even in bliss. Again we hear the whispers from Lolita when Alice initiates sex with Chappy. Like Lolita, she has had previous experience (almost certainly abuse) but is not quite prepared for the adult reality: "it was she... who took me" with an "apparent, if addled understanding of adult desire".
The final 100 pages are a miracle of controlled cohesion. The present (Chappy's appearance before the parole board) and the past (his time with Alice) combine seamlessly in his drugged mind. A symmetry of the senses has seldom been better evoked.
Despite a few moments of wobbly judgement, stagey stylishness and a love of alliteration, this is everything fiction should be - wrenching, disturbing and emotive. Shame on the British publishers who rejected it (such as HarperCollins). And congratulations to Anchor's Jon Saddler, who argues that "people don't have to read it, just as they don't have to see Sensation".
Homes seems to acknowledge Nabokov, rightly, as il miglior fabbro. She implicitly includes her own work in the process of general cultural deterioration. "Is being explicit the same as being pornographic?" she has asked. Read. Re-read.
The "A", by the way, stands for Amy.
Life & Style blogs
Watching TV after work makes you feel 'guilty and like a failure'
NHS medics are being lured away to Australia by more money, status and sunshine, survey suggests
Xiaomi Mi4: 'Chinese Apple' launches flagship mobile to challenge iPhone
Have sex with your iPad thanks to the new sex toy no-one asked for
Condom couture: Latex dresses hit the catwalk to raise awareness for HIV and Aids
The 'scroungers’ fight back: The welfare claimants battling to alter stereotypes
Arizona execution lasts two hours as killer Joseph Wood left 'snorting and gasping' for air
Malaysia Airlines MH17 crash: Ukrainian military jet was flying close to passenger plane before it was shot down, says Russian officer
Malaysia Airlines MH17 crash: Massive rise in sale of British arms to Russia
A day in the life of Vladimir Putin: The dictator in his labyrinth
Malaysia Airlines MH17 crash: victims’ bodies bundled in black bags and loaded onto trains
- 1 Is Gideon Levy the most hated man in Israel or just the most heroic?
- 2 Students offered grants if they tweet pro-Israeli propaganda
- 3 Satellite full of sexually experimental geckos adrift in space, Russia loses control of mission
Highly Competitive Salary: Austen Lloyd: MANCHESTER - Senior Employment Solici...
£600 - £650 per day: Orgtel: Conduct Risk Liaison Manager - Banking - London -...
Highly Attractive Package: Austen Lloyd: CITY - COMMERCIAL LITIGATION - GLOBAL...
£65000 - £75000 per annum + Benefits: Progressive Recruitment: The client is a...