Barclays and HSBC report strong underlying profits

Banking giants HSBC and Barclays today reported stronger underlying profits so far this year as the gulf widens with their beleaguered taxpayer-supported counterparts.

Barclays said a third-quarter haul of £1.5 billion helped profits more than double in the first nine months on an adjusted basis, while HSBC reported results "significantly ahead" in the quarter to 30 September.

The pair, which have avoided turning to the Government for state aid, gave hope that bad debts among recession-hit borrowers were starting to level off as they reported sharp quarter-on-quarter falls in impairment charges.

Barclays reported £4.54 billion in profits for the first nine months of the year - down by nearly a fifth against a year earlier.

But the group said the result more than doubled on an underlying basis as it had enjoyed "consistent profitability" so far in 2009.

HSBC added that, on a reported basis, its third-quarter figures were lower than a year earlier, with both banks being impacted by tightening in credit market spreads.

However, it too posted improving underlying figures as the two banking heavyweights began to put the troubles of last year's financial crisis behind them.

Concerns are mounting that the better results will see the return of excessive bank bonuses.

But Barclays and HSBC sought to assure that decisions have yet to be made on full-year payouts and will take current fears into account.

Barclays said bonuses were accruing at a "broadly consistent" rate to prior years, although it claimed this did not mean it was reverting to former bonus policies.

It has already signed up to international G20 rules on pay reforms which recommend clawback clauses and deferral over a number of years.

The bank is also talking to major investors over bonus pool levels ahead of its year-end decision.

"We will be fully compliant with the G20 rules in considering bonus amounts and we will be thinking of all our stakeholders - employees, shareholders and the broader community - and we will be taking into account all of their views," said the bank.

HSBC, which has also agreed to the G20 recommendations, said it would pay "appropriate" levels, "at the same time being conscious of the environment in which we are operating".