Jim Armitage: It's high time a scalpel was taken to the private healthcare market

Outlook Well, we didn't expect that diagnosis. Back in January, in its last pronouncement on the condition of the private healthcare market, the Competition Commission declared that there were too few rival hospital operators. The public was getting royally ripped off. It prescribed BMI, one of the oligopolists, to flog off some to increase rivalry and keep down prices. And it told American-run HCA to do the same in London.

Both companies squealed, as you'd expect, claiming there was no evidence they were overly dominant. The commission is anaesthetised to such howling, of course. Its job is to upset unruly big business.

But here's the funny thing: in yesterday's final judgement, the watchdog, now called the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) changed its mind.

Not where HCA was concerned – it now has to either sell its prestigious Wellington hospital, with its views over Lord's cricket ground, or both its London Bridge and Princess Grace centres.

But on BMI, which had previously been told to ditch seven hospitals, at some stage between the preliminary recommendations in January and yesterday's final report two out of the five adjudicators changed their minds. They could "no longer be confident" that the concentration of hospitals outside the capital was leading to higher prices for care. Re-sheath this scalpel, nurse. Only a clear 4-5 majority can carry out such a radical action.

As far as major competition inquiries go, a split vote like this is extremely rare. For a decision to change so dramatically in the last three months of a two-year inquiry is unheard of.

Furthermore, one of the judges who changed his mind was Roger Witcomb, the chairman of the commission.

Now you could argue, as HCA probably will, that the U-turn shows that the commission, from the top down, hadn't got a clue how to analyse the data outside the capital. Surely this means, HCA will say in its appeal, that its judgement on London should be ignored too?

We should not be swayed by HCA's lobbying. The competition situation in the few square miles of central London is far clearer than across the UK as a whole. HCA owns more than half the available overnight beds and charges significantly more for them to insured customers than its closest rivals, the commission found. That is an abusive position that costs many people too much – either on their insurance premiums or their direct bills. And, just because they're in central London, doesn't mean they're solely, to quote Tom Lehrer, specialists in diseases of the rich. Millions of ordinary workers in the capital on work healthcare schemes use them too.

Outside London, the picture is far more complicated – markets are wider, more fragmented. There are local areas with little or no competition, but proving a direct correlation with charges – which is what the commission had to do – was statistically difficult. Mr Witcomb and friends were drawing conclusions from 1.5 million hospital invoices for more than 1,500 types of treatment across the country.

Clearly, the Commission should have figured out that the evidence was too flaky a long time ago. It looks foolish to change its mind so spectacularly. There will be some who say Mr Witcomb's regime at the old organisation ended in embarrassment.

But Mr Witcomb and Co are economists – statisticians, not politicians. They should not live in constant terror of being accused of mental or moral weakness for changing their minds. Surely the commission should be applauded for its meaningful recent review of the evidence.

When such grave remedies as corporate amputations were in the offing, it was right to heed its doubts, however late in the day.

Voices
On the last day of campaigning before the polling booths open, the SNP leader has written to voters in a final attempt to convince them to vote for independence
voicesIs a huge gamble on oil keeping the First Minister up at night?
Life and Style
techApple has just launched its latest mobile operating software – so what should you do first?
Arts and Entertainment
Pointless host Alexander Armstrong will voice Danger Mouse on CBBC
tv

Much-loved cartoon character returns - without Sir David Jason

Arts and Entertainment
Liam Neeson said he wouldn't
tv

Liam Neeson's Downton dreams

PROMOTED VIDEO
Arts and Entertainment
Actor and director Zach Braff
tv

Arts and Entertainment
Rosalind Buckland, the inspiration for Cider with Rosie died this week
booksBut what is it like to be the person who inspires a classic work of art?
Arts and Entertainment
tv

Arts and Entertainment
The former Doctor Who actor is to play a vicar is search of a wife
film

