Education

Rain (AM and PM) 3° London Hi 9°C / Lo 6°C

Licence to chill: the primary school taking learning to another level

It may sound far-fetched but meditation is helping 11-year-olds to calm down and learn better. Hilary Wilce visits a school where pupils spend an hour a week relaxing

Meditation's what you need: children at Latchmere School in Kingston upon Thames practise their relaxation techniques. Many of the school's pupils value getting in touch with themselves

JOHN LAWRENCE

Meditation's what you need: children at Latchmere School in Kingston upon Thames practise their relaxation techniques. Many of the school's pupils value getting in touch with themselves

The film-maker David Lynch wants schools to teach meditation and has announced a campaign to support "consciousness-based" education around the world. Last month, Paul McCartney and Ringo Starr joined other music stars for a New York concert that raised £2m for his transcendental cause.

Lynch argues that every child needs "to dive into within himself and experience the field of silence – bliss – the enormous reservoir of energy and intelligence which is within us all." And the 600-plus pupils at Latchmere School in Kingston upon Thames would agree. Every child in this busy, successful primary school spends an hour a week in the school's chill-out Blue Room learning meditation and relaxation techniques, including visualisation and massage.

The Year Six pupils are the school's most experienced meditators. They have been doing it for four years and say they will take what they've learnt with them when they move to secondary school. In fact, they already use it in their daily lives. "I had a broken arm and was in hospital and it was all hectic and my arm hurt and so I used deep breathing and it felt better," says Charlie Baker.

Kate Rouvray, 11, also benefits from meditation. "We've had to do a lot of SAT practice tests but I did my breathing and felt really calm," she says.

According to Chris Howden, 11, meditation has changed the whole ethos of the school. "When you're playing games and people are arguing about goals and stuff, they know how to calm themselves down and get on with it," he says.

Over the years, these pupils have become so practised in settling down and turning inwards that when deputy head Kevin Hogston leads them in a short meditation session, they drop easily into a deep and focused calm.

Hogston developed the idea some years ago when looking at ways to encourage creativity and good learning. As well as setting up the Blue Room, he has introduced classroom routines such as a morning handshake, and having pupils post their pictures along a "feelings meter" every day.

"I wasn't a meditator," he says. "I am entirely non-religious, non-anything. My whole focus was simply on embracing the things that would give children the best possible chance of reaching their potential."

But it is clear that in the Blue Room, with its cloud-painted ceiling, fish tank and fountain, pupils are given more than just a calm space in their busy week. "One of the things we talk about is, 'Is everything we think true? Is that person really horrible, or is there a bit of a fault that's coming up?'" Hogston says. Pupils are taught about the importance of living in the moment, and how to use visualisations to switch their brain to feeling alert and good about life.

Meditation is practised by millions, but still seen by many as weird and alternative. "Some people think it's a strange thing for a school to do," he acknowledges. "When we started training the teachers, about 60 per cent said, 'Great, we do this in yoga,' but 30 per cent said, 'Convince me.'" The school head, Julie Ritchie, stresses that the Blue Room is simply one part of the whole "caring and learning" ethos underpinning the school.

Parents have also been supportive, and some pupils love it so much that there is a popular weekly meditation club. "It is amazing to see children giving up things like football to come to the Blue Room to calm down and meditate," says Hogston.

Jonathan Peers, a Year Six teacher, says the programme gives children skills that are vital for school and life. "That ability to show empathy, to be able to look after yourself and your peers, is very important, and you can see the effect on them."

The Latchmere programme, says Hogston, is based on "common-sense meditation" and its pragmatic mix is very different from the structured transcendental meditation (TM) that David Lynch is promoting in schools.

But Dr Fred Travis, director of the Center for Brain, Consciousness and Cognition, at the Maharishi University of Management, Iowa, says there is strong evidence that TM relaxes and integrates the brain more than any other type of meditation. "With all other methods there is always some sort of striving or focusing, which means the brain is still active and busy. With TM the content of your brain is decreased but the awareness is maintained."

On a recent visit to the UK he spoke to staff and students at Cambridge University and the University of London's Institute of Education about how meditation can act as a buffer against stress, and produce brain activity read-outs that show that beneficial Alpha brain waves flow more strongly in someone practising TM than in meditators using other methods such as Zen meditation. He also wired up an experienced meditator with electrodes to show how the effect of TM on the brain can be marked and instant.

