'There was a lot of blood. He went to the factory's nurse station, passing by me,' one witness said
A worker with blood dripping from his head marked a low point in the tense, grinding life at a southeastern China factory used by Ivanka Trump and other fashion brands. An angry manager had hit him with the sharp end of a high-heeled shoe.
Workers from the factory, including one current and two former employees who spoke to The Associated Press, reported overtime that stretched past midnight, steep production quotas and crude verbal abuse at Ganzhou Huajian International Shoe City Co. They said beatings were not unheard of, but the shoe attack, which all three say they witnessed last year, was violent enough to stand out.
“He was bleeding right from the middle of the head,” the current worker said.
“There was a lot of blood. He went to the factory's nurse station, passing by me,” said a second man, who said he quit his job at Huajian because of the long hours and low pay.
The three workers are the first people with direct knowledge of conditions at the Ganzhou factory to speak with the media. All three spoke to the AP on condition of anonymity, for fear of retribution or arrest.
Last month, three men investigating conditions at the Huajian Group factory in Ganzhou were detained, accused of illegally using secret recording devices to steal commercial secrets. They, like one of the three men AP spoke with, worked with China Labour Watch, a New York nonprofit that has been investigating Ivanka Trump’s Chinese suppliers for more than a year.
Li Qiang, founder of China Labour Watch, describes Huajian's Ganzhou factory as among the worst he has seen in nearly two decades investigating labour abuses. His group says pay can be as low as a dollar an hour, in violation of China’s labour laws. According to China Labour Watch investigators, until recently, workers might get only two days off – or less – per month.
China Labour Watch said the company forced workers to sign fake pay stubs with inflated salary numbers and threatened to fire workers if they didn’t fill in questionnaires about working conditions with pre-approved answers. Workers also said the company pressured people not to speak with outsiders about conditions at the factory.
In comments to the AP, the Huajian Group declined to respond to specific questions, but broadly denied all allegations, calling them “completely not true to the facts, taken out of context, exaggerated”. The company said it operates lawfully and that China Labour Watch “invented so-called ‘facts” by illegal means of buying undercover work, which has already affected the enterprise’s normal business seriously and affected the survival and employment of tens of thousands of staff”. The company noted its significant contribution to the economy and to society, particularly through its employment of disabled people.
Before taking on an official role as adviser to her father, Ivanka Trump stepped back from day-to-day management of her brand, but she has retained her ownership interest. She has not commented on the detentions or the reports of poor working conditions at one of her brand’s suppliers. Her spokeswoman declined to comment for this story.
Abigail Klem, president of the Ivanka Trump brand, said “the integrity of our supply chain is a top priority and we take all allegations very seriously”. The company says its products have not been made in the factory since March, but China Labour Watch said it had an April production schedule indicating that nearly 1,000 pairs of Ivanka Trump shoes were due in May.
In the past, some brands have used China Labour Watch's reports as a tool to help keep their supply chains clean. Walt Disney Co., for example, investigated and ultimately decided to sever its relationship with at least one supplier following reports of poor conditions, and sought to improve labour practices at others.
China Labour Watch outlined its findings in letters sent in June to Ivanka Trump at the White House and to other brands. So far, the group says it has gotten no response.
The group said it also sent Ivanka Trump a video taken inside the factory in May. That video included a clip in which a manager threatened to rough up a worker who had apparently arranged shoes in the wrong order.
“If I see them f--ing messed up again,” the manager yells, “I’ll beat you right here.”
The video has not been released to the public, but it was shown to AP at China Labour Watch’s office in New York.
Marc Fisher, which has made shoes for Ivanka Trump and Easy Spirit at the Ganzhou factory, has said it would look into the allegations.
G-III Apparel Group, which produces shoes for Karl Lagerfeld, said it had not received a letter but “fully supports the independent monitoring of global supply chains”.
