Girl power: who's buying it?
Raunchy music by girls, `filthy' books by girls ... They call it the new feminism, so why is it aimed at 7-year-olds instead of grown-up women? Eleanor Bailey reports
Sunday 24 November 1996
Cultural phenomena are like haircuts. They used to last for years but now experts recommend that you get a new one every six weeks. The latest in the phenomenon line is Girl Power. Personified by the Spice Girls and vilifed by the over-40s, girl power is the babeish answer to the Loaded Lad: girls going wild, showing their knickers and going on drinking sprees, on behalf of women and record companies everywhere.
What is Girl (or, correctly, Grrrl) Power all about? It is raunchy music by girls, "filthy" books by girls, defiant statements about men by girls in provocative clothes. It is about marketing men making money, it is about media folk filling ravenous newspapers. It is about thirtysomethings clucking over the collapse of the principles they valued in the punk era, and about pre-teenyboppers enjoying themselves. "I love the Spice Girls'' says Laura, aged seven and a half, who has seen them in concert." They are as good as The Beatles. I just love their music and I especially love their clothes. I want to look like Melanie. I have a knitted red T-shirt like her. But I am a bit cynical. They are just another pop group, really."
Confusingly, some girl power is good and some is bad, hereinafter (G) and (B). Then there is, of course, some bad that comes out ironically good (IG) and some of the ought-to-be-good that is unintentionally very bad (UB).
The Spice Girls (G, or perhaps B) are five nice, middle-class girls who have been transformed into hell-raising international pop superstars in five months. Their cultural output includes ``Wannabe'', a number one single in 23 countries which features the neo-feminist refrain, ``If you wanna be my lover, you gotta get on with my friends'', and the my-body- is-my-tool statement by singer Victoria Adams when she flashed all in an American hotel. They perform girl power salutes (B) and shout obscenities to workmen (IG).
The jaundiced newspaper world enjoyed revealing that the Spice Girls are middle-class fakes. But the Spice Girls don't mind. Their defiance isn't real anyway. For defiance these days is a form of obedience, since it is playing by the rules of the media. As Mel C explained in the Daily Mail: "To be a feminist in the Nineties means having something to say for yourself. You can look like a babe and make as much of a point as if you burnt your bra. There's no way I'm ever burning my Wonderbra. I couldn't; I'm nothing without it." Is this gender politics or vital statistics? Who knows? Who cares? Certainly not the 7-year-olds who are busy trying to attach the item in question to their 7-year-old chests.
The makers of Wonderbra are laughing. In fact a lot of large companies are sitting quietly in the background raking it in. You won't catch Virgin, record company of the Spice Girls, saying much about their feisty clients except that they see girl power as a massive positive force. And they'll stick to that until it's time to sell the fans something new.
If it is anything positive for women, girl power claims to be about girls having the last laugh. ``The whole cultural shift now means that women can wear a baby-doll dress and see-though clothes, and still - if a man touches you - tell him to F off," says Richard Benson, editor of The Face. "There is a massive generation gap between those in their mid-thirties and those who are younger. The younger generation want the escapism of glamorous fashion magazines and hedonism while being aware of the irony. If someone's a fake and middle-class really - so what?"
"There is always something real behind a marketing hype,'' agrees Al Deakin, lecturer in Cultural Studies at Westminster University, ``if it is truly manufactured, the audience doesn't fall for it. Surely the Spice Girls are a better role model for young girls, being feisty and humorous, than Mariah Carey?'' Yet if girl power really is the new feminism, why is it that pre-pubescent girls and middle-aged men are so far the main beneficiaries?
Where the Spice Girls lead, many are eager to follow. Tampasm is a Brighton based all-girl band made up of girls who have just finished their A-levels. Their first single ``Taxi Head Butt'' (B-side ``Glorified Vibrator'') has just come out. They, too, know that the pop game is played on many levels, that outrageous is the ticket to stardom. ``Since we've been going our bass player died of an overdose and apparently I've had an abortion with a rusty coathanger,'' says Charlotte Clark, 18, cheerily. ``We'd rather have the rumours, you need them to get noticed.''
To this end guitarist Oli says ``my guitar's not a penis extension but it makes a damn good vibrator''. Charlotte has threatened to kill somebody if she doesn't achieve huge stardom and talks lovingly about her porn video collection. "I love porn," she says. "I want to be a porn star."