There is growing evidence that today's young people urgently need meditation's beneficial effects, he says. Slides of brain activity demonstrate how alcohol, drugs, stress, poverty and sleep deprivation change the brain so it has a diminished ability to reflect, remember and process. "Everything we do has an impact on the brain and will physically change it."

The David Lynch Foundation for Consciousness-Based Education and World Peace is aiming to teach a million schoolchildren to meditate, and heads of schools in the US who have introduced it says it makes students more settled and confident. In the UK a growing number of schools are showing an interest in meditation programmes, and a number of heads and teachers are publicly committed to TM.

At £320-a-head for every teacher and pupil, the TM programme is not cheap, however, although the Maharishi Foundation, which is offering the Consciousness-Based Education programme to UK schools, says this is because it is individually taught by trained meditation teachers.

It claims TM is effective with children suffering from attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder, and can radically change the atmosphere in the toughest schools. But some critics assert that the Maharishi Mahesh Yogi made a multimillion-dollar fortune from packaging up a simple technique and selling it to gullible Westerners, and even today the image of TM remains irrevocably mixed with memories of the Beatles in their hippie days.

So while ideas about developing calmness and relaxation are now making headway in schools, it remains to be seen whether David Lynch's money will be able to persuade them that TM is the way to do it.

Post a Comment

View all comments that have been posted about this article.

Offensive or abusive comments will be removed and your IP logged and may be used to prevent further submission. In submitting a comment to the site, you agree to be bound by the Independent Minds Terms of Service.

