David Prosser: A decade after Enron's collapse, the failures of the audit industry have still to be confronted
Thursday 01 December 2011
Latest in Business Comment
On Facebook
Outlook Ten years ago tomorrow, Enron, which back then was the US's seventh largest company, filed for bankruptcy following a shocking accounting scandal that appeared to have completely passed its auditor by. The auditor in question, Arthur Andersen, subsequently disbanded.
One might think the lesson from Enron is that any auditor which fails to spot a problem large enough to sink a company can expect big trouble of its own. Yet no audit firm has paid the price for the failure to warn about the potential black holes in the accounts of the banks prior to the credit crunch, or the extent to which so many of them were using off-balance sheet special purpose vehicles. Rather, the dominance of the big four firms remains absolute, with Deloitte, Ernst & Young, KPMG and PriceWaterhouseCoopers even enjoying a boost from the post-Enron disappearance of Arthur Andersen.
It is in this context that Michel Barnier, the European Union's internal market commissioner, yesterday published new rules for auditors that had the biggest firms spitting tacks. Assuming Mr Barnier gets his rules onto the statute book, firms will have to split their audit and consultancy operations, while companies will be required to change their auditors regularly – possibly as often as every six years.
The big four may be angry, but the case for reform is compelling. Between them, Deloitte, Ernst & Young, KPMG and PWC hold the audit contracts for 85 per cent of blue-chip EU companies. They enjoy profit margins that are 50 per cent higher than the next four largest auditors, Mr Barnier claims.
Improved competition and higher standards go hand-in-hand. The requirement to prevent auditors selling consultancy to companies they audit is important because of the conflicts of interest that arise when providing both services. But in a more diverse market, such conflicts would be less likely even without such a ban. Similarly, it might also be that had a bank's auditor, say, previously been prevented from spending decades with the account, it might not have got so comfortable that it failed to spot the financial crisis coming.
There is an inherent conflict ofinterest in the auditing sector – auditors are paid by the very people they are supposed to be keeping an eye on. Still, mandatory rotation of audit accounts should give firms less reason not to assert their independence.
The argument against Mr Barnier's reforms seems simply to be that companies' audit costs may rise as a result of them. Well, that doesn't seem logical – more competition should surely lead to lower fees, especially if Mr Barnier is right about those margins. But even if costs do rise, isn't that a price worth paying if we end up with more robust auditors that do a better job of holding their clients to account?
It's not just the largest firms that are upset with Mr Barnier's proposals by the way. Smaller firms are upset he has backed down from one of his earlier ideas, under which blue chips would have been forced to appoint two joint auditors – one large and one small.
But dropping that proposal was sensible. While smaller auditors would have picked up more work, lines of responsibility would have been blurred, with the potential for problems to slip between the cracks in a dual approach – and for both firms to blame each other in the event of a failure.
One final point: there was some anger in Britain yesterday about the imposition of EU standards in an area where our corporate governance codes have traditionally held sway. But it would be easier to sympathise with that argument if the "comply or explain" approach had produced better results.
- 1 Brazil rocked by abortion for 9-year-old rape victim
- 2 News in pictures
- 3 Naked Miami man shot dead after being found eating another man's face
- 4 In pictures: The bewildering face of China
- 5 Principled Skinner rises above the fray
- 6 News International 'tried to blackmail select committee'
- 7 Postgraduate students are being used as 'slave labour'
- 8 UN condemns Syria after massacre of civilians
- 9 Coastguard warning after man drowns saving two children
- 10 Pope's butler: 'more arrests may follow'
- 1 Robert Fisk: The going price of getting away with murder... would $33m be enough?
- 2 Brazil rocked by abortion for 9-year-old rape victim
- 3 Hardcore, hard-wired: How the prevalence of porn is changing our everyday lives
- 4 Principled Skinner rises above the fray
- 5 Fat? Really? Olympic hope laughs off official’s jibe – but others aren’t amused
- 6 News International 'tried to blackmail select committee'
- 7 'Hello mum, this is going to be hard for you to read ...'
- 8 Postgraduate students are being used as 'slave labour'
- 9 Coke reveals its secret: It may need to carry a cancer warning
- 10 French in uproar over oral sex anti-smoking posters
Experience the Heineken Hub
Get free wi-fi and exclusive i content while you enjoy a tasty pint of Heineken at participating pubs.
Can you imagine a career in teaching?
Be inspired to teach - let real teachers show you how rewarding the job can be.
Playing a game-changing role during the Games
Cisco is providing the solutions for London 2012's complex IT needs.
Enter the latest Independent competitions
Win anything from gadgets to five-star holidays on our competitions and offers page.
Business videos from commercial thought leaders
Watch the best in the business world give their insights into the world of business.



Comments