LJK Setright: 'Safety' features can be downright dangerous

Forty years ago, the American lawyer Ralph Nader was preparing his book
Unsafe at Any Speed for publication in 1966.

Forty years ago, the American lawyer Ralph Nader was preparing his book Unsafe at Any Speed for publication in 1966. What began as a vicious criticism of General Motors and its Chevrolet Corvair (a car based on dubious Porsche design philosophy and no less vicious in its aberrations) swiftly grew into a tirade against the entire motor industry. Every manufacturer was portrayed as a callous purveyor of intrinsically dangerous cars.

The US government was delighted. This domestic issue would take minds off Vietnam. The protest grew into a consumerist movement with Nader as its god, and the liberation of purchasers from all responsibility as its aim. The doctrine of absolute liability of manufacturers for any mishap, even if caused by the customer's stupidity, took hold.

Before long, the safety-mongering business was in full swing. The US insurance industry thought to cut its losses on petty collisions by procuring legislation demanding that bumpers should survive a 5mph impact - only to find that an impact at 6mph or more would now prove much more costly. Cars had to be designed so that their occupants might survive being driven into a concrete block at 30mph: long crushable structures were added at nose and tail; and by putting on weight in quite the wrong places, cars became less controllable than before. The car most likely to survive an accident was the car most likely to have one.

The idea that a car competent to avoid an accident might be preferable to the car able to survive one carried no weight. Manufacturers committed to volume sales sought customers - and those customers regarded driving skills as no part of their obligation. It was up to the manufacturers to make their cars "safe". The customers would not even wear safety belts, unless laws requiring them were strenuously enforced.

The demands of safety legislation grew ever stiffer. Crash tests became more varied, more difficult. Airbags were introduced, and spread into the most unlikely places: today, they aretucked into windscreen pillars, thickening them and so reducing the field of view, making the car potentially more dangerous. To protect pedestrians, new regulations call for sloping pillars that have to be thickened for strength, reducing the view even more.

If there has been one worthwhile safety-oriented development, it has been anti-lock braking. Full marks to Bosch, which brought the first ABS (German abbreviation for the system) to market in 1978 - but what happened? BMW and Mercedes-Benz were both scheduled to adopt the system, and had agreed to announce it simultaneously; but Mercedes-Benz jumped the embargo. It showed no trace of remorse: working the safety racket successfully sells cars.

It still does. Today's cars come with festoons of electronic circuitry, contriving to prevent wheelspin, correct skids, stop you wandering out of your lane, discourage you from tailgating, and even to initiate braking.

Already there are plenty of cars available with twice as much horsepower as sufficed to carry Lindbergh to Paris in 1927. Put an unskilled driver into something so powerful, and he may well find himself in difficulties. He will blame the manufacturer, not himself, so into his overpowered car go all these systems which are all subtractive - that is, they work by reducing the car's performance.

The best example of an additive safety system, one that enhances the car's accident-avoidance ability, was the active four-wheel steering of the Honda Prelude. Shallow-brained salesmen did not know how to sell it, so Honda does not make it any more.

Like all the others, it is forced to follow the new fashion for tall vehicles, even though such things are fundamentally less stable. It is this trend that forces me to reckon that our safest cars were those from 10-15 years ago.

Independent Comment
blog comments powered by Disqus
Career Services

Day In a Page

Is Ridley Scott the most macho man in movies?

Ridley Scott: The most macho man in movies?

His cinematic CV is unparalleled. Yet the Alien director is still obsessed with beating his rivals.
Being Gary Lineker: The clean-cut anchorman is this summer's Mr Sport

Being Gary Lineker

The clean-cut anchorman is this summer's Mr Sport...
Gallic gourmets are putting French cuisine back on the culinary map

Gallic gourmets put France back on culinary map

Overdone, out of touch and old-fashioned: French cuisine has never been at a lower ebb...
So Moorish: Mark Hix offers his own take on classic Moroccan dishes

So Moorish: Mark Hix's Moroccan dishes

Why not create a north African-inspired feast to share with your friends?
Sin and the single mother: The history of lone parenthood

Sin and the single mother

Maureen Paton explores the history of lone parenthood.
The outsider: Margaret Howell is British fashion's queen of minimalism

The outsider: Margaret Howell

The designer tells Susannah Frankel why she has never felt part of the fashion industry.
The 50 Best luggage

The 50 Best luggage

From chic cases to compact baggage, pack it all in this summer
For men only: A pilgrimage to Mount Athos in Greece

For men only: A pilgrimage to Mount Athos

On a secluded peninsula in north-east Greece lies an enclave that's way off the tourist map, especially for women...
48 Hours In: Faro

48 Hours In: Faro

More than just the gateway to the Algarve, this city has much to tempt you off the beach.
Here, the coast is always clear: Celebrating sixty years of Pembrokeshire's National Park

60 years of Pembrokeshire's National Park

Mick Webb reveals a land of puffins, tanks and Hollywood blockbusters.
Free Range: Meet the designers of tomorrow

Free Range

Meet the artists of the future
Feeding a hungry world – or meddling with laws of nature?

Feeding a hungry world – or meddling with laws of nature?

As scientists at Rothamsted's GM trials plead with activists not to sabotage their work, Michael McCarthy visits the battle field
Monkey meat that could be behind the next HIV

Monkey meat that could be behind the next HIV

Deep in Cameroon's rainforests, poachers are killing primates for food. Evan Williams reports from Yokadouma on a practice that could create a pandemic
Catcalls, whistles, groping: just another day for a young woman

Catcalls, whistles, groping: just another day for a young woman

Government urged to take abuse more seriously as London study shows 41 per cent are harassed
Jailing of Maori separatists stirs colonial-era resentment

Jailing of Maori separatists stirs colonial-era resentment

Militant Tuhoe tribe members defiant amid claims race relations had been set back 100 years