What they all really, really want, they say, is to get taken seriously and they know that this is the way to do it. Likewise they are really feminists, but they can't admit it. ``If you say you're a feminist,'' says Charlotte, then everyone says, "Oh, she thinks all men are walking abortions. But feminist ideals - ie that we want to be equal - are taken for granted, really.''
This view is typical of this generation, according to Christine Griffin, social psychologist at Birmingham University, who has researched young women's attitudes here and in the States. ``Young women don't call themselves feminists, but they espouse feminist ideas and call themselves Girl Power,'' she explains. ``They say: `I'm not a women's libber, but all rapists should be castrated'. The point is that there isn't any one definition of feminism: it's a construct that changes over time.'' Griffin links girl power to the Riot Girls phenomenon in the States, where young women form groups and write fanzines supporting "girl" issues and outrageous behaviour without linking up with traditional feminist groups.
Those who support it say it's not the fault of girl power that the (male) establishment makes a packet out of it too. It is simply how things are. The launch of the girl power magazine Minx (`for girls with a lust for life") a couple of months ago was not, of course, a desire by publishers Emap to redress the balance between the sexes, but a desire to latch on to a good thing. This does not mean that Minx couldn't strike out on behalf of girl power, but, as it happens, it doesn't much. For sadly, whereas Loaded's noxious semi-pornographic yobbism masquerading as irony hits the spot (to the extent that it has almost as many female fans as male), Minx's female counterblast achieves the one thing that is truly offensive - it isn't funny. It tries and fails, trying too hard to play the boys at their own game, and adding weight to the belief that men are funnier.
There is the same problem with girl power television. The ghastly Girlie Show (UB) kicks off a new series in January. But both it and dreadful Pyjama Party tried to break the mould and have not as yet been successful. According to a Girlie Show insider, the blonde, boorish, babeish presenter Sarah goes down a storm with men but tends to annoy women - hardly a rip-roaring triumph for the new feminism.
If it is to be more than a marketing gimmick, girl power has to appeal to, not alienate, women above the age of 12. While the sexual agenda is addressed in shiny hot pants and sponsored by middle-aged man plc, the bubblegum will inevitably burst.
1 Grrl Power 1996 (autumn)
2 New Lass 1996 (spring)
3 New Lad 1995
4 Babeism 1994/95
5 Androgny and bisexuality - 1993 6 Grunge - 1992
everybody drops out but
thinks society sucks
7 Slacker - 1991 everybody drops out but in
8 New Man 1980 to 1991
9 Raveism 1989/90 - everybody freaks out and wears yellow
10 Thatcherism - pre-1989 Dark Ages (see: Michael J Fox)
Life & Style blogs
Planes go hybrid-electric in important step to greener flight
GTA 5: Christmas arrives in Los Santos as update brings snowball fights, festive jumpers and a homing missile launcher
'Tis the season!: Google celebrates Christmas Eve with second animated Doodle
Christmas 2014: Jesus was not born in a stable, says theologian
Pornhub: Kim Kardashian's sex tape is the most-watched porn video of all-time
Nigel Farage defends Kerry Smith 'ch***y' comment: 'If you are going for a Chinese, what do you say you’re going for?'
Rozanne Duncan: Ukip expels councillor for 'jaw-dropping' comments made in BBC TV interview
British actor Idris Elba cannot star as James Bond because he is black, says shock jock Rush Limbaugh
Germany anti-Islam protests: 17,000 march on Dresden against 'Islamification of the West'
Panic Saturday: 13 million Britons spend £1.2bn – while 13 million others across the country live in poverty unable to afford food
BBC director Danny Cohen: Rising UK antisemitism makes me feel more uncomfortable than ever
- 1 Planes go hybrid-electric in important step to greener flight
- 3 Antonio Martin shooting: Mayor says there should be 'no comparison' to Ferguson
£20000 - £35000 per annum: Recruitment Genius: This full service social media ...
£24000 - £35000 per annum: Recruitment Genius: We are 'Changemakers in retail'...
Very Competitive: Austen Lloyd: Senior Conveyancer - South West We are see...
Excellent Salary: Austen Lloyd: DORSET MARKET TOWN - SENIOR PROPERTY SOLICITOR...