In the raw: Question marks over milk

Unpasteurised milk is the latest superfood – nutritious, delicious and packed with friendly bacteria. But is it safe? By Anastasia Stephens reports

News in pictures
News in pictures
On Facebook
Life & Style blogs

HIV orphans in Thailand prepare for the future

In Baan Gerda, a community for HIV infected or affected youngsters in Northern Thailand, a group of ...

Online House Hunter: England’s most romantic places

Our Online House Hunter goes in search of romance this Valentine's Day...

Online House Hunter: Rugby – a Dickens of a town

Charles Dickens didn't think much of the railway town of Rugby in Warwickshire, calling it Mugby. Bu...

Prince Charles has been a fan for years. Now the health-conscious tribes of LA and New York are claiming that it can help everything from childhood allergies and eczema to digestive disorders. Raw, unpasteurised milk, straight from the cow, is making a comeback – and it's starting to catch on over here.

Indeed, UK producers report that demand for the "real" white stuff is stronger than ever, and growing. Sold in "green label" bottles from farms and farmers' markets, popularity is spreading fast, mostly through personal recommendation.

At the Chelsea Farmers Market, raw milk is one of the most popular dairy products. And at Meadow Cottage Farm, a Surrey supplier, demand is outstripping supply. "We sell 50 litres a day but customer demand just seems to keep growing," says Celia Haynes of Meadow Cottage, which specialises in unpasteurised milk and cream produced by the family's herd of Jersey cows. "We don't just get local customers coming to the farm – people travel for miles, and buy in bulk. Unpasteurised milk has a rich but refreshing flavour which adults and children seem to love."

It's not just about the taste, though. One study published in The Internet Journal of Asthma, Allergy and Immunology found that raw milk reduced children's risk of suffering allergy-related conditions by up to 40 per cent. There are overall nutritional benefits, too. Proponents say that unpasteurised milk is so packed with nutrients that it's a virtual superfood. Unlike heat-treated milk, it is full of beneficial gut bacteria, known to improve digestion and immunity. Raw milk contains a full complement of folic acid, B vitamins, vitamin C, omega-3 fatty acids and other nutrients that are partially or completely destroyed in pasteurisation. Raw milk drinkers also benefit from digestive enzymes, as well as something called Wulzen factor, a compound that combats arthritis and arterial stiffening. Some people with a history of digestive tract problems such as Crohn's disease swear by the curative powers of unpasteurised milk; others praise its nutritional value and its ability to strengthen the immune system.

Proponents of raw milk argue that pasteurisation, a process in which milk is heated to 71C for short bursts followed by rapid cooling, destroys much of the nutrition in milk. For example, pasteurisation breaks down lactase, an enzyme that helps digest the milk-sugar lactose, meaning that lactose-intolerant individuals can drink raw milk but not pasteurised milk. Raw milk supporters also argue that pasteurisation renders calcium more difficult for the body to absorb. Meanwhile, the widespread process of homogenisation, in which the milk fat is evenly distributed throughout the liquid, can make the drink harder to digest.

The product remains controversial, though. It is potentially a source of food- poisoning bugs such as salmonella, listeria and E.coli. In Britain, the Food Standards Agency says tests on raw milk show that it can contain illness-causing pathogens. Scotland banned it 20 years ago; in England and Wales, sales are restricted to farmer's markets or directly from farm shops, with labels clearly warning of the risk.

"Pasteurisation is there as a safety net to kill off any bugs in milk," says Lisa Miles of the British Nutrition Foundation. "Without it, the risks would be just too great."

But the farmers who make it say that their raw milk is made to a strict standard. John Barron, of Beaconshill Farm in Herefordshire, points out that stringent regulations to ensure the safety of raw milk tend to mean that the cows are significantly healthier than those on commercial farms. "The simple fact is, we've never had a single case of food poisoning," he says.

Celia Haynes agrees. "We undergo four spot-checks a year, looking at the health and cleanliness of our animals," she says. "The milk itself has to undergo checks for levels of harmful bacteria to ensure it is safe. Think about it: healthier cows mean healthier milk."

The research has certainly been promising so far. Prompted by figures showing that children growing up on farms are less likely to develop allergies, scientists at the University of London gave children a couple of glasses of raw milk a week. They found that it seemed to cut their chances of developing hay fever by 10 per cent and eczema by 38 per cent. They also looked at blood samples from 4,700 primary-school children in Shropshire, and found that raw milk drinkers, most of whom lived on farms, had 60 per cent lower levels of immunoglobulin E – an antibody that the body's immune system pumps out in huge quantities on exposure to an allergen. Levels of histamine, another chemical that is released by cells during an allergic reaction, were halved.

