Standard Life: the vote must be yes, but that's just the beginning
Policyholders will have to back the Scottish insurer's plans, but they don't have to stay with it, says James Daley
Saturday 08 April 2006
More than 2.4m Standard Life customers will finally find out how much they stand to make from the insurer's proposed demutualisation later this month, as the group plays its trump card in its bid to secure policyholders' backing for the transformation.
With the management requiring the approval of 75 per cent of its members to push ahead, it hopes the promise of cash will help convince the floating voters to come on board on the big day, scheduled for 31 May.
Although the Scottish insurer has been careful not to give too much away, analysts estimate that average share distributions will be worth in the range of £500 to £1,000. The exact details will depend on how long you have been a customer with the company and the size of your policy.
To qualify for the share distribution, you must have been a Standard Life member on 31 March 2004. Those who have been with the company for many years and now have sizeable policies could be in for windfalls worth several thousand pounds. But even with the windfalls on offer, should you vote yes to Standard Life's demutualisation? A report from a cross-party group of MPs, published last month, concluded that, historically, mutual companies have served their customers much better than their stock-market-quoted rivals.
It warned that windfall payments following previous demutualisations have generally been scant compensation for savers and investors for the subsequent decline in returns and customer service standards.
The explanation seems obvious. Publicly quoted companies have a duty to shareholders as well as customers, and the interests of the two must be balanced. As a result, the MPs warned demutualised companies' charges have a tendency to creep up over time, while savings rates and loan rates are often only competitive for the newest customers.
Mutuals, however, can put their customers first, which should in theory enable management to survive on slimmer profit margins, with more money left over for policyholders.
Nationwide, the UK's largest building society and one of the top three biggest mutuals in the country, operates with a profit margin of just over 1 per cent on its lending and savings balances. This compares with margins of as high as 2.75 per cent at Lloyds TSB, and 2.28 per cent at HSBC.
The MPs' report found that customers could lose the value of their windfall in higher charges and less competitive rates within four years of demutualisation. It warned that mutual customers tended to lack "a full understanding of what they were voting for" at decision time.
Some plcs have argued they run more efficiently, wiping out the gains of mutuality. And in the case of Standard Life, the insurer has not had much choice about maintaining its mutuality.
Solvency regulations that came into force a couple of years ago require insurers to keep much more money aside for every policy that they sell. As a mutual, Standard Life cannot raise money nearly as easily as a public company, and has struggled to meet the regulator's solvency requirements for its existing business, let alone find enough money to back any substantial growth in new business.
Although many of the company's senior management battled passionately to keep the company's status only six years ago, life for mutual insurance companies is now becoming increasingly challenging. Ned Cazalet, a life insurance analyst, says: "If it doesn't demutualise, it will have a lot of difficulties. I can't think of one reason why you can say it would not be sensible to demutualise."
Although the pressures of being a publicly listed company may well mean that customers see charges rise and service deteriorate over the next few years, things could be much worse for members if Standard Life maintains its mutual status.
Tom McPhail, head of pensions research for Hargreaves Lansdown, the financial adviser, says: "I like mutuality and I am a Standard Life policyholder. But it's really not in the interests of policyholders for Standard to remain a mutual. The best course is to take the money from demutualisation, then decide whether you want to remain a customer after that."
Should I stay or should I go?
* One option for Standard Life policyholders is: vote yes, take the shares then go elsewhere. But if you switch out of a with-profits fund, you're likely to be subject to a market value reduction (MVR).
* Like many insurers, Standard Life charges up to 25 per cent for switching out of your policy before maturity. Not all policies are affected though, so check.
* Returns across with-profits funds have varied dramatically over the past few years. If you put £100 a month into Scottish Widows' with-profits pension for the past 20 years, you would now have a fund worth £48,000. Savers with Liverpool Victoria would have almost £90,000. Liverpool Victoria is still mutual, Scottish Widows demutualised five years ago, though there is no automatic correlation between high returns and mutuality.
* Many advisers believe with-profits products have had their day. If you're thinking of switching, take professional advice. To find an adviser, visit www.unbiased.co.uk.
Independent Partners: See how much you could save by switching credit cards. Compare now
peopleContenders for Time magazine's Person of the Year are a mixture of the good, the bad and the holy
newsAs the world remembers Mandela the hero, the prison where he spent 27 years seems all the more brutal
tvSteven Moffat reveals the actor was dying to take on the role of the Time Lord and says he is excited to see what he will do with the character
sportBayern Munich 2 Manchester City 3: City come from two down to beat reigning European Champions
arts + ents... and a chance to paint Booker Prize winning author Hilary Mantel
danceUnder Tamara Rojo's inspired direction, it seems possible that it could challenge the dominance of the Royal Ballet. We meet some established names and rising stars
travelDiscover Uruguay's jet-set beach resort, an Atlantic enclave with plenty of art and culture to explore on the side
- 1 Mountain goats' miraculous escape from avalanche captured in dramatic video footage
- 2 It’s shameful that our universities have accepted gender segregation under pressure from the most oppressive religious fanatics
- 3 Sir Ian McKellen hits back at Damian Lewis' 'fruity actor' claims
- 4 Kenyan politician Mike Sonko left red-faced after photoshopping himself next to Nelson Mandela
- 5 Selfie at funeral: Cameron squeezes in on Obama snap at Mandela memorial
- < Previous
- Next >
iJobs Money & Business
£50000 - £65000 per annum + BONUS + BENEFITS: Harrington Starr: A leading mark...
