I turned off Motty, too

Well, nearly. Even the BBC's head of sport uses the red button - but only for an ITV game - to switch to a radio commentary. Roger Mosey says all sports journalism should aspire to Five Live's standards
Click to follow
The Independent Online

The appointment of Roger Mosey as head of BBC Sport last August did not go down well with the strapping, front-row types in the Sports division. They wondered how a man nicknamed "Mr Blobby", an obviously cerebral former head of BBC Television News known for his fascination with politics, could blend into the macho world of sports journalism. It didn't help that Mosey seemed to want to shake up BBC sports coverage.

"At its bluntest," he said, "broadcast sports journalism lacks the range and ambition that we see elsewhere, and we have to put that right."

So how is it going so far? "I'm absolutely loving the World Cup," he says, "but the pressure is relentless. It is the closest thing to running a general election campaign I have experienced since leaving news. There is more involvement from audiences through blogs and message boards than ever before, and you are constantly negotiating with the host broadcasters and Fifa."

Like elections, the World Cup also involves lively controversy about the deployment of personnel. Last week Mosey discovered that some licence-payers lack his faith in the BBC's veteran commentator, John Motson. Nearly four million digital viewers used the interactive red button on their Sky Digital and Freeview remote controls, many selecting commentary from other sources, including Radio Five Live.

During England's tense victory over Trinidad and Tobago, which was not shown live by the BBC, Mosey did the same thing: "I was in the BBC Sport office with a dozen people from around the department and a few beers, watching ITV and listening to Five Live."

But Mosey remains a big "Motty" fan. "I've only been doing this job for 10 months and the first big brouhaha about commentators arose when Alan Green was in the firing line. The Daily Telegraph was full of letters saying, 'Why isn't there an alternative to Alan Green?' In the wonderful way the cycle rolls about, it's now: 'Isn't Alan Green a wonderful alternative to John Motson?'

"Let's get the numbers in perspective. The red button does not just give you choice of audio. It gives highlights, text and other information as well. So actually estimating how many people switched away from the television commentary is hard. It is not massive numbers. We do research on commentators across sport, and in that research John Motson comes out so clearly and so far ahead of any other commentator that it would be nuts to think about the arrangements we have made in Germany."

But he does regard Five Live, the radio news and sport station of which he was appointed controller in 1997, as a standard-setter in sports journalism. "Five Live has proved that you really can do live-event coverage and very good sports journalism too. Some of the attitude of Five Live in its journalism is what I want to see go across television and online journalism as well."

In fact, that will be crucial if BBC Sport is to survive Sky's dominance of live coverage and the growth of new rivals such as Irish satellite broadcaster Setanta.

Key to realising this ambition is the recruitment of a sports editor. The new post, which Mosey calls "a Nick Robinson [the BBC political editor] or Evan Davies [economics editor] equivalent for sport", was advertised earlier this month. It will not go to a former sportsman. Mosey dislikes the "fans with typewriters" attitude he detects in some famous names who have moved behind the microphone.

He refuses to confirm that the widely admired Today programme sports presenter, Gary Richardson, is a candidate, but admits: "Gary has a fantastic contacts book and he is not afraid to ask questions." The sports editor, who will work jointly for news and sport, will be required to provide hard news stories to flagship programmes such as the Ten O'Clock News and Today.

Equally important is the commitment to launch a weekly sports journalism programme on BBC 1. "We lack investigative depth in sports journalism. Newspapers do that better than broadcasters. At the moment we either do two and a half minutes within a news bulletin or a pure sports story. The ability to spend 10 minutes on a film or an interview is going to be crucial. The new programme is at a very early stage but we will begin piloting this autumn. There will be a sports journalism programme on BBC television. It will launch in 2007."

Both editor and programme are intended to raise standards. "I would have hoped our sports editor would have been more across England's search for a manager. Maybe the new programme would have got access to film the story of how it really happened."

Mosey recalls receiving an email from a viewer asking "How do you know?" after a sports bulletin reported that Alan Curbishley and Luiz Felipe Scolari were names in the frame for the manager's job. "I had the uncomfortable feeling that we probably did not and that it was one of those 'facts' in sports journalism that's good enough to be a talking point but not something you'd stake your house on."

This month Mosey staked more than the value of a house on securing the future of Gary Lineker's Match of the Day until the end of the decade. In a straight bidding war with Channel 5, he agreed to pay £171.6m for the rights to screen Premier League highlights for three seasons from 2007-08 - an increase of £66m on the existing deal. Few analysts expected the price to be so high, and rivals have condemned the windfall given to Premier League chairmen, players and agents.

Mosey is unapologetic. "Match of the Day underpins a huge amount of BBC output at the weekend. It's not just Match of the Day on Saturday night. It's MOTD2 on Sunday evening, the re-run of MOTD on Sunday morning, Score and Final Score on Saturday afternoon, and Football Focus as well."

