Mutuals are fighting back

The tide may be turning against carpet-baggers as societies woo new customers, says Dan Gledhill

It used to be said there was no such thing as a free lunch, but the wave of demutualisations in the past few years has put paid to that idea. Thousands of investors, who carpet-bagged conversion after conversion, have gorged themselves on the fruits of their windfalls. All they had to do was deposit as little as pounds 100 with the relevant mutual society and wait for the thousands to roll in. And anyone hungry for yet another course has the likely demutualisation of the Bradford & Bingley - among others - to look forward to.

But this gratis greedfest has left a bitter taste in the mouth and now the leftovers of the mutual sector are fighting back. Some customers of converted building societies, such as the Halifax and Abbey National, complain they are being penalised by the need of their banks to satisfy greedy shareholders. Many have voted with their feet by pocketing their windfalls and promptly taking their business back to remaining mutuals like the Nationwide and Britannia.

Elsewhere, the head of the John Lewis Partnership has mounted a spirited defence of the department store group's mutual status in the face of workers baying for pounds 100,000 windfalls that demutualisation could bring. Could it be that the AA, which last week was sold to Centrica, will go down as the last great demutualisation?

The evidence is strong that, in spite of all the defections, the mutual sector is in rude health. That was the conclusion of Charles Leadbeater and Ian Christie, members of the left-wing think-tank Demos, who recently published a book called To Our Mutual Advantage. They estimated that organisations owned by their members had a combined annual turnover of pounds 25bn and employed 250,000 people. The sector encompasses activities as diverse as child care and Neighbourhood Watch, but it is in the arena of building societies where the arguments for and against mutuality have been propounded.

It is a debate where the pro-demutualisers have held sway. Since 1989, when Abbey National set the ball rolling, a series of building societies have surrendered their mutual status. Those 10 years have provided ample opportunity for the benefits of demutualisation to be identified, but the signs point the other way. Figures from the Building Societies Association suggest mutuals are increasing their share of mortgage lending.

David Holmes, a spokesman for the mutual Yorkshire building society, says: "We decided demutualisation would mean mortgage rates going up and savings rates going down because when you float you have to pay out pounds 35 in every pounds 100 in dividends."

Brian Davis, chief executive of the Nationwide building society, says: "We're picking up a lot of business because we can offer lower prices, but there's more to it than that. Our motivation is not to be money-grabbing. Unlike plcs, we don't get patted on the back by shareholders if we make more money."

It is not an argument which the convertors would accept but the mutuals are eager to ram it home. On Friday, the Nationwide threatened to sue Barclays unless it rescinded a plan to charge the customers of other banks pounds 1 for using Barclays cash machines. Nationwide was fighting this cause for its members, the mutual proclaimed, unlike Barclays which only cares about shareholders.

Just a publicity stunt, maybe, but the Nationwide's stance reflects the growing confidence among mutuals that they are winning the argument. This is bolstered by knowing mutuals are no longer sitting ducks. Like several other building societies, the Nationwide has created a charitable foundation so that would-be carpet-baggers would have to give their demutualisation windfalls to charity. Nationwide's status has been strengthened by the adoption of higher voting thresholds.

Mr Davis, who carries the baggage of the Nationwide's 150- year history, is conscious of the burden of posterity. Mutuals exist not just for the benefit of current members but also for future ones, so the moral justification for one generation cashing in at the ex-pense of the next is questionable.

"It makes you wonder if you can join an organisation by depositing pounds 100, then get it back plus pounds 1,000, when the fact is that it destroys that organisation and deprives your kids of it," he says. "I can see why people are tempted, but you shouldn't just destroy it for a one-off gain."

History is preying on the mind of Sir Stuart Hampson, who took over the top job at John Lewis from a member of the founding family. Sir Stuart's commitment to public service is evident in his defence of the group's unfashionable structure. "Being a partnership means that you offer something different in terms of employing your partners," he says. "They are not mercenaries, but citizens."

Despite last week's announcement of a 22 per cent profits slump, he believes that the company is well-served by worker ownership: "Customers see the involvement of our staff and feel there is a quality of trust and integrity, fairness and care."

