Julian Knight: Pension minister's plan is a flight to fairyland

Suggested Topics

'Too clever by half" is a peculiarly British phrase, summing up our long-standing national mistrust of the intellectual. We laud our Isambard Kingdom Brunels and warriors while the French adore their existentialists and pint-sized painters.

On this basis, I think they'd love our current Pensions Minister Steve Webb in the salons of Paris. For starters he's a professor, recognised as one of the coalition's biggest brains – up there with David "Two Brains" Willetts no less – and takes a very academic approach to his role, carefully weighing up evidence and inviting lots of discussion.

All well and good, and he has been, to date, light years ahead of some of the dullards who passed for pensions ministers under Labour. But in Parisian salon style, Mr Webb is also away with the fairies and I don't mean the green variety. Last week we saw the fruits of his latest burst of intellectualism, his discussion paper on the future of workplace pensions.

The centre piece is Mr Webb's idea for so-called defined ambition pensions. In short, what the prof would like firms to do is to move to a new type of workplace pension which would see risks shared between the employer and employee and be less dependent on the ups and downs of the stock market and interest rates.

In advance of the report, Mr Webb has been travelling the country meeting – in the dire language of modern government – stakeholders, getting them onside. According to officials, several big companies are interested in pursuing the defined ambition route for staff and I'm sure over time some may dabble.

There are lots of lovely platitudes directed at Mr Webb's defined ambition idea – you know the sort of thing: "a welcome addition to the debate", "interesting suggestions that merit further discussion".

In private though, these same people tell me defined ambition is "cloud cuckoo land stuff" and that Mr Webb is indeed "away with the fairies".

Defined ambition could have worked a decade ago when we still had a private-sector final salary pension system (defined ambition could be applied to the public sector but there seems no appetite from Mr Webb for that) and firms were looking for lower-cost less risky alternatives, but we are way beyond that time now.

Overwhelmingly firms have moved to defined contribution where the risks rest wholly on the employee. With the International Monetary Fund reckoning the UK economy will struggle to grow at more than 1.5-2 per cent a year over the long term, are firms really going to move back to a pension system where their risks and costs are upped once again?

What's more, the nature of employment is changing. I have a phrase "we are all freelance now" and we seem to be moving away from standard modes of employment with people more likely to become self-employed or take on contract work. In such a world employers still need to make a contribution to pensions of course, but it won't be through Mr Webb's complex defined ambition model.

He would do better looking at how to get more workers using the schemes they have. Auto enrolment is here for some and will arrive for all soon, but we need to get people genuinely interested in their pensions. This can only be done by letting them access their money when they want and making tax relief simpler and fairer (I would abolish higher rate tax relief on pension contributions and use the cash to boost the basic rate).

Mr Webb, who made a good start to his job as Pensions Minister, needs to forget dreaming his dreams and look at getting what we have now to work better. In the case of defined ambition, Professor Webb has proved too clever by half.

Independent Comment
blog comments powered by Disqus
Finacial products from our partners
News in pictures
World news in pictures
Property search
       

ES Rentals

    Independent Dating
    and  

    By clicking 'Search' you
    are agreeing to our
    Terms of Use.

    iJobs Job Widget
    iJobs Money & Business

    Finance Governance Manager - Banking - £500pd

    £500 per day: Orgtel: A top tier banking client urgently requires Finance Gove...

    Quant Analyst,Front Office/Risk,London,£500-680pd

    £500 - £680 per day: Orgtel: Quantitative Risk Analyst, Front Office/Risk Bank...

    Quant Analyst, Banking, London, £55-60k Per Annum

    £55000 - £60000 per annum + Benefits + Pension: Orgtel: Quantitative Analyst, ...

    Fidessa Analyst / PM - Banking - London - £600pd

    £550 - £600 per day: Orgtel: Fidessa Analyst / PM - Banking - London - Up to £...

    Day In a Page

    'There is a battle going on inside us that is never discussed'

    Masculinity in crisis?

    'There is a battle going on inside us that is never discussed'
    Have US shock jocks gone too far?

    Have US shock jocks gone too far?

    An incendiary remark from Rush Limbaugh may be the beginning of the end for outspoken right-wing US broadcasters
    The ‘Beverly Hills’ of Surrey pays more income tax than big cities of the North

    The ‘Beverly Hills’ of Surrey

    Elmbridge pays more income tax than big cities of the North
    Heavenly Bodies

    Heavenly Bodies

    Michael Landy's artistic marriage made in heaven... and hell
    'He will always be a friend': Jackie Stewart backs Polanski

    'He will always be a friend'

    Jackie Stewart backs Roman Polanski
    The price of pacifism: Refusing to go to war is finally being recognised as a brave act

    The price of pacifism

    From the Second World War refusenik to the 19-year-old Israeli, Holly Williams talks to five people who risked shame and suffering to take a stand as conscientious objector.
    'It was mass hysteria': Jason Isaacs on groupies, theatre bores and snogging James Bond

    Jason Isaacs: Groupies, theatre bores and James Bond

    To millions, Jason Isaacs is one of Harry Potter's arch enemies – but his wife prefers him as a Scottish TV detective.
    Notes from a small island: Is Sealand an independent 'micronation' or an illegal fortress?

    Sealand: 'Micronation' or illegal fortress?

    Thomas Hodgkinson spent a week at the tiny platform off the Suffolk coast to find out.
    Not a bad bone: Mark Hix cooks with cutlets and ribs

    Mark Hix cooks with cutlets and ribs

    If you ignore cutlets and ribs, you'll risk missing out on some delicious and easy meals, says our chef.
    The experts' guide to summer: From getting fit for the beach to recreating that Olympic buzz

    The experts' guide to summer

    From getting fit for the beach to recreating that Olympic buzz
    Sex, drugs and fast cars: The legend of James Hunt has set Hollywood hearts racing

    Legend of James Hunt has set Hollywood hearts racing

    Early glimpses of Ron Howard's film Rush suggest it will portray Hunt as a high-living lothario, with an insatiable appetite for partying.
    Macklemore: 'I don't have moderation when using drugs and alcohol. It was hurting my life'

    Macklemore: 'I don't have moderation'

    The next Vanilla Ice or the next Eminem? Macklemore doesn't have a record contract – but he does have the UK's biggest-selling single of the year.
    Don't be shy: Bill Granger's Sri Lankan recipes

    Don't be shy: Bill Granger's Sri Lankan recipes

    Sri Lankan cuisine is light, sunny, wonderfully spiced – and so easy to cook from scratch. Just as soon as you've broken into the coconut, that is.
    Sir James Dyson’s latest project: Cleaning up hospitals

    Sir James Dyson’s latest project: Cleaning up hospitals

    Doctors are hailing the revamp of a Bath neonatal unit, where babies sleep more and feed better, as the model for patient care
    One man returns to Argentina's town that drowned

    One man returns to Argentina's town that drowned

    Epecuen was submerged under 10 metres of water in 1985. Now the floods have gone – and 83-year-old Pablo Novak has moved back in