£60000 - £85000 per annum + BONUS + BENEFITS: Harrington Starr: A leading asse...
£45000 - £70000 per annum + Bonus + Benefits: Harrington Starr: Technical Impl...
£65000 - £90000 per annum + Bonus + Benefits: Harrington Starr: Rogue Trading ...
Day In a Page
A Grade II-listed mansion with two apartments and a cottage, near Gretna Green
A three-bedroom Grade II-listed mews house with vaulted ceilings and roof garden
A spacious Grade II-listed family home with annexe and equestrian facilities among four acres of land in Itchingfield
A four-bedroom home with exposed brick walls and open fires in the picturesque village of Northill
A Grade II-listed property with five bedrooms and unique tower, overlooking Hastings Old Town
A charming five-bedroom detached family home, set within half an acre in Kew
A two-bedroom maisonette set on the top two floors of a period building, close to Kentish Town Tube.
Take advantage of the extra space provided by former stables and outbuildings at this five-bedroom farmhouse.
This three-bedroom Victorian terrace is near to Queen’s Road Peckham station, Nunhead station.
A five-bedroom modern house with terrace, swimming pool, Zen treehouse and large carp pond
An unexpected gem with four bedrooms, remarkable vaulted reception and a galleried study area
A five-bedroom house in one of Lymington's most sought after tree lined avenues, moments from the marinas and sailing clubs
A grand early 19th century B&B close to the historic harbour, with four en suite bedrooms
A four-bedroom, 17th century home with walled gardens, a landscaped terrace, cellar and open fires
A six-bedroom house with five bathrooms and four reception rooms spread over 4,000sq ft of luxury living space
A stunning three double-bedroom apartment with two decked terraces in the exclusive gated community, Bromyard House
A 10-bedroom period, family home amid beautiful surroundings in the centre of the Wentworth Estate in Longcross village
A stylish three-bedroom apartment with two bathrooms and private landscaped garden, moments from Fitzroy Square
A Grade II-listed Elizabethan barn with landscaped gardens, exposed elm beams and four bedrooms, all with lovely views
A six-bedroom family home, dating back to 1280 with four reception rooms, barn, swimming pool and tennis courts in Harwell
A spacious two-bedroom flat, refurbished to a very high standard with private landscaped garden, close to Kentish Town station
An exceptional two-bedroom apartment with balcony and underground parking in the centre of Richmond
A one-bedroom, luxury, duplex apartment in the grand landmark building, Imperial Hall
Run a fabulous boutique shop, live above it in a one-bedroom flat and let a second one-bedroom flat that comes part and parcel
A Grade-II listed, thatched cottage in Hundleby village, with five bedrooms, a coach house and three and a half acres
A spacious two-bedroom flat in the heart of Hoxton Square with wooden floors and roof terrace
A five-bedroom family home with stunning pool and gym complex set among two acres of land
A six-bedroom period house with heated swimming pool and a separate two-bedroom annexe cottage in Townlake, £795,000
A spacious and contemporary two-bedroom flat arranged over three floors, with garden patio close to St George Square, £600,000
A one-bedroom flat in a beautiful Regency building opposite the beach in Kemp Town, £190,000
A two-bedroom flat with London skyline views close to Surrey Quays. £395,000.
A seven-storey tower with three bedrooms and a stunning roof terrace. Guide price: £850,000.
A 16-bedroom country pile with nine reception rooms, four self-contained flats and a 13th century Peel Tower. £850,000.
A classic six-bedroom Victorian Manse house 10 miles from Edinburgh. £495,000.
John Lennon's childhood home in Liverpool to be sold at auction. Guide price: £150,000-£250,000.
A six-bedroom detached period property with secluded gardens, ample parking and a double garage in Rye, £675,000.
A large split-level property with three double-bedrooms and roof terrace, close to Crouch End Broadway, £625,000.
A charming barn conversion in the picturesque Cotswold village of Ilmington with three bedrooms, a detached garage, workshop and beautifully manicured gardens £675,000.
A three-bedroom new build, ground-floor flat with two bathrooms, close to Bermondsey tube, £445,000.
A three-bedroom house in an enviable new development moments from Oxshott High Street, with secluded garden and decked area, £385,000