Irish minister urged to quit over release of IRA remand suspects

Click to follow
The Independent Online
Ireland's justice minister Nora Owen was last night resisting Opposition calls for her resignation after a number of alleged Republican paramilitary remand prisoners had to be released and re-arrested after Government officials bungled a judge's retirement date.

Fifteen prisoners, including 13 from Portlaoise Prison where many IRA inmates are held, had to be freed early on Wednesday morning, after legal advice indicated that detention orders made by the non-jury Special Criminal Court were flawed. They included Brixton prison escaper Nessan Quinlivan.

The fiasco arose when it emerged that one of the court's three judges, Mr Justice Dominic Lynch, was sitting while officially no longer a judge of that court.

His July request to step down had been approved by the Government in August, but the judge himself, normally based in the Circuit Court, was not informed of the decision. It was after this that he made the orders which were subsequently ruled ultra vires.

Government embarrassment was worsened by the fact that the judge's "de- listing" was confirmed in print in an official publication.

Those brought back to the Special Criminal Court yesterday to receive remand decisions renewing their custody were five Londonderry men facing arms charges following last week's discovery of a primed IRA mortar near Malin Head in Donegal.

Others involved are IRA suspects detained after the discovery of a County Laois bomb factory in June. Lawyers for the prisoners were last night seeking to challenge their continued detention.

A sixteenth man was yesterday released and re-arrested for the same reasons. Five others on bail may have their cases re-assessed.

In the Dail Mrs Owen was unable to say exactly why her department failed to inform Judge Lynch that his request to step down had been approved. She said a letter from the Attorney General warning her of the problem had not been brought to her attention.

She promised a "full, speedy and impartial inquiry" by outside officials, but denied it was a resignation matter.

The main Opposition Fianna Fail party's justice spokesman John O'Donoghue said: "This would be a joke in a banana republic, and it's a joke in this republic. Someone is going to have to pay for it."

He urged her to "do the honourable thing and resign." Fianna Fail leader Bertie Ahern asked how the minister could have remained in the dark as it appeared the judge's predicament had been known to the Attorney General in September. The minister had said she was not alerted and the letter to Judge Lynch not finalised until Wednesday this week.