Exams head: Balls 'sexed up' evidence against me

Accusations fly over chaos that beset national curriculum tests last year

News in pictures
News in pictures
On Facebook
From the blogs

Tyrannosaur and Drive: The difference between loneliness and being alone

The prospect of loneliness is probably one of the biggest fears that humans have to contend with. Mo...

The Woman in Black: From page, to stage, to film

Director James Watkins and screenwriter Jane Goldman discuss how they kept up the constant high leve...

The future of academic publishing

These are the most uncertain times in living memory for academic publishing. After decades of bumpin...

Books with soundtracks: no, really, this one works…

Books with soundtracks. The idea is so glaringly obvious, and so obviously feeble, that I hesitate t...

Ministers "sexed up evidence" to an inquiry into last summer's national curriculum tests fiasco to discredit the head of the Government's exams watchdog, MPs heard yesterday.

Both the Children's Secretary Ed Balls and Schools minister Jim Knight misled Parliament and the inquiry about the role of Ken Boston, the former chief executive of the Qualifications and Curriculum Authority, in the affair, they were told.

Dr Boston said he was treated as if he was "a troublesome priest" that they wanted to rid themselves of. "A plot was devised well before the failure of the national curriculum tests," he told MPs on the Commons committee monitoring education.

His main allegation centred on an account of a meeting on 17 June between himself, Mr Knight and the National Assessment Agency – the wing of the QCA responsible for delivering the test results – in which Mr Knight implied that Dr Boston was "disengaged" and "complacent" in deflecting all questions.

In a letter to the Select Committee, Dr Boston said: "This is fiction. I was not at the meeting." However, Mr Knight's account formed the basis of evidence to the inquiry held by Lord Sutherland, the former chief schools inspector, and was later repeated by Mr Balls to MPs.

"At the end of a 45-year career in education, I don't wish to be portrayed by a minister as complacent and disengaged when it is untrue and based on false evidence," Dr Boston said.

"I resent evidence against me being presented by ministers being sexed up in a report for Lord Sutherland."

Mr Knight later wrote to the inquiry – after publication – to admit his information had been incorrect.

Dr Boston also revealed that, six days after giving evidence to the Sutherland inquiry, he received an approach from Sir David Bell, the Permanent Under-Secretary at Mr Balls' department, asking if they could negotiate an early resignation. "It was on the grounds that the report would be bad for me," he said. "By the time the two ministers gave their evidence to the inquiry the skids were under me."

Last night Sir David said that ministers did not know of his approach.

Dr Boston said relations had soured earlier over disagreements in the formation of Ofqual, the new exams regulator. Dr Boston said that he wanted it to be given more independence.

He said he should have resigned two years earlier in 2006 when ministers rejected his plans for reforming the way national curriculum tests were marked by moving towards a system of online marking successfully trialled for GCSEs and A-levels.

"I was left running an organisation that was faced with an impossible task," Dr Boston said.

Ministers turned down the idea because he could not guarantee the test results would be the same, he said.

"They would be better but they would be different," he said. "They may be better, they may be worse but they would not be the same. That was too big a gamble."

Dr Boston also criticised the way the inquiry framework was drafted to ensure it only investigated the actions of the QCA and ETS Europe, the firm given the contract to deliver the results, and the use of government observers at QCA meetings. He said that the remit set out by Mr Balls had thrown a "protective cloak" around ministers. On the observers, he said it had the effect of making supposedly independent quangos only put forward advice ministers wanted to hear.

Graham Stuart, a Conservative member of the select committee, said: "I would like to hear evidence from the ministers and certainly ministers might well consider their positions on the basis of what we have heard today."

A spokesman for Mr Balls' department said Mr Knight had acknowledged the information about the meeting was incorrect but Lord Sutherland had indicated that it made no difference to the outcome of his inquiry.

Testing times: Boston's claims

The claim Ministers "sexed up" evidence to the inquiry to discredit him, and the Schools minister Jim Knight accused him of deflecting questions about the crisis at a crucial meeting.

What happened Dr Boston was not present at that meeting.

The claim The "skids" were under him before the inquiry reported.

What happened He was approached by Sir David Bell, the Permanent Under Secretary at Ed Balls' department, before the inquiry reported, asking to negotiate an early resignation.

The claim The remit of the inquiry ignored any part that Mr Balls' department had played in the crisis.

What happened It was just asked to investigate the role of the QCA and ETS Europe, the firm handling the contract, in the run-up to the test result delays.

Independent Comment
blog comments powered by Disqus

Day In a Page

Eat it don't tweet it: Do table manners still matter?

Eat it don't tweet it: Do table manners still matter?

In the technological age, modern dining etiquette is about so much more than just keeping your elbows off the table.
The 10 best knife sets

The 10 best knife sets

From blades inspired by Japanese master sword craftsmen to ceramic blades that feel as light as a feather
Once a Redgrave: Joely Richardson on playing the role made famous by her mother and sister

Once a Redgrave: Joely Richardson

The actress discusses playing a role made famous by her mother and sister
The growth industry: Veg boxes have gone from a niche product for worthies to a foodies' essential

The growth industry: Veg boxes

Vegetable boxes have gone from a niche product for worthies to a foodies' essential
RIBA's latest exhibition charts the changing face of the British home

Changing face of the British home

Oliver Bennett explores the Royal Institute of British Architects’ latest exhibition
First Night: In the Land of Blood and Honey, Berlin Film Festival

First Night: In the Land of Blood and Honey

Courage under fire! Jolie's debut is not for faint-hearted
The XX files: The hunt for victims of Guatemala's 36-year war

The XX files

The hunt for victims of Guatemala's 36-year war
Rein man: did Dustin Hoffman harm horses in his new drama?

Did Dustin Hoffman harm horses in his new drama?

Big-budget HBO series targeted by campaigners after two star performers had to be put down
How the FA can win with Harry's game

How the FA can win with Harry's game

Even an initial part-time role up to Euro 2012 would work, while England could be set free by Redknapp
James Lawton: Blame for this awful mess lies squarely with Capello

James Lawton

Blame for this awful mess lies squarely with Capello
Chris Ashton: Not so flash but still keen to make a splash in Rome

Chris Ashton interview

Not so flash but still keen to make a splash in Rome
London Eye: She's buddies with Bolt but this golden girl revels in anonymity

Simon Turnbull's London Eye

Jamaica's Trecia Smith is buddies with Bolt but this golden girl revels in anonymity
The data goldmine: Why forgetting to log out can cost you dearly

Data goldmine: Have you forgotten to log out?

David Crookes finds out how much stolen Twitter accounts, hacked eBay pages and more are really worth.
The 10 best free games

The 10 best free games

From The Secret of Grisly Manor to Words With Friends...
Fear and loathing in London: The Death of Klinghoffer is staged in the capital for the first time

Fear and loathing in London: The Death of Klinghoffer

The ENO is staging the controversial opera in the capital for the first time