Comments

My Back Pages
[info]misterhawaii wrote:
Thursday, 28 May 2009 at 03:34 am (UTC)
Boy things have changed since I went to school. We didn't have a Blue Room for relaxation back then. Fortunately there was a public lecture on Transcendental Meditation at my high school and I attended the lecture and learned on my own. At that time meditation was a strange thing but now its pretty commonplace. One side note: Transcendental Meditation is a non-profit charity, not a business and the Maharishi himself was a monk without a bank account in his name. Sure the TM organization got big. so whats wrong with that? If it hadn't of grown then we wouldn't be reading this article and millions would not be getting its benefit. So tell the critics to stop being so critical. Peace to all!
TM and ADHD
[info]keithlov4esluke wrote:
Thursday, 28 May 2009 at 03:48 am (UTC)
The claims that TM is effective in helping children with attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder, is actually gaining more and more ground thanks to empirical proof, some of which is listed at http://www.tm.org/benefits-adhd#q08. To me, proof was gained through direct experience. I have a little stepdaughter who had been diagnosed with ADHD. Her mother wanted her to be put on medication, Ritalin, Dehexedrin, that sort of thing. Luckily, we decided to try transcendental meditation first. The child improved right away, she was able to focus better, interact better, and her relationship with other children improved, she no longer had outbursts. Six years later, she has no trace of ADHD. I think that something so powerfully effective needs to be given very serious consideration. I for one, would love to see our children be given access to it in school.
TM helped manage ADHD
[info]richtext2 wrote:
Thursday, 28 May 2009 at 04:52 am (UTC)
My godson had ADHD at age five, when he learned Transcendental Meditation. He ran riot around the house and his single mother dropped into bed at 11:30 every night, exhausted, with him still up and refusing to go to bed. Needless to say he was useless the next morning and had to be dragged out of bed and into school. Within a few months of learning Transcendental Meditation he was going to bed at 8:30pm and meditating in bed with his mum for five minutes. He wouldn't sleep straight away but he would lie singing contentedly to himself until he fell asleep. In TM he found an experience that satisfied whatever he was looking for, a tender and personal experience that could do more than all the attempts to control him, or drugs. And it was all his own, and independent of external circumstances, under his own control.
meditation
[info]clarify108 wrote:
Thursday, 28 May 2009 at 05:12 am (UTC)
The important points abut Transcendental Meditation are that is backed by over six hundred scientific studies, it is effortless to do and easy to learn and is practised twice a day everyday. Lieing down for hour a week will have its value but will not produce the same benefits as Transcendental Meditation.
Exactly what schools need
[info]danrjohnstone wrote:
Thursday, 28 May 2009 at 05:47 am (UTC)
The fact that Consciousness-based Education is so systematic and simple means that it can be reliably introduced into any school. The extensive scientific research shows that it benefits pupils AND teachers. The cost of learning is tiny compared with the budget for education and the extensive benefits not only to the pupils but also to every aspect of the school.
TM Reduces Anxiety
[info]drjeantobin wrote:
Thursday, 28 May 2009 at 06:02 am (UTC)
Thank you for this article which mentions Transcendental Meditation's successful results in schools around the world. One study not mentioned in this article showed TM to be 3 to 4 times as effective at reducing anxiety than any other mental technique claiming to reduce anxiety. TM has been a great help to me, allowing me to remain calm in situations that would have previously resulted in my feeling anxious and angry. We need to start looking at rigorous scientific research to find out what works to make our children healthier, smarter and happier. Transcendental Meditation Technique (TM.org) brings benefits in all areas of life. You will find the closer you look the better you realize it is! I looked into it and found out the 350 peer-reviewed research studies were conducted on over 10,000 subjects who were practicing the TM technique. These studies included numerous randomized controlled trials, along with eight meta-analyses of 597 separate studies on the effects of meditation. The studies were conducted at Harvard Medical School, Yale Medical School, Stanford Medical School, University of PA, University of Kentucky, and more than 200 other independent institutions, and were done by 360 scientists from 29 countries. All total, over 30,0000 subjects (participating in TM, other techniques or controls) were involved in the hundreds of research studies on TM. The majority of these studies compared TM to other practices or control groups. TM deserves serious consideration when deciding any school curriculum.
The Technique of Algorythmy
[info]sandrian wrote:
Thursday, 28 May 2009 at 06:31 am (UTC)
Algorythmy! Well I made that word up to describe the 'process' of meditation itself as yoga teaches it. This process of meditation consists of the adding, on the level of thinking, of a word of no conceptual meaning or content to the natural flow of our thoughts, thus the inner intentional momentum of thinking is distracted. In this the dynamic of thinking does not form a new conceptual platform for whatever stray thoughts that may arise in the quietude of the inner. In the 'process' of meditation, in the 'algorythmy', thoughts are not taken to their conclusion, no new momentum for activity is generated and the vehicle of the meditative process, the mantra itself (from the Sanskrit, 'man'=to think, ponder, and 'tra'=indicates instrumentality [after Feuerstein, Kak, Frawley, 2001]) also fades away and the mind is left without content. This state is subjectively experienced as a deep blissful rest (theistically neutral) and objectively as a deep metabolic rest (see the scientific research). It's all about rest and activity, first one rests (deeply) then one acts, these are the two steps of yoga. Yoga is a paradigm of rest and activity. The process is recursively repeatable, as if it were a back-propagating algorithm: thus 'algorythmy'. (For more on this see my blog http://another-albatross.blogspot.com/ where I define the paradigm.)

I have been teaching the method of Transcendental Meditation since 1971; Hey! George, Paul, Ringo and John, thanks to you all, and I am still at it). In his first lecture in 1958 Maharishi Mahesh Yogi said that any word may do, then he says the word 'mike' and knocks on the microphone, yah!, but ideally the mantra should be devoid of any connotation which is the reason it it is not used in any other circumstance (such as speaking it out loud), it but fades, as one does the algorythmy, and that's it.

Sandrian (Another Albatross)

Juri Aidas, from Sweden.
TM
[info]helen_evans27 wrote:
Thursday, 28 May 2009 at 09:27 am (UTC)
I have been a specialist teacher for children with Specific Learning Difficulties for twenty five years. I am also a teacher of Transcendental Meditation. Over the years, I have taught many of my pupils to meditate (TM) with fantastic results. The dyslexics become less frustrated by their difficulties and are consequently able to achieve more. The pupils with ADHD begin to concentrate more easily on their work and are less distracted in the classroom. Several of my colleagues in various schools have also learned TM and find the experience of teaching more enjoyable. They think more clearly, plan more effectively and are more creative in their teaching styles. They are calmer, more centred and consequently more tolerant and understanding of pupils' difficulties.