Business picture of the day
English wine producers celebrate record turnover from past year
On the rise and no longer laughing, stocks of English wine have enjoyed a record year. Independent English wine producers have defied ridicule to register £132m in turnover from 2015-2016, an all-time high, according to new research by online business finance supermarket Funding Options. Getty Ivanka Trump and World Bank to start fund for women entrepreneurs
The World Bank said it will start a fund to finance women entrepreneurs, an idea it developed in tandem with Ivanka Trump, the daughter of the US president. The Women Entrepreneurs Finance Initiative will make more than $1bn available to improve access to capital for women, the Washington-based development institution said Saturday. The fund will provide technical assistance and invest in projects and programmes that support women and women-led small- and mid-size businesses, said the World Bank, which bankrolls development in poor countries. AP How to use a student loan to build a £4m travel business
Lee McAteer and his 100-strong team will send 20,000 British millennials to summer camps all over the world, from Massachusetts to Mali, this year, through his empire of holiday companies catering for 18-30s. You could call him a pretty successful businessman. Or you could call him Lee Mac, like the aspiring business owners he gives free space and support to at his hip office in Salford. Or even “Britain’s best boss” like the Daily Mail did when he pranked his team by turning the whole office into a giant ball pit. Just don’t call him an entrepreneur. Invasion British Airways to pay strikers' bonuses to cabin crew who are working
In a move that seems certain to inflame the cabin crew dispute, British Airways is paying staff working normally the bonuses that would have gone to their colleagues who are on strike. Members of Mixed Fleet, who are employed on less-favourable terms than longer-serving Heathrow cabin crew, are normally paid a bonus known as My Incentive. Karen Slinger, head of inflight customer experience, has told staff that the airline is saving money “as a result of not paying My Incentive within Q1 and Q2 to those Mixed Fleet crew taking strike action”. Reuters Sports Direct boss Mike Ashley tells high court he is a 'power drinker' and enjoys binging
Mike Ashley has reportedly told a high court judge that he likes binging on alcohol and is a “power drinker”. On the fourth day of a trial in London, where the Sports Direct boss is being sued by investment banker Jeffrey Blue, Mr Ashley was asked how much he had been drinking when he allegedly made a deal with Mr Blue relating to Sports Direct’s share price, according to the BBC. Reuters Brexit concerns shrink UK's lead as Europe's top finance hub
Brexit concerns have bitten into the UK’s lead as Europe’s top financial services location for investors, new research shows. The UK’s financial services industry has retained its title as Europe’s most attractive location for international investment, but its lead has narrowed due to fears over the impact of Brexit, according to a report by professional services firm EY. Reuters Longest squeeze on household incomes since 1970s, says ONS
The aggregate real disposable income of UK households has fallen for three quarters in a row for the first time since the 1970s, according to the Office for National Statistics. The ONS said that the inflation-adjusted compensation of the household sector fell 1.4 per cent in the first three months of 2017, reflecting spiking inflation and weak pay growth. Macrobond, The Independent Brexit worries Wimbledon strawberry farmer who depends on EU workers
The owner of the farm which provides Wimbledon with its strawberries has said she hopes there is a “mechanism” for European citizens to work seasonally in the UK after Brexit. Marion Regan, who owns Hugh Lowe Farms in Kent with her husband Jon, relies on seasonal labour to make sure Wimbledon is supplied with fresh strawberries throughout the tournament. Reuters Consumer confidence slips back to post-Brexit vote lows
Consumer confidence is now almost back down to the lows seen in the wake of last June's Brexit referendum, adding to a picture of a wilting consumer in the face of fast rising inflation and weak wage growth. The latest GfK Index slipped to -10 in June, down from -5 in the previous month, its lowest since last July. Tobacco giant Philip Morris wants everyone to quit smoking
Philip Morris International, the world’s second largest tobacco company, has said it wants people to quit the habit. Peter Nixon, UK and Ireland managing director for the global tobacco giant said “We are absolutely serious - one day we want to stop selling cigarettes.” Alibaba’s Jack Ma warns evolving technology could cause World War III
Chinese business magnate Jack Ma said that evolving technologies are likely to pose a threat to more than just the job market and could in fact trigger a Third World War. In an interview with CNBC, the billionaire chairman of Alibaba said that world leaders have a duty to educate people to prevent the pain caused by a rapid rise in automation and artificial intelligence. Getty Japanese bank Nomura chooses Frankfurt for EU headquarters after UK's withdrawal
Nomura picked Frankfurt as the headquarters for its European Union operations after the UK leaves the bloc, people with knowledge of the matter said. Japan’s biggest brokerage will start preparations this month to form a base in the German financial centre, one of the people said, asking not to be identified as the matter is confidential. It will seek regulatory approval and find office space before transferring fewer than 100 employees from London to the city, according to the person. Getty Images will.i.am says artificial intelligence will be more disruptive to UK tech than EU withdrawal
