What makes a man ‘alpha’? Perhaps he’s confident, successful, strong, brave, charming, tall and attractive.
Men want to be him, women want to be with him. He gets his way and picks up women with ease. Everyone loves him.
Or so we’re led to believe.
This James Bond-like idea of an alpha male - in contrast to beta males (shy, weak, nerdy - you know the stereotype) - is one that prevails in our culture. The same concept for women, however, is barely given a second thought.
But can men really be divided into alpha and beta (and perhaps even omega)? Or is it just a case of some people being more confident than others?
According to Stefan Djordjevic, not only do alpha males exist, but anyone can learn to be one.
Djordjevic runs an online course called “How to Approach Women - Effective Ways to Be More Alpha.” He believes that “studying female behaviour is a science just like biology and physics” and revealed to The Independent that he’s been on over 150 dates in the past four years.
If Djordjevic is to be believed, men can learn to be more confident with women, and he endeavours to teach them his ways.
“The course is designed for people who are shy, awkward or strange in some way,” he says. “I used to be extremely shy and awkward, until I learned the secrets to public speaking and female-male conversation. I don't think I'll ever go back!”
As you might expect, the majority of his clients are single males between the ages of 18 and 27 who - in Djordjevic’s words - “need an extra boost when it comes to talking to women. Whether that's fear of rejection, lack of confidence, or an underlying social phobia, the course helps to break through that barrier.”
They all believe they can become alpha men and turn their lives around.
The trouble with the sound of Djordjevic’s course is that he seems to suggest there’s a one-size-fits-all approach to picking up women, and that being confident with women is all it means to be alpha.
However today’s idea of alpha males may actually be more to do with social dominance than anything else:
“Studies have demonstrated that socially dominant men hold sway with many women, and can invoke feelings of inferiority among men,” says clinical psychologist Dr. Vinita Mehta. “Thanks to current research, these men may also be more readily identifiable.”
But when you delve into scientific research, there’s little evidence to suggest alpha males are anything more than a myth.
It’s hard to believe considering how often the idea of alpha males appears in popular culture, but about 50 years ago, it wasn’t a term that was used at all - not outside of the domain of primatology anyway.
The release of the Dutch primatologist Frans de Waal’s book Chimpanzee Politics: Power and Sex Among Apes in 1982 changed things though: “I don’t think the term alpha male was in use outside of primatology when I wrote Chimpanzee Politics,” de Waal told New York Magazine.
Many primates have social hierarchies with one most dominant member at the top, but this isn’t something that works for humans. If it was the same, that would mean there was only one dominant male in every community.
Men don’t work like that - the guy who’s the confident captain of his rugby team could be shy and retiring at work.
“What too often goes missing in discussions about being ‘alpha’ or ‘beta’ is that status is context specific,” says psychologist Scott Barry Kaufman.
“A CEO of a Fortune 500 company has a high level of status in our society, but if he was thrown into the general population at Sing Sing Prison, he’d find himself at the very bottom of the pecking order. You can be an alpha amongst one group, and a beta in another.”
Whilst this might point to an obvious flaw in Djordjevic’s course, he believes all men have the capacity to be alpha or beta and can sway back and forth between the two.
For his part, Kaufman has a problem with the division of men into alpha and beta - he thinks it “greatly simplifies the multi-dimensionality of masculinity, and grossly underestimates what a man is capable of becoming, but it also doesn’t even get at the heart of what is really attractive to women.”
One of the earliest studies into the link between dominance and attraction was conducted in 1987.
The researchers found that while “dominance” was considered sexually attractive, “aggressive” and “domineering” tendencies did not make men more attractive. Which will be unsurprising news to women the world over.
A further study broke down the idea of dominance into two types and found women respond differently to both: whilst being assertive and confident is considered attractive, being demanding, violent or self-centred is not.
In fact, the most attractive combination according to the women in the study was kindness and assertiveness (which, yet again, most women could have told you).
But does that mean the idea of typically alpha men being most attractive to women is a myth? Should males stop trying to become more alpha in the hopes of attracting women?
“In our species, the attainment of social status, and the mating benefits that come along with it, can be accomplished through compassion and cooperation just as much (if not more so) as through aggression and intimidation,” says Kaufman.
