A battle for the soul of mutuals

With Scottish Amicable planning a flotation, Peter Rodgers asks if insurers are going the way of building societies

If ever there were an example in a single organisation of both the benefits and the drawbacks of mutual ownership it is Scottish Amicable, which announced last month that it planned to float on the Stock Exchange, provoking a pair of rival bids from Abbey National and the Pru.

Now that building societies are moving towards extinction, it is a serious issue whether the insurers are heading the same way. Do they deserve to disappear? Or would the economy and the financial services sector benefit from the continued existence of mutual ownership in this specialised area?

It is clear from ScotAm's accounts that the most important financial characteristic of most mutual insurers is that they do not build large reserves, because they distribute profits as they go. The only free reserves they accumulate are their working capital, so when they demutualise there is no enormous windfall to hand back to their mutual owners. This distinguishes them from building societies, which have built valuable surpluses which allow large distributions of cash or shares to members.

Since they distribute their profits as they go, life insurers remain close to the 19th century principles of mutuality. The businesses are run largely for the benefit of members, who are also the customers. Indeed, managements are required to consider the interests of all their stakeholders, including employees.

In a conventional insurance company, 10 per cent of the profits of the life funds go to outside shareholders. This may explain why mutuals appear more often at the top of policyholder performance tables than shareholder- owned life insurance companies.

In contrast, building societies have long since forgotten the ideal of mutuality, the last glimmerings of which disappeared in the early 1980s when mortgage rationing was abolished. Until then, membership of a society at least assured a preferential place in the queue for a mortgage, and the rates were cheaper than those charged by banks.

Some of the societies that remain have suddenly realised that they have lost touch with the original concept of mutuality, and have begun to distribute profits as they go, by charging less for mortgages and paying more for deposits than banks. But they are probably too late to stop the wave of demutualisation sweeping through the industry.

However, the mutual insurers' advantage - their ability to distribute most of their profits as they go - is also their Achilles' heel. Despite not paying dividends, their growth can easily be restricted by their lack of capital.

They can take a decision to build up higher reserves. But to do so they must pay less of their profit to policyholders, so they drop down the performance league tables and find it hard to win new business. There are ways in which mutuals can raise outside loan capital, but their flexibility is restricted, compared with the freedom of conventional companies to raise cash from shareholders.

If mutuals outgrow their capital by taking on too much new business, it creates a vicious circle. If the capital is insufficient, prudence dictates that less of the money under management is invested in equities, because of their greater volatility. Yet over a long period, equities bring higher returns than anything else, so the performance of the funds falls off and it is again harder to sell new policies and win new business.

This is a dilemma all too familiar to ScotAm and in the past to others such as Scottish Equitable and London Life. The solution is usually to demutualise and invite new owners to inject more capital into the business. Another option, the one the Pru has suggested to ScotAm, is to stop taking new business altogether, so working capital is no longer needed and can be distributed to policyholders.

Another disadvantage of mutuality that is clearly displayed by the ScotAm affair is the lack of corporate governance pressures on management, at least compared with conventional companies. ScotAm would never have been able to spend last week ignoring the Abbey and Pru offers if it had been a conventional company with institutional investors, governed by the rules of the Stock Exchange and the Takeover Panel.

It is curious that the whip hand in the ScotAm auction could be held by three trusts that specialise in investing in second-hand endowment policies. They have enough ScotAm policies to call a special general meeting to force a vote against management, exactly the kind of pressure conventional companies often find themselves under during bids.

The final and perhaps most serious criticism of mutual insurers is to do with the nature of the products they sell. The endowment insurance policy is probably one of the most one-sided contracts ever written.

For a start, it is several years - and as many as 10 for some companies - before investors receive back all their cash if they surrender their policies. This is a result of high fees and commissions and early surrender penalties. And while the main advantage of a mutual is that profits are distributed as bonuses, the way it is done is open to question. Annual and terminal bonuses are at the discretion of the insurer. The terminal bonus on a long-term policy can be as high as 250 per cent, but is never guaranteed, so there is huge scope for massaging the results.

This means, incidentally, that any promises by bidders for ScotAm to add a chunk of money to the terminal bonus are almost meaningless, since there is nothing to stop the company adjusting downwards the rest of the terminal bonus when the time comes.

Does it matter for the econ-omy if these mutuals disappear? Probably not a great deal. The advantages in efficiency and in investment performance of mutuals are noticeable, but not large enough to have a serious impact. And shareholder-owned companies do have the benefit of being able to grow faster, because of their easier access to capital.

For customers of the life insurance industry, being a policy-holder in a mutual means you own part of the company. The effect is that your investments are weighted towards the life insurance industry itself. This is no bad thing given the bid premiums that are emerging for life insurers, but it will not always be an advantage.

While it is certainly hard to feel any sentimental attachment to mutual building societies, since they behave exactly like banks, mutual insurers nevertheless remain very different.

First, the windfalls for members on demutualisation are much smaller, so in theory there is less incentive for members to vote them out of existence.

Second, though the list of drawbacks to mutuality may look longer than the list of advantages, a well-run mutual such as Standard Life or Scottish Widows does bring significant advantages to its members, compared with a shareholder-owned company. This is an area of commercial life where mutuality should be encouraged, because it really does mean something.

