Chess

William Hartston
Monday 20 January 1997 00:02 GMT
Comments

When I first saw the closing position of this study by David Gurgenidze, I found it difficult to believe. White is a rook and pawn behind, with no threats, and it's Black's move. Yet it's a draw.

Starting in the diagram, it's White to play and draw and his first task is to cope with the threat of Rxb1+. Since 1.Qc2+ Qxc2+ 2.Kxc2 Rxb1 gives Black an easy win, the first move is easy enough: 1.Qf7+ when Kxb1 allows immediate mate on b3. So Black plays instead 1...Kb2 and now what? White will not survive long if he plays 2.Qf6+ Kxb1 3.Qxb6+ Ka2+. Something more drastic is called for.

Well, if you can't find a perpetual check, look for a stalemate. So let's get on with it: 2.Rg2+! Qxg2 3.Qf2+! and if Black takes the queen the goal is achieved. But he needn't oblige, for now it's Black's turn to be clever with 3...Kb3! when 4.Qxg2 loses to Rxb1+ followed by Rb2+.

There is nothing for it but to return to the perpetual check idea: 4.Qxb6+ Ka2 (the only place to hide from an otherwise endless series of checks) and now since Qf2+ no longer gives a stalemate when captured, it has to be 5.Qe6+ Kxb1 6.Qb3+ Qb2.

Now White seems totally lost. After he checks on d3, the black king sidles back to a2, discovering a fatal check from the rook. It seems to be all over, but White has a remarkable resource: 7.Qc4!!

Now if Black's queen moves up the board, then Qc2 will be mate, if she moves sideways, then Qb3+ will force repetition of moves. 7...a2 lets White force mate with 8.Qd3+ so the only try is 7...Ra2 when White plays 8.Qb4!! Ka1 9.Qc3!! Kb1 10.Qb4. If the queen is taken, it is stalemate, otherwise Black cannot escape the merry-go-round. A remarkable draw.

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

Comments

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in