Spare change goes to market

Investment trusts have spent the past decade finding new ways to tempt small savers. On pages 17 to 20 we examine the options for lifting returns while reducing risk

Anthony Bailey
Saturday 21 October 1995 23:02 BST
Comments

INVESTMENT trusts have enjoyed a renaissance over the past 10 years. The companies that run them have successfully caught the attention of small investors And it does not look as if they are content with recent progress.

For example, Flemings is the latest investment trust manager to extol the virtues of using an investment trust as the core investment of a personal pension plan. Others are bound to follow suit.

In fact, investment trusts were originally designed for the private investor. The first was launched to enable the Victorian middle classes to participate in the booming investment opportunities of the time.

The main selling-point was that they did not have to invest directly in one company and risk all in something like a double-or-quits South American railway. Instead, they could buy investment trust shares immediately, spreading risk across a number of stocks.

The principle of pooling money and spreading risk still holds good for investment trusts today. But for a long time investment trusts fell out of favour, superseded in the investing public's affection by another pooled investment - the johnny-come-lately unit trust.

Nowadays both vie for investors' spare cash, though a number of fund management companies offer a range of both unit and investment trusts.

Both give easy access to world stock markets, but there are important differences.

Investment trusts are companies quoted on the stock exchange, just like Marks and Spencer and ICI. To invest in an investment trust, you buy its shares. With a unit trust, you buy units.

With a unit trust, the value of your units is directly linked to the value of the trust's investments. But the value of investment trust shares depends on supply and demand.

The value will obviously be influenced by the trust's holdings, but it may not be a full reflection. Historically, investment trust shares have stood at a discount to the value of the underlying holdings. Typically that discount has narrowed over recent years.

Some shares even stand at a premium. They are being bought and sold at a value greater than the true worth of the underlying investments. So with an investment trust, the return will come in part from the performance of the trust's holdings. But it will also depend on whether the discount (or premium) has changed between buying and selling the shares.

If there is a sudden fall in share prices and lots of unit trust investors want to sell up, the fund manager has to sell investments to pay unit- holders. He may have to sell some of his best investments or sell at low prices to raise the cash.

Investment trust managers do not have this worry. You cash in investment trust shares by selling to another investor through the Stock Exchange. The company running the trust does not have to sell any of the underlying investments. Not having this potential to become a "forced seller" makes investment trusts better ways of investing in, for example, emerging markets or venture capital, where buying and selling holdings can be that much more difficult. Against this, though, in falling markets the trust's discount may widen.

Like other companies, investment trusts can borrow money and invest it. This can increase overall returns when markets are rising but give a double whammy to performance when markets fall. Unit trusts cannot borrow money.

Investment trusts also have the power to invest in a wider range of investments than unit trusts.

Some investment trusts, known as split-capital trusts, have a fixed life and different types of share. At their simplest there might be two types. One class of share gets all the capital growth of the trust's investments, the other class gets all the dividend income.

Alternatively, you can buy shares that have a fixed and pre-determined rate of growth. There are, how-ever, no guarantees. Whether you get this fixed return depends on the performance of the trust's underlying investments.

The shares of split-capital trusts can have particular uses for tax and financial planning needs. But it is sensible to get advice on what's what and to make sure you fully understand how they work (a separate article on splits is on page 20).

There are many similarities between unit and investment trusts. Both give investors a range of funds, such as those that specialise in the UK, North America and so on.

But which is best? You have decided you want to invest in a European fund. Should you choose a unit or investment trust? There is no automatic answer.

The decision may rest on which fund manager has the investment remit you want (for example, a remit to invest in privatised companies, or large companies only). It may depend on which manager has the best reputation for delivering the goods.

On average, investment trusts have performed a bit better than unit trusts over a 10- year period. But only on average. Part of the superior performance is down to a general narrowing of discounts. In other words, investment trust share prices have tended to rise a little faster than their underlying investments. But there are limits to how much discounts can narrow and the extent to which the share price will go to a premium. The reverse can also happen - discounts may widen. Buying investment trusts at a premium, therefore, is risky. Where an investment trust is at a premium you should consider a unit trust.

The investment trust industry is well geared up to selling its wares to private investors. The trade organisation has an excellent range of publications and free leaflets explaining all aspects of investment trusts.

o Write to the Association of Investment Trust Companies (AITC), Durrant House, 8-13 Chiswell Street, London EC1Y 4YY (0171-431 5222).

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

Comments

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in