Jeremy Warner: West Bromwich saved for the nation?


Outlook West Bromwich Building Society seems to have won a reprieve. By persuading holders of £182.5m of subordinated loans to convert their debt into instruments that would qualify as core tier 1 capital, West Bromwich hopes to avoid enforced merger with someone else, or the even more unpalatable end of falling victim to the Government's shiny new special resolution regime, the fate that befell its sister building society up in Dunfermline.

I will believe this when I see it, but having sanctioned the creation of the monopolistic Lloyds Banking Group, the Government is desperate to save the mutual model so as to maintain diversity in UK financial services, so it is just about possible that West Brom will stagger on as an independent. Not that this West Brom is going to provide much competition to Lloyds, but I guess anything is better than nothing.

When the banking crisis first broke, it was the converted building societies that everyone worried about. Fired up by the prospect of big bonuses for senior executives, they had then gone hell for leather for growth and ended up overstretching themselves. All of them have now been either closed, subsumed into something else, or nationalised.

Yet some of those who remained in the mutually owned sector have turned out to be just as reckless. Like Dunfermline, West Brom turns out to have been overweight in commercial lending and high-risk mortgage lending such as buy-to-let. Mutual ownership, is seems, was no guarantee of good behaviour.

As it happens, the bigger building societies seem to be basically all right, and so too do the tiddlers, the ones that have stuck to their core purpose of deposit taking and mortgage lending. In some cases, the chief executive of these tiddlers will know all his customers by name, rather as if he were behind the counter in the village shop. Some of these smaller building societies are as much part of the local community they serve as the local school or doctor's surgery, and are much to be encouraged.

It is the middle-ranking building societies which the FSA has had to worry about, the ones that developed ambitions beyond their status and tried to play with the big boys. Dunfermline and West Brom were among them. One or two others are going to have to be dealt with over the months ahead too.

A return to the basic principles of community banking is an obvious way forward for an industry which has lost the trust of its customers by playing fast and loose with their money. The main elements of the building society model is still essentially fine, even if many of the problems that now beset the movement could have been avoided had not the regulatory regime been tampered with by successive governments in the rush to liberalisation.

Independent Comment
blog comments powered by Disqus
Career Services

Day In a Page

Child of the revolution: the Burmese family that democracy brought back together

Home of the free

The Burmese family that democracy brought back together
Cannes review: Canine accolade and Hitler's return are high spots amid the gloom

Cannes review

Frocks, canine accolade and Hitler's return
Robert Fisk: The going price of getting away with murder... would $33m be enough?

The going price of getting away with murder

Robert Fisk: The long view
Principled Skinner rises above the fray

Principled Skinner rises above the fray

Andy McSmith meets Dennis Skinner
Patrick Cockburn: I fear this terrible massacre will be the beginning of a long civil war in Syria

Patrick Cockburn

I fear this terrible massacre will be the beginning of a long civil war in Syria
Hardeep Singh Kohli: For me, it is all about 'Gregory's Girl', a record of first love

Hardeep Singh Kohli

For me, it is all about 'Gregory's Girl', a record of first love
Christian Louboutin: 'I don't think comfort equals happiness'

Christian Louboutin interview

'I don't think comfort equals happiness'
Happy birthday, Hotel Babylon!

Happy birthday, Hotel Babylon!

Hollywood's home to the A-list celebrates 100 years of discreet luxury
Rupert Cornwell: Low-rise capital could finally reach for the sky

Rupert Cornwell: Out of America

Low-rise capital could finally reach for the sky
The secret life of the red carpet

The secret life of the red carpet

As Cannes reaches its climax with the Palme d'Or and the celebrities gather in London for the Baftas tonight, Kate Youde and Jack Dean investigate the real star of the show
It's not easy being Professor Green: The rapper, the heiress and a drama made in Chelsea...

It's not easy being Professor Green

The rapper, the heiress and a drama made in Chelsea...
Hardcore, hard-wired: How the prevalence of porn is changing our everyday lives

How porn is changing our lives

It's everywhere - from pop videos to fashion magazines to the theatrical stage.
River Phoenix: the final reel

River Phoenix: the final reel

Twenty years after the actor's death, his last film is to be released
Facebook: The shares shenanigans

Facebook: The shares shenanigans

Investors are crying foul over the huge losses they incurred when the social network site floated on the stock market last week
Up and away – how '7 Up' went global

Up and away – how '7 Up' went global

As the last episode of Britain's '56 Up' airs, the first episode of '28 Up', from the former USSR, starts. Then there's the US, Japan, Germany...