His argument seems to be prevailing. Paul Fineman, who works for Peter Jones in London's Sloane Square, has tabled a resolution about John Lewis's structure at tomorrow's meeting of the company's central council, but the signs are the status quo will be endorsed. Not even the lure of pounds 100,000 windfalls for each of John Lewis's 40,000 staff would appear to be enough to persuade them.

It may be that the resurgence of the mutual is a dead cat bounce. Normal service may be resumed next year when members of the Bradford & Bingley decide its future. But there are signs that the remaining mutuals will be ready for the next onslaught.

Start your day with The Independent, sign up for daily news emails
ebooksA special investigation by Andy McSmith
  • Get to the point
Latest stories from i100
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?
Independent Dating

By clicking 'Search' you
are agreeing to our
Terms of Use.

iJobs Job Widget
iJobs Money & Business

SThree: Trainee Recruitment Consultant

£20000 - £25000 per annum + OTE £45,000: SThree: SThree Group have been well e...

Ashdown Group: IT Manager / Development Manager - NW London - £58k + 15% bonus

£50000 - £667000 per annum + excellent benefits : Ashdown Group: IT Manager / ...

Recruitment Genius: Sales Consultant / Telemarketer - OTE £20,000

£13000 - £20000 per annum: Recruitment Genius: Scotland's leading life insuran...

Ashdown Group: Training Programme Manager - City, London

£40000 - £45000 per annum + benefits : Ashdown Group: Training Programme Manag...

Day In a Page

Where the spooks get their coffee fix: The busiest Starbucks in the US is also the most secretive

The secret CIA Starbucks

The coffee shop is deep inside the agency's forested Virginia compound
Revealed: How the Establishment closed ranks over fallout from Loch Ness Monster 'sighting'

How the Establishment closed ranks over fallout from Nessie 'sighting'

The Natural History Museum's chief scientist was dismissed for declaring he had found the monster
One million Britons using food banks, according to Trussell Trust

One million Britons using food banks

Huge surge in number of families dependent on emergency food aid
Excavation at Italian cafe to fix rising damp unearths 2,500 years of history in 3,000 amazing objects

2,500 years of history in 3,000 amazing objects

Excavation at Italian cafe to fix rising damp unearths trove
The Hubble Space Telescope's amazing journey, 25 years on

The Hubble Space Telescope's amazing journey 25 years on

The space telescope was seen as a costly flop on its first release
Did Conservative peer Lord Ashcroft quit the House of Lords to become a non-dom?

Did Lord Ashcroft quit the House of Lords to become a non-dom?

A document seen by The Independent shows that a week after he resigned from the Lords he sold 350,000 shares in an American company - netting him $11.2m
Apple's ethnic emojis are being used to make racist comments on social media

Ethnic emojis used in racist comments

They were intended to promote harmony, but have achieved the opposite
Sir Kenneth Branagh interview: 'My bones are in the theatre'

Sir Kenneth Branagh: 'My bones are in the theatre'

The actor-turned-director’s new company will stage five plays from October – including works by Shakespeare and John Osborne
The sloth is now the face (and furry body) of three big advertising campaigns

The sloth is the face of three ad campaigns

Priya Elan discovers why slow and sleepy wins the race for brands in need of a new image
How to run a restaurant: As two newbies discovered, there's more to it than good food

How to run a restaurant

As two newbies discovered, there's more to it than good food
Record Store Day: Remembering an era when buying and selling discs were labours of love

Record Store Day: The vinyl countdown

For Lois Pryce, working in a record shop was a dream job - until the bean counters ruined it
Usher, Mary J Blige and to give free concert as part of the Global Poverty Project

Mary J Blige and to give free concert

The concert in Washington is part of the Global Citizen project, which aims to encourage young people to donate to charity
10 best tote bags

Accessorise with a stylish shopper this spring: 10 best tote bags

We find carriers with room for all your essentials (and a bit more)
Paul Scholes column: I hear Manchester City are closing on Pep Guardiola for next summer – but I'd also love to see Jürgen Klopp managing in England

Paul Scholes column

I hear Manchester City are closing on Pep Guardiola for next summer – but I'd also love to see Jürgen Klopp managing in England
Jessica Ennis-Hill: 'I just want to give it my best shot'

Jessica Ennis-Hill: 'I just want to give it my best shot'

The heptathlete has gone from the toast of the nation to being a sleep-deprived mum - but she’s ready to compete again. She just doesn't know how well she'll do...