One school in Lancashire, established over twenty years ago, is a dedicated Transcendental Meditation School - the Maharishi School, named after the founder of the TM Movement who devoted his life to bringing greater peace and harmony to the world. The children start and end their day with a ten minute meditation and visitors always comment on how impressed they are by the calm atmosphere and focused work ethos. The school has an extremely impressive record of success in all areas, particularly in Poetry, Science and Maths competitions!

TM is practised by 6 million people worldwide and the David Lynch Foundation was set up some years ago to bring Maharishi's knowledge - Consciousness based Education - to more and more schools around the world. David Lynch's aim is to enable our children to enjoy more creativity, a more comprehensive intelligence, better health and more fulfilling relationships, thereby achieving their full potential more easily, which is, after all, the purpose of education and the goal of every school.

Helen Evans, Director of TM Wales
'Licence to Chill'
[info]rwbuswell wrote:
Thursday, 28 May 2009 at 11:47 am (UTC)
I am pleased to see educators now recognising the importance and possibility of enhancing the developing brains of students particularly through Transcendental Meditation (TM). At the Maharishi School in Lancashire we have taught consciousness-based education for over 25 years. All the pupils age 5 to 16 practice TM at school, and the results in terms of academic development and student well-being have been consistently outstanding - despite non-selective entry. Transcendental Meditation remains the 'industry standard' for developing creativity and intelligence in students and is extensively documented. The latest evidential input from the field of Neurophysiology as described by Dr Fred Travis and mentioned in the article underlines the great benefit to be had from adding TM into the school day.
Richard Buswell MSc , Maharishi School Council
TM in Schools
[info]candyshoes wrote:
Thursday, 28 May 2009 at 01:25 pm (UTC)
This is a wonderful article on the need to reduce stress for children and teachers in schools and how the Transcendental Meditation program can provide the means to these ends. I have been doing TM myself since my student days, and i know first hand how it helped me to learn better, improve my memory, and do better in exams. I found the whole learning experience to be much more fluid and easy after I learned TM. Now, thanks to the David Lynch Foundation, the TM program can be made available to schools all over the world. What a great endeavor and I wish them the best of luck!
I stand corrected
[info]leamutt wrote:
Thursday, 28 May 2009 at 01:45 pm (UTC)

I must admit to being rather sniffy about this but after reading this I am very much open-minded.

Congrats to all for contributing.
TM works - and so does Tai Chi.
[info]sickofstupidity wrote:
Thursday, 28 May 2009 at 03:41 pm (UTC)
I learned TM when I was 15.

TM works; I know this both from my own experience and from the countless scientific studies of it that support its claims of unrivalled efficacy in everything from stress-management to intellectual function. I think teaching it to all school children, including it in the National Curriculum, in fact, would be an excellent idea.

But I would also like to see schools teaching kids Tai Chi; it also has a profound effect on reducing mental and physical stress and promoting overall well-being. In addition, it is an excellent form of exercise that develops balance, good body-posture, spatial awareness, muscle tone, agility and coordination, while being pleasant and easy to learn for people of all ages and physical abilities. And because it is a gentle form of exercise that does not require great flexibility, strength or stamina (though it does develop these over time), or getting out of breath, it will not discourage those kids who are averse to more traditional forms of sport and physical exercise at school.

Introducing both TM and Tai Chi to school curricula would have immeasurable benefits for school children, both physically and psychologically, that would last their entire lives. Are there any schools that currently do this?
A great program
[info]kheney wrote:
Thursday, 28 May 2009 at 03:47 pm (UTC)
It's great to hear about another school reciving the benefits of meditation through the David Lynch Foundation. The David Lynch Foundation has brought a great gift to schools around the world. Any approach to improving kids' lives that is so different to Westerners will always be questioned and there will be many who are suspicious. The technique has been around for many centuries, and it's had astounding results in schools. I hope there continue to be stories like this as people focus onthe results of bringing meditation to schools rather than their fears and suspicions.
The DLF has an informative website at: http://www.davidlynchfoundation.org/
TM in schools
[info]tmhelpedme wrote:
Friday, 29 May 2009 at 09:14 pm (UTC)
TM reversed my educational misfortunes as a teenager by enabling me to succeed in exams. It also helped me to communicate with my immediate family. It is simple, easy, natural and its wide-ranging benefits have been scientifically validated. Of all the methods of raising standards in education currently on the table, I believe TM has the most to offer.
On TM and the Philosophy of Yoga.
[info]sandrian wrote:
Friday, 29 May 2009 at 10:29 pm (UTC)
Hi again,