Mosey's own interest in sport began with watching the defunct Bradford Park Avenue, and later Bradford City. "I was also brought up on rugby league," he says. "Bradford Northern was the main place we went to. My dad and uncle were the sort of casual fans brought in by success. So, we did sneak off to Leeds United a bit in the late 1960s. I have A-level knowledge of Leeds teams of the late Sixties/early Seventies. These days my godson and some friends are Arsenal fans. I wouldn't call myself one, but I do tend to see Arsenal more than anyone else."

The whole story is that the BBC's willingness to spend so lavishly on football images is part of a broader strategy - the charter renewal commitment to promote digital switchover and other new technology. "For this World Cup we have been pushing very hard into high definition. We have broadband coverage of games for the first time. Sport drives digital take-up. The single strongest driver into high definition television will be major sports events."

If that suits the Government's ambitions for the television market, it suits the BBC too. With so much live sport lost to Sky and Setanta, coverage of events such as the World Cup, Wimbledon and the Olympic Games do more than anything else to promote licence-payer approval.

Colleagues believe this is why one of the corporation's most accomplished executives, young enough still to be spoken of as a future director-general, has been charged with reforming BBC Sport. Without it the corporation's claim to serve all its viewers and listeners would become very hard to sustain.


BORN Bradford, 1958

EDUCATION Bradford Grammar School; Wadham College, Oxford


* His first job was as a community affairs producer at Pennine Radio, Bradford.

* Joined the BBC in 1980 as a reporter with Radio Lincolnshire.

* Moved to produce Radio 4's The Week in Westminster, followed by the Today programme. Appointed editor of PM in 1987 and editor of Today in 1993.

* Appointed controller, Five Live, in 1997, and later head of BBC Television News. Became director of sport in August 2005.


Football, film; reads thrillers and political biographies.


Stacked odds?

A case of misplaced loyalty by Jeremy Deedes? When the former Telegraph chief executive launched The Sportsman in March, he asked his old newspaper group to run the distribution. But with The Sportsman struggling on a circulation of 22,000 (about half its target after a three-month run) the finger of blame has been pointed at those very same distributors. In a last-ditch bid to perk up sales, Deedes' team dumped the Telegraph in favour of the Daily Mail distributors. The first visible signs of this switch are stacks of Sportsman papers appearing on London buses. Some copies had even been read.

Costly threesomes

It's all over for the 3am girls, or at least as a threesome. Last week, Venezuelan beauty Kiki King announced she was leaving the column after almost exactly a year. But rather than hiring another gossip girl to fill her photo-slot at the top of the page, the Daily Mirror has decided to axe her position entirely. "There isn't going to be another 3am girl," says a friend of the column. "It's just felt with all the redundancies, this would be a good place to save a bit of money." King, who had joined the Mirror from the Daily Mail, now intends to follow up opportunities in television, leaving just Eva Simpson and Caroline Hedley heading the column. The "2am girls" just doesn't have the same edginess, though.

Has-been counters

The latest indignity thrust upon the old-timers in the Telegraph Group is a gang of consultants who have been seen roaming the Sunday Telegraph offices in Canary Wharf with clipboards in preparation for the autumn move to their new Victoria base. Hacks are being examined by time-and-motion experts. The consultants have been hovering over them, drawing flow-charts of copy-processing stages, complete with boxes to fill in with questions such as: "What percentage of commissioned stories need to be rewritten completely?" Shurely shome mishtake?

Blackhurst stays put

Psst... Chris Blackhurst is not to be business editor at The Observer. Contrary to excited reports in Press Gazette, the Evening Standard's City editor will not be moving into the chair of Frank Kane, who decided to cash in his share options last month. Observer editor Roger Alton and Blackhurst are known to have conferred, but they did not get as far as striking a deal.

Licensed to drink

The BBC's reported £20m expenditure on chairs might have been better invested in bar stools. When air-conditioning failed at Television Centre in White City last week, hot and bothered staff repaired to a nearby bar and cracked open a couple of magnums of champagne to cool themselves down. The expenses claims have yet to be submitted.

Murdoch manoeuvres?

This week's Spectator has acres of its glossy paper given over to Irwin Stelzer holding forth on the subject of how David Cameron shapes up to Gordon Brown. Stelzer is not the only man hedging his bets. It is noted that Matthew d'Ancona is showing a certain bravery in airing the views of Stelzer, Rupert Murdoch's ludicrously nicknamed "ambassador on earth", right under the nose of his chief executive, Andrew Neil, who is barely on nodding terms with the Sun King. Is this the first sign of rebellion? "It's a little more mercenary than that," observes one Spectator-watcher. "Matthew is wise to keep a foot in both camps. Should he find himself leaving The Spectator in the near future, it's handy to have someone to put in a good word for him with Rupert." How cynical to interpret it like that.