Matt Smith is set to join cast of the Jane Austen classic - with a twist

Arts and Entertainment
tvReview: An undercooked end (spoiler alert)
Arts and Entertainment
Lionel Messi in action for Barcelona
filmWhat makes the little man tick?
News
i100
News
ebooksAn unforgettable anthology of contemporary reportage
Arts and Entertainment
Pharrell dismissed the controversy surrounding
musicThe singer said 'the last thing I want to do is degrade'
Sport
Cesc Fabregas celebrates his first Chelsea goal
footballChelsea vs Schalke match report
Arts and Entertainment
Toby Jones (left) and Mackenzie Crook in BBC4’s new comedy The Detectorists
tvMackenzie Crook's 'Detectorists' makes hobby look 'dysfunctional'
Life and Style
fashion

Olympic diver has made his modelling debut for Adidas

News
i100
Latest stories from i100
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?
Independent Dating
and  

By clicking 'Search' you
are agreeing to our
Terms of Use.

iJobs Job Widget
iJobs Money & Business

Property Underwriter

£70-90,000: Saxton Leigh: Our client a London Market Insurer are seeking a Pro...

Operational Risk Manager - Asset Management

£60,000 - £80,000: Saxton Leigh: Our client is an leading Asset Manager based...

Trainee Recruitment Consultant Birmingham

£18000 - £23000 per annum + Comission: SThree: The SThree group is a world lea...

Trainee Recruitment Consultant - Birmingham - Real Staffing

£18000 - £23000 per annum + Commission: SThree: Real Staffing are currently lo...

Day In a Page

Mystery of the Ground Zero wedding photo

A shot in the dark

Mystery of the wedding photo from Ground Zero
His life, the universe and everything

His life, the universe and everything

New biography sheds light on comic genius of Douglas Adams
Save us from small screen superheroes

Save us from small screen superheroes

Shows like Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D are little more than marketing tools
Reach for the skies

Reach for the skies

From pools to football pitches, rooftop living is looking up
These are the 12 best hotel spas in the UK

12 best hotel spas in the UK

Some hotels go all out on facilities; others stand out for the sheer quality of treatments
These Iranian-controlled Shia militias used to specialise in killing American soldiers. Now they are fighting Isis, backed up by US airstrikes

Widespread fear of Isis is producing strange bedfellows

Iranian-controlled Shia militias that used to kill American soldiers are now fighting Isis, helped by US airstrikes
Topshop goes part Athena poster, part last spring Prada

Topshop goes part Athena poster, part last spring Prada

Shoppers don't come to Topshop for the unique
How to make a Lego masterpiece

How to make a Lego masterpiece

Toy breaks out of the nursery and heads for the gallery
Meet the ‘Endies’ – city dwellers who are too poor to have fun

Meet the ‘Endies’ – city dwellers who are too poor to have fun

Urbanites are cursed with an acronym pointing to Employed but No Disposable Income or Savings
Paisley’s decision to make peace with IRA enemies might remind the Arabs of Sadat

Ian Paisley’s decision to make peace with his IRA enemies

His Save Ulster from Sodomy campaign would surely have been supported by many a Sunni imam
'She was a singer, a superstar, an addict, but to me, her mother, she is simply Amy'

'She was a singer, a superstar, an addict, but to me, her mother, she is simply Amy'

Exclusive extract from Janis Winehouse's poignant new memoir
Is this the role to win Cumberbatch an Oscar?

Is this the role to win Cumberbatch an Oscar?

The Imitation Game, film review
England and Roy Hodgson take a joint step towards redemption in Basel

England and Hodgson take a joint step towards redemption

Welbeck double puts England on the road to Euro 2016
Relatives fight over Vivian Maier’s rare photos

Relatives fight over Vivian Maier’s rare photos

Pictures removed from public view as courts decide ownership
‘Fashion has to be fun. It’s a big business, not a cure for cancer’

‘Fashion has to be fun. It’s a big business, not a cure for cancer’

Donatella Versace at New York Fashion Week