Ex-MP's libel case thrown out
Thursday 09 December 2010
A libel case brought by a former Tory MP in the wake of the expenses "scandal" has been thrown out by the High Court.
Jacqui Lait represented Beckenham before she announced, in September 2009, that she would not stand in the 2010 election to make way for a younger candidate.
In November 2009, Mrs Lait put her name to a letter published in The Times expressing concerns by female MPs about the possible consequences of recommendations contained in the Kelly Report into reforming expenses, which led to an article in the Evening Standard which she said was defamatory.
She complained it meant that her public opposition to a reform banning additional expenses for MPs living within reasonable commuting distance of Westminster could be regarded as hypocritical and not motivated by concern for the safety of women MPs, or was apt, rightly, to provoke public anger.
Today, Mr Justice Eady ruled in favour of the claim by Evening Standard Ltd that its fair comment defence was "bound to succeed" and gave summary judgment in its favour.
The paper had argued that people may well be angered, not so much because of hypocrisy, but because MPs who had claimed expenses under the old system should "slink away in shame and keep their mouths shut" in relation to proposals for reform.
The judge noted that not just the public, but also party leaders, took the approach that MPs should shut up and take their medicine.
"Even though some suggested at the time that this may have been governed by electoral or public relations considerations, rather than by principle or natural justice, it illustrates how difficult it now is in this context to argue that no reasonable citizen could feel legitimate anger at the behaviour of their elected representatives.
"This is not, of course, specific to Mrs Lait. It would apply to each and every one of her co-signatories - as well as most other MPs.
"In the case of each MP, there will have been his or her own expenses claims, and they will no doubt differ considerably; yet the criticism is not based wholly on individual figures but largely upon the suggestion that, merely by taking advantage of the 'overly-generous' system, they have forfeited the right to be heeded any longer on that topic.
"For these reasons, a jury of 12 citizens, which would no doubt include voters and taxpayers, could - at the least - come to the conclusion that, notwithstanding the failure to establish hypocrisy, the rather ill-formulated observation about justifiable 'ire' constitutes fair comment."
Geoffrey Macnab reviews American Hustle, also starring Christian Bale and Bradley Cooper
newsFormer soldier taped 33 of the animals to the floor and then stamped on them one by one
Michelle Nijhuis' daughter insists (s)he is, and she learnt a valuable lesson on gender in books
news Opponents claim it would stop performers such as Beyonce and Madonna appearing on TV
It takes a platoon of chefs, litres of brandy and rum, and almost 100kg of dried fruit
food + drink
Sun will 'flip upside down' within weeks, says Nasa
Lee Rigby murder: How killers Michael Adebolajo and Michael Adebowale became ultra-violent radicals
Cycle death inquest: Boyfriend hugs driver of 32 tonne tipper truck that killed his girlfriend
Paul Walker death caused by speed alone
Apollo Theatre collapse: Scores injured after ceiling collapses in London's West End
- 1 America's 'virgin births'? One in 200 mothers 'became pregnant without having sex'
- 2 North Koreans are gasping for the truth: Let's give it to them
- 3 Sun will 'flip upside down' within weeks, says Nasa
- 4 Christmas comes early: Justin Bieber is 'retiring from music'
- 5 Iain Duncan Smith leaves Commons food banks debate early
- < Previous
- Next >
£6.31 per day: Inspiring Interns: One of the biggest names in sport is offerin...
£20000 - £25000 per annum: Inspiring Interns: This company is a division of th...
Up to £22K (OTE year 1 - £40,000): Seltek Consultants Ltd: Seltek is a leading...
£285 per day: PCR Recruitment Limited: This is a unique opportunity for an Ent...