These findings aren't news to raw milk producers: their customers report real improvements to their children's skin and respiratory health. "Our customers are convinced the milk is good for their health," says Barron. "Many have reported improvements to allergy symptoms in themselves or their children while drinking unpasteurised milk. Others have found that bloating and other digestive difficulties have settled down."

Sam Jennings, 42, a schoolteacher from Walton-on-Thames, Surrey, had his first taste of unpasteurised milk on holiday in the Channel Islands four years ago. "It was so delicious, we tracked down a local producer when we came home. It is really thirst quenching and pleasant, so we switched to it.

"Then we noticed a surprising change in our seven-year-old son. His lungs were often tight and wheezy. But after a few days of drinking the new milk, his breathing got better; his symptoms had pretty much disappeared. We are convinced the benefit came from the milk. On the occasions we've run out of it and gone back to the commercial variety, his wheezing has returned."

None the less, Lisa Miles warns that those who drink raw milk should be careful. "I'd advise pregnant women to steer clear, as should elderly people or those with weak immune systems," she says. "It may be popular and even healthy. But that doesn't necessarily mean its safe."

What's in raw milk

* According to the Campaign for Real Milk, a US-based organisation, raw milk contains 10 per cent more B vitamins and 25 per cent more vitamin C.

* Raw milk is rich in CLA, a "superfat" that helps promote weight loss and is alleged to have anti-cancer properties.

* Unlike pasteurised milk, raw milk contains the enzyme lactase, which breaks down the milk-sugar lactose. This means that it can be drunk by people who are lactose-intolerant.

* Raw milk generally contains more omega-3 fats, and as they're not corrupted by heat treatment, they're better for you.

* It's a rich source of probiotic bacteria, which boost immunity and aid digestion.

* It may be richer in nutrients and vitamins overall, as animals are grass-fed and kept to high standards. As many producers are organic, the milk is more likely to be free of growth hormones and antibiotics.

* Raw milk is sold at farmers markets or direct from dairy farms (www.seedsofhealth.co.uk/resources/dairy). Raw goat's milk is available via mail order from Bevital.com (08707 879904), and in London from the Chelsea Farmers Market (020-7351 4321).

Independent Comment
blog comments powered by Disqus
Career Services

Day In a Page

No secularism please, we're British

No secularism please, we're British

Arguments about the role of religion in national life have recently acquired a new urgency
Harold Tillman: 'Chinese tourists can save the high street – if we let them'

Harold Tillman interview

'Chinese tourists can save the high street – if we let them'
Working as a jail torturer ruined my life

Working as a jail torturer ruined my life

Meet the former soldier who has joined the political prisoners he tortured in Turkey's Mamak prison by suing the generals who led a regime of terror
The local high street jet shop

The local high street jet shop

Got a spare $50m and can't stand the queues at Heathrow? Get yourself down to London's first private plane dealership
Do you like your doctor? It could be the death of you

Do you like your doctor?

It could be the death of you...
The mysterious affair of how Agatha Christie is teaching foreigners English

How Agatha Christie is teaching foreigners English

Twenty of the author's novels have been adapted and presented with learning notes and a CD
Six Grammys, five years off: Adele puts love before career

Six Grammys, five years off

Adele puts love before career
The 10 Best binoculars

The 10 Best binoculars

From no-frills to bins with digital cameras
Milan for £300

Milan for £300?

A cultural family holiday - on a budget - to Italy's most stylish city
'Black-hole' resorts: Turn up, tune out, log off

'Black-hole' resorts

Turn up, tune out, log off
New Arsenal face an old question of credibility in San Siro

New Arsenal face an old question of credibility in San Siro

Remodelled since winning in Milan in 2008, for all their consistency – and prize-money – Wenger's side are yet to claim a European title
James Lawton: This prodigal son deserves no forgiveness

James Lawton: This prodigal son deserves no forgiveness

City would be putting their desire to win title ahead of morals if Tevez plays for them
Mark Cavendish: Is Olympic gold at end of the rainbow?

Mark Cavendish interview

Is Olympic gold at end of the rainbow?
Apple admits it has a human rights problem

Apple admits it has a human rights problem

After years of complaints and workers' suicides in China the technology giant faces up to the human cost of its gadgets
Peter Moore: 'I feel guilty I'm the only one alive'

Peter Moore interview

'I feel guilty I'm the only one alive'