Secrets of Success: Pick well and with-profits can still work

For those of you with the stomach for getting into detailed statistical study of investment returns, there are some interesting figures to be extracted from the latest annual survey of with-profits endowment policies by the trade magazine
Money Management.

For those of you with the stomach for getting into detailed statistical study of investment returns, there are some interesting figures to be extracted from the latest annual survey of with-profits endowment policies by the trade magazine Money Management. They remind us about what is good and what is bad about the whole with-profits concept.

If you go solely by the headlines in the press, you will surely believe that with-profits as a concept is dead. Bonus rates and realised values for with-profits policies have been falling for years. Each year seems to bring fresh announcements of cuts. Worse still, some providers continue to levy a surrender penalty - euphemistically called a market value adjustment - if you try to take your money out before your policy has matured. Since the Equitable scandal broke five years ago, sales of with-profits policies have plummeted. Few financial advisers have the nerve to recommend them any more.

But in practice, however, the real picture about with-profits is not quite as simple as the headlines would have you believe. Millions of investors do still have their money tied up in with-profits policies that they rightly feel unable to abandon, if only because they also recognise there is no guarantee they would do any better by switching.

And while it is true that the whole concept of with-profits has taken a critical lambasting and has now in many respects become outdated, the performance record is not as uniformly bad as popular opinion would have you believe.

Take the level of returns recorded on maturing with-profits endowments as an example. The sums realised on these policies have certainly been falling. The average 10-year with-profits endowment policy maturing in February 2005, for example, produced a pitiful annual average rate of return of 2.7 per cent, just 0.1 per cent above the rate of inflation over the same period. Until five years ago, by comparison, the annual yield on 10-year with-profits policies was consistently between 9 and 10 per cent a year. The comparable figures for the average 25-year endowment - the kind most people use to support their mortgages - are nothing like as bad. But they too have fallen from a realised annual return of 12.4 per cent on policies maturing 10 years ago to 9.1 per cent for those maturing in February this year, a decline of around 25 per cent in five years.

However, there are two important caveats. One is that these are nominal, not absolute returns. If you take inflation into account, the picture changes. As the second chart shows, the downward trend is much steeper for 10-year endowments, but much less marked for the longer 25-year policies. While the average 10-year policy's realised yield has fallen from five per cent to zero, the comparable figure for 25-year policies is actually higher (at 4.5 per cent a year) than it was 10 years ago.

The second thing to emphasise is that the average figures conceal an extraordinarily wide range of performance by individual providers. The second chart shows the best and worst inflation-adjusted returns achieved in both the 10-year and 25-year endowment sectors. You can see that the best providers have paid out consistently good returns of more than six per cent a year in real terms, while the worst have been terrible, especially for shorter term policies.

The figures provide ammunition for both critics and supporters of the with-profits concept. The performance of many with-profits policies has been bad, something that can be attributed both to their relatively high costs and the indifferent investment performance of many life companies. In reality the with-profits concept, with its aim of smoothing returns through the stock and bond market cycles, only works as a long-term investment.

In up and down markets, 10 years is simply too short a period to allow smoothing to work in a cost-effective way. That is why the figures for 10-year policies are so much more volatile and unimpressive than their 25-year equivalents. The reason so many financial advisers continued for many years to push their clients into 10-year with-profits products may not be unrelated to the handsome upfront commissions life companies pay on these policies.

On the other hand, there is nothing wrong with the impressive rates of return that the best with-profits endowments have produced over time. A realised average real return of five to six per cent a year represents a more than acceptable return, particularly for the cautious investors at whom with-profits have historically been directed. Most sensible people, if offered such a return over 25 years, should grab it with open arms.

The paradox is that the longer you set out to invest for, the more important it becomes to pick a provider that you can trust to invest your money competently and cost-effectively over such a long period. This is tough and the job is more difficult because new technology has completely outmoded the old way of doing things.

The with-profits industry has failed to demonstrate that it merits the trust of investors. This overshadows the fact that a well-run low-cost smoothed investment fund is of itself a perfectly sound investment concept that can still deliver something of value to the lucky minority who pick wisely.