I'm glad to see so may positive comments here on Hilary Wilce's article. I hope it'll all work out well, the schools an' all, with the children an' all. The youngest person I ever taught this meditation technique to was a li'l girl of eight, and it went well, hope she's doin' fine. But with TM children generally are not told to sit and meditate for any longer stretch of time, not even to sit, let the whole thing be a play, they do it a little differently and are encouraged to do this when they notice that they have become quieter in their play (which surely must be the most natural state to be in as one is a child), an' a li'l regularity wont hurt, when ones parents are quietly meditation, or doing other yogic practice, such as, say, bodily movements or breathing techniques, then, then's the time to encourage the kids to be a li'l quiet, eh?. They do the 'silent' meditation from abouts 10-12 years of age, all depending on their personal propensities and maturity.


Albatross (Sandrian)

Juri Aidas

(I wrote too long a post so I'm posting this in a few separate installments.)
On TM and the Philosophy of Yoga - II.
[info]sandrian wrote:
Friday, 29 May 2009 at 10:36 pm (UTC)
Hi again, again,

Yea! Transcendental Meditation is a good thing, a simple, easy, effortless practice for to quieten the whole psycho physiological system and yet retain a wakeful awareness, a restful alertness. In the philosophy of Yoga the 'process' of meditation is regarded as one of the four inner 'limbs' (or 'branches' if one'd use the metaphor of a 'tree of yoga' [see: "The Paradigm of Yoga" http://issuu.com/albatross/docs/paradigm-of-yoga), as contrasted with the four outer limbs/branches. The inner being: (dynamic) bliss, meditation (as process), focusing, withdrawal (of the senses); and then the outer: breath, body, morals and ethics (these last two should, in this context, be regarded as but pertaining to the recursive method of yoga, the algorythmy, and are not to be seen as bases of any externalized ideology, the application of these but subtly tunes or attitude towards sensible practice, and the accrued result therof is spontaneously, and naturally, integrated into our lives and into our living). Well, eight aspects all in all. These are delineated in Maharishi Patanjali's (whom I mentioned in my former comment, above) "Yoga Sūtra" ('sūtra'=thread, sūtras are memnonic statements in a structured context), a short text on the wholity of yoga. Maharishi Mahesh Yogi spent a large part of the middle 1970's in analyzing and offering discourse on this text and I was fortunate enough to partake of a couple of months of those lectures first hand. Thus as I see it TM is about Yoga. And Yoga is not but a program of gymnastics with some added inspirational content for peacefulness et al., Yoga is a whole system of philosophy (See: On The Bhagavad-Gita: A New Translation and Commentary, Maharishi Mahesh Yogi, 1967 [link below, its so looong], appendix, six systems of Indian philosophy).

Tai-Chi which was mentioned above also encompasses all these aspects in its own way as do many other methods of 'algorythmy'. Most schools of yoga touch a bit on all these aspects, and as for the TM-movement it too teaches of all these limbs/branches of yoga. The Sidhi program of the TM-movement is but the application of chapter three (of 4, 196 verses all in all, or 195 depending on how one counts) of the Yoga-Sūtra. The Sidhi program ('sidhi'=perfection) is regarded as the heart of Yoga as it fuses the (dynamic bliss), meditation (as process) and focusing into a wholeness as the mind leaves the transcendental 'field'. Patanjali has this to say on the establishing of a settled mind as goes for different schools of yoga, "So does any meditation that is held in high esteem", YS., I:39. Yoga is not about competition 'tween the different practices and merits of different schools as we all have our roots in Patanjalis excellent delineation (which in itself rest upon the intuitive Vedic heritage from abouts 2500 BC - 1700 BC). For an excellent translation of this classic text see the translation, from Sanskrit, by Alistair Shearer, "The Yoga Sūtras of Patanjali" (link below, same reason as above). Mr Shearer is a teacher of Transcendental Meditation and once offered said translation to Maharishi for comment and as I understand it he got a positive response. I recommend it.