The reckless rise of artificial intelligence is going to be much more disruptive for the London technology scene in the longer run than Britain’s departure from the EU, according to musician, entrepreneur and philanthropist will.i.am. Speaking at an event celebrating his collaboration with Atom Bank, an app-based digital-only bank launched last year, the founding member of The Black Eyed Peas said that by 2030, Brexit will be “an old school thought” for the UK’s rapidly evolving tech industry and AI will present a much more acute challenge. Getty Images How climate change will threaten food security of world's poorest countries
Some of the world’s poorest countries will be hit hardest as climate change affects marine fisheries all over the world, according to a new study. The global fishing industry produces a total catch worth of about $90bn (£71bn) but the warming ocean temperatures are causing many valuable species to shift their usual ranges. Lisa Murray Supersonic passenger jet to take off next year
An American firm is promising the return of supersonic passenger aviation, with transatlantic airfares “about the same price as today’s business class tickets”. Boom, based in Denver, says London-New York will cost £2,000 one-way and take just 3 hours 15 minutes. With a planned cruising speed of 1,451mph, the plane is almost 100mph faster than Concorde. Casamigos: George Clooney tequila brand sold for $1bn to drinks giant Diageo
George Clooney is selling his US tequila brand Casamigos to British beverage company Diageo for almost $1bn (£790m). The London-based distiller will initially pay $700m (£553m) for Casamigos and possibly an additional $300m (£237m) based on the performance of the brand over the next decade. The purchase will be Diageo's biggest since it bought United Spirits for $3.2 billion (£2.5 billion) in 2014. Getty Images Jaguar Land Rover to create 5,000 new jobs
Britain's biggest carmaker Jaguar Land Rover will hire 5,000 staff as it boosts its skills in autonomous and electric technology, a welcome business endorsement as Prime Minister Theresa May starts Brexit talks after a botched election. JLR, which employs more than 40,000 people globally, said it would hire 1,000 electronic and software engineers as well as 4,000 additional personnel including in manufacturing, most of whom will be based in Britain. European shares rebound as Emmanuel Macron wins historic majority
Internet giants will face increased pressure to tackle online extremism as European leaders were expected to back a UK-led drive for tougher internet regulation. Foreign Secretary Boris Johnson will lead calls to ensure there is “no safe space for terrorists” to plot attacks and share radical material online when he attends a meeting of EU foreign ministers in Luxembourg on Monday. Reuters The real reason UK employers hire European Union workers
While the end of free movement is presented by politicians as ‘taking control’, for employers it means quite the reverse – it means a loss of control, it means new barriers to recruitment and, for some, the risk of irreparable damage. In our research at the National Institute for Economic and Social Research (NIESR) before and after the referendum vote we’ve detected a gradual change in outlook among employers. AP Boris Johnson calls on internet giants to leave 'no safe space for terrorists'
Internet giants will face increased pressure to tackle online extremism as European leaders were expected to back a UK-led drive for tougher internet regulation. Foreign Secretary Boris Johnson will lead calls to ensure there is “no safe space for terrorists” to plot attacks and share radical material online when he attends a meeting of EU foreign ministers in Luxembourg on Monday. Rex Amazon to buy Whole Foods for $13.7 billion
Amazon, the e-commerce behemoth that sells everything from toothpaste to tennis shoes, has announced it will purchase grocery store Whole Foods for $13.7bn (£10.7bn). The Seattle-based retailer will buy the popular health food chain for $42 per share, pending approval by its shareholders. Getty Workers producing Ivanka Trump's fashion line subjected to verbal abuse and 'poverty pay'
Ivanka Trump has come under fire again after workers at a factory making clothes for her brand in Indonesia described an environment of “verbal abuse” and poverty wages. More than a dozen workers at the factory in Subang told the Guardian that they regularly work unpaid overtime and are paid one of the lowest minimum wages in Asia, despite production targets that are impossible to meet. AP EU launches antitrust investigation into Nike, Universal Studios and Hello Kitty owner
The EU has launched antitrust investigations into Nike, Universal Studios and the owner of the Hello Kitty brand, over their licensing and distribution practices within the single market. In a statement, the European commission said that it was looking into whether the three companies were illegally preventing retailers from selling certain goods licensed by them across borders and online, thereby breaking competition rules. Morrisons is selling 16oz 'Daddy of all burgers' for Father's Day
