Jeremy Laurance: Social services cannot recruit because of the Baby P effect

Medical Life

News in pictures
News in pictures
On Facebook
Life & Style blogs

HIV orphans in Thailand prepare for the future

In Baan Gerda, a community for HIV infected or affected youngsters in Northern Thailand, a group of ...

Online House Hunter: England’s most romantic places

Our Online House Hunter goes in search of romance this Valentine's Day...

Online House Hunter: Rugby – a Dickens of a town

Charles Dickens didn't think much of the railway town of Rugby in Warwickshire, calling it Mugby. Bu...

Last week was a grim one in the annals of child protection. On the same day that Baby P's abusers were sentenced following one of the grossest professional failures in recent memory, the controversial paediatrician David Southall, who pioneered covert video surveillance to detect child abuse, learnt that his career was over. His appeal to the High Court against a decision by the General Medical Council to strike him off the register was dismissed.

The criticism of the professionals in the Baby P case was that they did not act swiftly or decisively enough to protect the 17-month-old when signs emerged of his ill treatment. The criticism of Southall was that he acted too swiftly and decisively to protect a child he believed to be at risk – acting in an "offensive" and "unjustified" manner.

The end in both cases is tragedy – a baby has lost his life and a crusading paediatrician has lost his livelihood. The hope is that these events will improve the protection of children. But will they?

Social services departments cannot recruit to their benighted profession, because of the Baby P effect, and there is an alarming swing against parental rights, which means more children judged "at risk" will be removed from their homes into the frequently damaging realm of state care.

Meanwhile paediatricians with one of the toughest jobs in medicine – distinguishing accidental from non-accidental injury – are left badly undermined by the spectacle of a doctor of international renown suffering professional extinction.

Southall was found to have accused a mother of drugging and murdering her 10-year-old son, who was found hanging from a curtain rail in 1996. He denied this, insisting he had raised it as one possible scenario to explain the death, in the course of assessing whether it was safe to leave her caring for her other son.

The judge in last week's appeal did not believe him or the social worker who backed his account. The accusation was "truly shocking", "offensive" and "inconsistent with the status of an independent expert," the judge said. He concluded that the GMC had been right to strike Southall off.

Anyone who has followed David Southall's career could not doubt his energy, industry and commitment to the cause of child protection. That very commitment has, however, made him the target of a vicious campaign orchestrated by a small group of affected parents, aided by certain sections of the media. The GMC, and now the courts, have found that he made serious errors of judgment. That is as may be. But given the fevered atmosphere in which he worked – under constant threat of verbal, physical and legal assault – is the punishment appropriate to the crime?

The GMC is confident that, having won the court's backing, it did the right thing by striking Dr Southall off, to "protect the public interest". In truth, this is a nasty case that has decided very little – and will do nothing to encourage other paediatricians in this desperately difficult line of work.

Independent Comment
blog comments powered by Disqus
Career Services

Day In a Page

No secularism please, we're British

No secularism please, we're British

Arguments about the role of religion in national life have recently acquired a new urgency
Harold Tillman: 'Chinese tourists can save the high street – if we let them'

Harold Tillman interview

'Chinese tourists can save the high street – if we let them'
Working as a jail torturer ruined my life

Working as a jail torturer ruined my life

Meet the former soldier who has joined the political prisoners he tortured in Turkey's Mamak prison by suing the generals who led a regime of terror
The local high street jet shop

The local high street jet shop

Got a spare $50m and can't stand the queues at Heathrow? Get yourself down to London's first private plane dealership
Do you like your doctor? It could be the death of you

Do you like your doctor?

It could be the death of you...
The mysterious affair of how Agatha Christie is teaching foreigners English

How Agatha Christie is teaching foreigners English

Twenty of the author's novels have been adapted and presented with learning notes and a CD
Six Grammys, five years off: Adele puts love before career

Six Grammys, five years off

Adele puts love before career
The 10 Best binoculars

The 10 Best binoculars

From no-frills to bins with digital cameras
Milan for £300

Milan for £300?

A cultural family holiday - on a budget - to Italy's most stylish city
'Black-hole' resorts: Turn up, tune out, log off

'Black-hole' resorts

Turn up, tune out, log off
New Arsenal face an old question of credibility in San Siro

New Arsenal face an old question of credibility in San Siro

Remodelled since winning in Milan in 2008, for all their consistency – and prize-money – Wenger's side are yet to claim a European title
James Lawton: This prodigal son deserves no forgiveness

James Lawton: This prodigal son deserves no forgiveness

City would be putting their desire to win title ahead of morals if Tevez plays for them
Mark Cavendish: Is Olympic gold at end of the rainbow?

Mark Cavendish interview

Is Olympic gold at end of the rainbow?
Apple admits it has a human rights problem

Apple admits it has a human rights problem

After years of complaints and workers' suicides in China the technology giant faces up to the human cost of its gadgets
Peter Moore: 'I feel guilty I'm the only one alive'

Peter Moore interview

'I feel guilty I'm the only one alive'