News
John Travolta is a qualified airline captain and employed the pilot with his company, Alto
people'That was the lowest I’d ever felt'
Life and Style
healthIt isn’t greasy. It doesn’t smell. And moreover, it costs nothing
News
i100

Other places that have held independence referendums
Arts and Entertainment
Jack Huston is the new Ben-Hur
film

It scooped up an unprecedented 11 Academy Awards when it was first remade in 1959

PROMOTED VIDEO
Life and Style
fashion

Olympic diver has made his modelling debut for Adidas

Arts and Entertainment
Blossoming love: Colin Firth as Stanley and Emma Stone as Sophie, in 'Magic in the Moonlight'
film

Actors star in Woody Allen's 'Magic in the Moonlight'

News
news

News
peopleThe Times of India said actress should treat it as a 'compliment'
Arts and Entertainment
Maxine Peake plays Hamlet at Manchester's Royal Exchange
theatreReview: Maxine Peake brings emotional ferocity to Shakespeare's starring part
News
London's New Year's Eve fireworks event is going to be ticketed this year for the first time at £10 a head
news

Revellers will have to pay to see New Year's Eve fireworks in London

News
news

Watch this commuter wage a one-man war against the Circle Line
Property
Home body: Badger stays safe indoors
lifeShould we feel guilty about keeping cats inside?
News
ebooksAn unforgettable anthology of contemporary reportage
Travel
travel

...and the perfect time to visit them

Sport
Jonas Gutierrez (r) competes with Yaya Toure (l)
football

Newcastle winger reveals he has testicular cancer - and is losing his trademark long hair as a result

News
A male driver reverses his Vauxhall Astra from a tow truck
news

Man's attempt to avoid being impounded heavily criticised

Life and Style
tech

Try putting that one on your Christmas list
Arts and Entertainment
While many films were released, few managed to match the success of James Bond blockbuster 'Skyfall'
filmsDaniel Craig believed to be donning skis as 007 for first time
Latest stories from i100
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?
Independent Dating
and  

By clicking 'Search' you
are agreeing to our
Terms of Use.

iJobs Job Widget
iJobs Money & Business

Trainee Recruitment Consultant - Birmingham - Real Staffing

£18000 - £23000 per annum + Commission: SThree: Real Staffing are currently lo...

Recruitment Consultant - Soho - IT, Pharma, Public Sector

£20000 - £25000 per annum + OTE £35,000 first year: SThree: The SThree group i...

Sales Executive

£20 - 24k (Uncapped Commission - £35k Year 1 OTE): Guru Careers: We are seekin...

Payroll & Accounts Assistant

£20 - 24k + Benefits: Guru Careers: This is a great opportunity for an enthusi...

Day In a Page

Mystery of the Ground Zero wedding photo

A shot in the dark

Mystery of the wedding photo from Ground Zero
His life, the universe and everything

His life, the universe and everything

New biography sheds light on comic genius of Douglas Adams
Save us from small screen superheroes

Save us from small screen superheroes

Shows like Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D are little more than marketing tools
Reach for the skies

Reach for the skies

From pools to football pitches, rooftop living is looking up
These are the 12 best hotel spas in the UK

12 best hotel spas in the UK

Some hotels go all out on facilities; others stand out for the sheer quality of treatments
These Iranian-controlled Shia militias used to specialise in killing American soldiers. Now they are fighting Isis, backed up by US airstrikes

Widespread fear of Isis is producing strange bedfellows

Iranian-controlled Shia militias that used to kill American soldiers are now fighting Isis, helped by US airstrikes
Topshop goes part Athena poster, part last spring Prada

Topshop goes part Athena poster, part last spring Prada

Shoppers don't come to Topshop for the unique
How to make a Lego masterpiece

How to make a Lego masterpiece

Toy breaks out of the nursery and heads for the gallery
Meet the ‘Endies’ – city dwellers who are too poor to have fun

Meet the ‘Endies’ – city dwellers who are too poor to have fun

Urbanites are cursed with an acronym pointing to Employed but No Disposable Income or Savings
Paisley’s decision to make peace with IRA enemies might remind the Arabs of Sadat

Ian Paisley’s decision to make peace with his IRA enemies

His Save Ulster from Sodomy campaign would surely have been supported by many a Sunni imam
'She was a singer, a superstar, an addict, but to me, her mother, she is simply Amy'

'She was a singer, a superstar, an addict, but to me, her mother, she is simply Amy'

Exclusive extract from Janis Winehouse's poignant new memoir
Is this the role to win Cumberbatch an Oscar?

Is this the role to win Cumberbatch an Oscar?

The Imitation Game, film review
England and Roy Hodgson take a joint step towards redemption in Basel

England and Hodgson take a joint step towards redemption

Welbeck double puts England on the road to Euro 2016
Relatives fight over Vivian Maier’s rare photos

Relatives fight over Vivian Maier’s rare photos

Pictures removed from public view as courts decide ownership
‘Fashion has to be fun. It’s a big business, not a cure for cancer’

‘Fashion has to be fun. It’s a big business, not a cure for cancer’

Donatella Versace at New York Fashion Week