On The Bhagavad-Gita, Maharishi Mahesh Yogi: ( http://www.amazon.com/Maharishi-Mahesh-Yogi-Bhagavad-Gita-Translation/dp/B000G6E2FM/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1243631828&sr=8-1 ), Penguin edition 1969. No comments for this edition at Amazon, but this is the one I been readin'.

(... and a different edition ...)
On The Bhagavad-Gita: ( http://www.amazon.com/Maharishi-Mahesh-Yogi-Bhagavad-Gita-Translation/dp/0140192476/ref=sr_1_2?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1243631828&sr=8-2 ), also a Penguin edition but from 1990. This edition at Amazon has all the comments.

Yoga Sūtra, Alistair Shearer: ( http://www.amazon.com/Yoga-Sutras-Patanjali-Sacred-Teachings/dp/0609609599/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1230966091&sr=1-1 ).


Enjoy,


Albatross (Sandrian)

Juri Aidas
On TM and the Philosophy of Yoga - III.
[info]sandrian wrote:
Friday, 29 May 2009 at 10:38 pm (UTC)
Hi again, again, and yet again (this is the final part),

One of my concerns here about TM in education is that I do not wish for TM to become embroiled in any mixup with faith-based teachings (I am affiliated with The Brights, [ http://www.the-brights.net/ ], an organization whose purpose is "illuminating and elevating the naturalistic worldview ", and to "Promote the civic understanding and acknowledgment of the naturalistic worldview, which is free of supernatural and mystical elements.") There's a whole aura of culturally inherited theistic memes surrounding any attempt at defining any subjective ontology, and even in TM a confusion may arise, thus I hold TM to be thesitically neutral (even though its outer attribution at times will smack of specific allusion to said heritage), I but substitute the recurring reference to God as an expression of a 'Sense of Wonder' and I look upon the 'God'-concept as the anthrophomorphic projection of our desire to grasp).

TM thus has much to offer and kudos to Mr. David Lynch for propagating the great vision of Maharish Mahesh Yogi, a true 'rishi'=seer, in this wonderful, ideal way.


My homage to Maharish Mahesh Yogi, the track "Flower Power", a song, from my 'Wild River Collection', a bunch 'a bright songs at: ( http://www.myspace.com/ananotheralbatross ).


Enjoy,


Albatross (Sandrian)

Juri Aidas
Re Claims and Cost of TM
[info]lewiswalch wrote:
Saturday, 30 May 2009 at 07:17 am (UTC)
I enjoyed the article and it is good that the efficacy of Transcendental Meditation is recognised, but I took issue with two points. Firstly, TM advocates do not simply 'claim' that it is more effective than other forms of meditation. If the author had done their homework properly they would have found masses of peer reviewed research which concludes exactly that. And secondly, I did not see the value of sniping at TM over the cost. TM is not just lying down and thinking nice thoughts, valuable though this may be. It requires professional training which teachers pay for themselves, and it takes time to teach it, especially when teaching ADHD children. It also involves extensive follow up for at least 6 months. From my own experience of teaching TM for over 30 years, careful follow up is vital. TM is a simple practice but you would be astonished at how many people try to make it into hard work. The £320 is a special reduced cost fee when large groups of 20 or more are learning in a school which is intending to introduce 'Consciousnesss Based Education'. If the truth be told, it does not make the teachers rich and the ones I know teaching at this price in schools are actually subsidising the projects from their own pockets. In conclusion, I feel the author or their editor were not completely objective, or if their aim was to give honest information they ought to have done their research more thoroughly. It was dishonest to make out that all meditations are equal or that TM is expensive, when experience and research say quite the opposite.
Re: Re Claims and Cost of TM
[info]zee_nova wrote:
Saturday, 6 June 2009 at 11:08 pm (UTC)
I have to agree that the claim that TM is expensive is a little arbitrary here. Sure, it's a couple hundred dollars for a child to learn, but the cost of one visit to the doctor and a prescription could be as much if not more than TM instruction. A bottle of medication will only last a few weeks and have numerous side-effects yet Transcendental Meditation only has benefits and is there for life.