The “daddy of all burgers” has arrived, just in time for Father's Day. Morrisons launched the huge, one pound, 18cm monster, which should satisfy even the hungriest of dads, on Wednesday. Each one is made by butchers in-store using 100 per cent British beef seasoned with paprika, sage and parsley. Morrisons claims it is the biggest beef burger money can buy in a UK supermarket, and it costs just £3. Shoppers will have to be quick however, as the oversized patties are only available until Sunday. PA Trade unions have slammed a review into the gig economy and changing working practices across the UK. Unite, the country's largest union said Tueasday's report "spectacularly failed to deliver" on its promise to tackle the problem of insecure work, while the GMB described it as a "disappointing missed opportunity". Business groups delivered a mixed reaction to the long-awaited Taylor review, with the Institute of Directors saying it "strikes the right balance". Getty Thames Water hit with £8.55m fine after failing to reduce leakages
While that is the premise of Snap's popular messaging platform, investors also saw any gains from its red-hot IPO disappear when shares plunged far below their initial sale price on Tuesday. Morgan Stanley, a lead underwriter on the company's initial public offering, slapped a price target of $16 (£12.48) on the stock - a dollar below its March IPO price. Analyst Brian Nowak wrote in the note that “we have been wrong about Snap's ability to innovate and improve its ad product this year.” Bloomberg UK General election 2017: Pound sterling hovers near two-week high as voters take to the polls
Travel money and consumer finance startup Revolut secured $66m (£51.3m) in funding last week, bringing total investment to $83m. The UK-based prepaid debit card provider offers foreign currencies at the Interbank or ‘wholesale’ exchange rate - generally better than that offered by conventional bureau de change. UK car production slumps by nearly a fifth in April as timing of Easter bites - Thursday May 24
I warned yesterday that Theresa May’s Government would be unlikely to stand for it if Matthew Taylor’s review into the “Gig Economy” proposed radical reforms to make Britain fairer. Turns out that she didn’t have much to worry about on that score. The review contains lots of pretty words, but the likes of Uber, Deliveroo and the rest will probably be breathing a sigh of relief in the wake of its publication. PA Marks and Spencer reports slump in profit hurt by clothing sales and cost of new food stores - Wednesday 24 May
An arm of the technology giant Samsung has decided not to set up its European headquarters in London because the city is “not a fun place to live unless you are really rich”. Speaking to The Times, Felix Petersen, the managing director of Samsung Next Europe, a $150m (£117m) technology fund owned by the South Korean company, said that Berlin had been selected as a location for the fund instead. “When workplace safety and fairness issues are brought to our attention, we take them very seriously and work with our partners to resolve them,” G-III spokesman Chris Giglio said in an email.
Ann Taylor spokesman Shawn Buchanan also said the company takes the allegations “very seriously” and is “actively conducting an investigation to assess this facility's compliance with our code of conduct and applicable laws and regulations”.
The Kendall & Kyle brand said its “footwear manufacturer works with many footwear production factories and all factories are required to operate within strict social compliance regulations”.
Other brands identified by China Labour Watch as customers of the Ganzhou factory include Nine West, Naturalizer and the Camuto Group, which makes shoes for BCBG Max Azria, Jessica Simpson and Tory Burch. None responded to requests for comment.
The current Huajian employee who spoke to the AP said life at the factory has changed since the arrests of the three investigators brought the glare of public attention.
Overtime was radically reduced this month, he said. Shifts used to run from 7.10am until after 9pm or 10pm, and sometimes after midnight, with two daily breaks, he and a former employee both said. But for the last few weeks, workers have been released before 7pm.
They're also starting to get every Sunday off, which is standard under Chinese labour law, said the current employee, who also moonlights for China Labour Watch.
City government officials turned up recently, he said, and the factory gave everyone an egg to eat in the middle of their afternoon shift.
Life inside Ganzhou Huajian is focused on a single number: the monthly quota of shoes that must be produced, according to China Labour Watch investigators and workers. A single production line of 50 workers may need to produce close to 30,000 pairs of shoes, depending on seasonal demand, the current employee and one former employee told AP.
Those who miss their targets do not collect the full salary, said the current employee.
“It is impossible to meet the target, actually, because it just keeps on going up,” the former employee said.
The new abbreviated working hours are a mixed blessing, the current employee said, because they haven't been able to meet production targets.
Huajian, meanwhile, has been moving production to Ethiopia, where workers make around $100 a month, a fraction of what they pay in China, according to Song Yiping, a manager at Huajian's Ethiopian factory, who spoke to the AP in January. He said he’s heard President Trump talk about bringing jobs back to America, but he doubts that will happen with shoes. Even Chinese vocational school dropouts don't want to work for Ethiopian wages.
“The American clients push down the price,” Song explained. “Consumers want to buy cheaper shoes.”
AP