jd@intelligent-investor.co.uk

Independent Partners; request a free guide on NISAs from Hargreaves Lansdown

Voices
A Russian hunter at the Medved bear-hunting lodge in Siberia
Save the tigerWildlife charities turn to those who kill animals to help save them
News
Davis says: 'My career has been about filling a niche - there were fewer short actors and fewer roles – but now I'm being offered all kinds of things'
PeopleWarwick Davis on Ricky Gervais, Harry Potter and his perfect role
News
i100
Sport
Frank Lampard will pass Billy Wright and equal Bobby Charton’s caps tally of 106 caps against
sportFormer Chelsea midfielder in Etihad stopgap before New York contract
PROMOTED VIDEO
Arts and Entertainment
The first film introduced Daniel Radcliffe to our screens, pictured here as he prepares to board the train to Hogwarts for the first time.
booksHow reading Harry Potter helps children grow up to be gay-friendly
Arts and Entertainment
A scene from Aladdin is performed at the Tony Awards in New York in June
theatreBrit producer Lythgoe makes kids' musical comedy a Los Angeles hit
Sport
Usain Bolt of Jamaica smiles and shakes hands with a competitor after Jamaica won their first heat in the men's 4x100m relay
sport
News
Chancellor George Osborne, along with the Prime Minister, have been 'complacently claiming the economy is now fixed', according to shadow Chancellor Ed Balls
i100... which is awkward, because he is their boss, after all
Life and Style
A small bag of the drug Ecstasy
Health
Life and Style
Floral-print swim shorts, £26, by Topman, topman.com; sunglasses, £215, by Paul Smith, mpaulsmith.co.uk
FashionBag yourself the perfect pair
News
news
News
Netherlands' goalkeeper Tim Krul fails to make a save from Costa Rica's midfielder Celso Borges during a penalty shoot-out in the quarter-final between Netherlands and Costa Rica during the 2014 FIFA World Cup
newsGoalkeepers suffer from 'gambler’s fallacy' during shoot-outs
News
people
Arts and Entertainment
Standing the test of time: Michael J Fox and Christopher Lloyd in 'Back to the Future'
filmReview: A week late, Secret Cinema arrives as interactive screening goes Back to the Future
Extras
indybest
News
i100
Finacial products from our partners
Property search
Latest stories from i100
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?
Independent Dating
and  

By clicking 'Search' you
are agreeing to our
Terms of Use.

ES Rentals

    iJobs Job Widget
    iJobs Money & Business

    Financial Analyst - Forecasting - Yorkshire

    £300 - £350 per day: Orgtel: Financial Analyst, Forecasting, Halifax, Banking,...

    Business Architect - Bristol - £500 per day

    £500 per day: Orgtel: Business Architect - Banking - Bristol - £500 per day A...

    Regulatory Reporting-MI-Bank-Cardiff-£300/day

    £200 - £500 per day + competitive: Orgtel: I am currently working on a large p...

    Trainee Recruitment Consultant - Birmingham - Real Staffing

    £18000 - £23000 per annum + Commission: SThree: Real Staffing are currently lo...

    Day In a Page

    Save the Tiger: Meet the hunters tasked with protecting Russia's rare Amur tiger

    Hunters protect Russia's rare Amur tiger

    In an unusual move, wildlife charities have enlisted those who kill animals to help save them. Oliver Poole travels to Siberia to investigate
    Transfers: How has your club fared in summer sales?

    How has your club fared in summer sales?

    Who have bagged the bargain buys and who have landed the giant turkeys
    Warwick Davis: The British actor on Ricky Gervais, how the Harry Potter set became his office, and why he'd like to play a spy

    'I'm a realist; I know how hard this business is'

    Warwick Davis on Ricky Gervais, Harry Potter and his perfect role
    The best swim shorts for men: Bag yourself the perfect pair and make a splash this summer

    The best swim shorts for men

    Bag yourself the perfect pair and make a splash this summer
    Has Ukip’s Glastonbury branch really been possessed by the devil?

    Has Ukip’s Glastonbury branch really been possessed by the devil?

    Meet the couple blamed for bringing Lucifer into local politics
    Dress the Gaza situation up all you like, but the truth hurts

    Robert Fisk on Gaza conflict

    Dress the situation up all you like, but the truth hurts
    Save the tiger: Tiger, tiger burning less brightly as numbers plummet

    Tiger, tiger burning less brightly

    When William Blake wrote his famous poem there were probably more than 100,000 tigers in the wild. These days they probably number around 3,200
    5 News's Andy Bell retraces his grandfather's steps on the First World War battlefields

    In grandfather's footsteps

    5 News's political editor Andy Bell only knows his grandfather from the compelling diary he kept during WWI. But when he returned to the killing fields where Edwin Vaughan suffered so much, his ancestor came to life
    Lifestyle guru Martha Stewart reveals she has flying robot ... to take photos of her farm

    Martha Stewart has flying robot

    The lifestyle guru used the drone to get a bird's eye view her 153-acre farm in Bedford, New York
    Former Labour minister Meg Hillier has demanded 'pootling lanes' for women cyclists

    Do women cyclists need 'pootling lanes'?

    Simon Usborne (who's more of a hurtler) explains why winning the space race is key to happy riding
    A tale of two presidents: George W Bush downs his paintbrush to pen father’s life story

    A tale of two presidents

    George W Bush downs his paintbrush to pen father’s life story
    Restaurateur Mitch Tonks has given the Great Western Pullman dining car a makeover

    The dining car makes a comeback

    Restaurateur Mitch Tonks has given the Great Western Pullman dining car a makeover
    Gallery rage: How are institutions tackling the discomfort of overcrowding this summer?

    Gallery rage

    How are institutions tackling the discomfort of overcrowding this summer?
    Louis van Gaal has £500,000 video surveillance system installed to monitor Manchester United players

    Eye on the prize

    Louis van Gaal has £500,000 video surveillance system installed to monitor Manchester United players
    Women's rugby: Tamara Taylor adds fuel to the ire in quest to land World Cup

    Women's rugby

    Tamara Taylor adds fuel to the ire in quest to land World Cup