Donald Trump's first 100 days: in cartoons
Donald Trump's first 100 days: in cartoons
Donald Trump's first 100 days in office were marred by a string of scandals, many of which caught the eye of the Independent's cartoonists
Trump's first 100 days have seen him aggressively ramp up tensions with his nuclear rivals in North Korea
Mr Trump has warned of a "major, major conflict" with the pariah nation lead by Kim Jong Un
Mr Trump dropped the "mother of all bombs" on alleged ISIS-linked militants in Afghanistan, amid an escalation of US military intervention around the globe
Mr Trump has been accused of falling short of the standards set by his predecessors in the Oval Office, including Franklin D Roosevelt
The tycoon's ascension to the White House came at a time when the balance of power is shifting away from Western nations like those in the G7 group
Western politicians, including the British Conservative party, have been accused of falling in line behind Mr Trump's proposals
Brexit is seen to have weakened Britain, reducing still further any political will to resist American leadership
Mr Trump's leadership has been marked by sudden and unexpected shifts in global policy
Trump's controversial missile strike on Syria, which killed several citizens, was seen by some analysts as an attempt to distract from his policy elsewhere
The President has also spent a large majority of his weekends golfing, rather than attending to matters of state
Though free of gaffes, a visit from Chinese president Xi Jinping spotlighted trade tensions between the two states
One major and unexpected setback came when Mr Trump's Healthcare Bill was struck down by members of his own party
Mr Trump has been a figure of fun in the media, with his approval at record lows
A string of revelations about Mr Trump's financial indiscretions did not mar his surge to the White House
Outgoing President Barack Obama was accused of wiretapping Trump Tower by his successor in America's highest office
The alleged involvement of Russian intelligence operatives in securing Mr Trump the presidency prompted harsh criticism
The explosive resignation of Security Adviser Michael Flynn, who lied about his links to the Russian ambassador, was just one scandal to hit the President
Many scandals, such as the accusation Barack Obama was implicated in phone-hacking, first broke on Mr Trump's Twitter feed
Donald Trump's election provoked mass protests in the UK, with millions signing a petition to ban him from the country
Donald Trump cited a non-existent terror attack in Sweden during a campaign rally
Donald Trump stands accused of stoking regional tensions in Eastern Asia
North Korea has launched a number of failed nuclear tests since Mr Trump took power
Theresa May formally rejected the petition calling for Mr Trump to be banned from the UK
When Mr Trump's initial so-called Muslim ban was struck down by a federal justice, the President mocked the 69-year-old as a "ridiculous", "so-called judge"
A week after his inauguration, Theresa May met with Mr Trump at the White House
Donald Trump's first days in office were marked by a hasty attempt to follow through on many of his campaign promises, including the so-called Muslim ban
Donald Trump's decision to ban citizens of many majority-Muslim countries from the US sparked mass protests
Revelations about Donald Trump's sexual improprieties were not enough to keep him from being elected President
British PM Theresa May was criticised by many in the press for cosying up to the new President
One of Mr Trump's top aides, Kelly Anne Conway, was mocked for describing mistruths as "alternative facts"
British PM Theresa May was quick to demonstrate that her political aims did not hugely differ from Mr Trump's
Donald Trump's inauguration, on 20 January 2017, sparked protests both at home and abroad
So social status can either be achieved through prestige or dominance. The latter would be the traditional alpha, but perhaps the former could be achieved by someone considered more of a beta.
Kaufman is of the opinion that “dominance is a short-term strategy for success; prestige is a long-term one.” Which suggests that no perceived alpha male will remain one forever.
How many of the most popular, attractive and confident boys from your teenage years at school grew into surprisingly beta adults? Exactly.
The black and white notion of alpha and beta men doesn’t hold up because masculinity is much more multidimensional - as are people generally.
“The most attractive male is really a blend of characteristics, including assertiveness, kindness, cultivated skills and a genuine sense of value in this world,” says Kaufman. “The true alpha is fuller, deeper, and richer.”
As neuroscientist Dean Burnett suggested: “Maybe the supposed human alpha male is a combination of disgruntled male wish fulfilment and borderline-pseudoscientific justification for resorting to bullying, intimidation and generally all-round unpleasant behaviour by men hoping to impose their will on a world they find too complex and unnerving so revert to their baser instincts to get what they want, despite knowing deep down they don’t deserve it and shouldn’t have it?”
Maybe indeed.Reuse content