Doctors call for booze ad ban
Digg
del.icio.us
Facebook
Reddit
Google
Stumble Upon
Fark
Newsvine
YahooBuzz
Bebo
Twitter
Independent Minds
Alcohol advertising should be banned and a minimum price introduced to stop people drinking too much, doctors said today.
They called for a minimum price of 50p per unit of alcohol, echoing demands from the Government's chief medical officer earlier this year.
Prime Minister Gordon Brown has given a lukewarm response to Sir Liam Donaldson's idea, saying he wants to protect the "sensible majority of moderate drinkers".
But doctors backed Sir Liam by a majority today, saying more needs to be done to tackle the UK's drinking culture.
Those attending the British Medical Association (BMA) conference in Liverpool heard how one in four adults are drinking at levels that are hazardous to their health and 36,000 11 to 15-year-olds get drunk every week.
Paediatrician Dr Keith Brent, from Bournemouth, said one of his first questions when he goes to work on a Saturday morning is to ask how many teenagers have been brought in drunk overnight.
He warned that teenagers get "tanked up" on cheap booze bought at supermarkets before heading out for a night on the town.
He blamed "really cheap cider, cheap cheap vodka and alcopops", adding that he saw one or two teenagers every Saturday morning who had overdone it.
He said the numbers were "much greater" than a decade ago and hospitals across the country were experiencing the same problem.
Dr Brent accused the Government of ignoring findings of reviews they have commissioned themselves which show that introducing minimum pricing cuts drinking among both young people and heavy drinkers.
"The Government are doing what they have done in the past with these public health measures - pushing them into the long grass," he said.
"They already have the evidence, they already know what the answer is."
Dr Brent said it was "ludicrous" for the Government to continue to refuse a minimum price on the grounds it would unduly hit the majority of responsible drinkers.
The research showed it would add just 23p per week to the cost of their alcohol, he said.
"Once again the Government in England is bowing down to big business," he added.
The Scottish Government is currently considering introducing a minimum price per unit of alcohol of between 40p and 50p.
Dr Chandra Mohan, from London, who proposed today's motion, said research showed there could be a cut of 100,000 hospital admissions every year in England if minimum pricing was introduced.
Over a decade, health savings would be £1.37 billion.
Dr Charles Daniels, from the BMA's GPs committee, spoke against the motion, saying it was "nanny state politics" and would "punish the majority for the sins of the minority".
A spokesman for the Department of Health, said: "The Government has decided not to proceed with any national or local measures around minimum unit price.
"While there is good evidence that cheap alcohol is linked to people drinking more and subsequent harm to their health, it is important that any Government interventions reduce harm without impacting unduly on the majority of responsible drinkers. We will look to develop further the evidence base in this area."
View all comments that have been posted about this article.
Offensive or abusive comments will be removed and your IP logged and may be used to prevent further submission. In submitting a comment to the site, you agree to be bound by the Independent Minds Terms of Service.
- Print Article
- Email Article
-
Click here for copyright permissions
Copyright 2009 Independent News and Media Limited
Comments
AND there's a green space where they could piss, but no! Most of them prefer to piss on someone's door!
:)
And yet, they want to outlaw the "legal highs" that are currently available, without any evidence that they actually cause any significant harm, or negative social effects.
Can anyone help to explain this discrepancy? Is it that the lobby of alcohol manufacturers is too influential?
It may be that the pub for the English is where experience is shared and political ideas get discussed, better stop that eh, job nearly done ?
Another may be that a populus who are numbed, depressed poor and apathetic through constant binges of alcohol is easier to manage or manipulate than one that wakes up fresh and lively each day. 10 out of 10 on this one Right Honourable Gentlemen.
Could be the donations of a Mr Sainsbury to the Labour Party, fairly unlikely though.
Or look up the two largest breweries in the world and consolidation in the global brewing industry over the past five years with particular attention to these brewers share of each national market.
For fun pay specific attention to the tied bar model introduced in the U.K. its results and property speculation as a means of reducing pub numbers. Always ask to what end and whose benefit (and loss) ?
Our government is not governing or legislating in the interests of the people in Britain.
The dead men said this is because Greed and Luxury will always undo democracy, that is why it is our duty to repair and protect it as best we can until such time as it can be repaired no more.
Alcohol is a drug , it is being abused , it costs the country billions in lost work hours,policing and health . Allowing it to continue being romanticised and made to look like a trendy humourous and glamourous habit is ignorant and unnacceptable.
Alcohol advertising should be stopped now , as should sales at pocket money prices .