Humanists rejoice! BBC will consult them on religion
For the first time, the broadcaster will take advice on programmes like 'Thought for the Day' from a secularist
David Sandison
Salisbury Cathedral Choir during 'Songs of Praise'. The humanists hope for greater influence in religious and ethical programming
Religious broadcasting has taken an unexpected turn at the BBC, leaving secularists last night claiming a breakthrough. An important new committee that the corporation will consult on religious broadcasting is to include a humanist.
The move, which some see as a potential threat to the future of slots such as Thought for the Day, will see groups representing secular beliefs offering advice and suggestions to the broadcaster. The move is a significant shift for the corporation, and follows a series of recent victories for secularists in public life, including a legal ruling in favour of the so-called atheist bus, the addition of humanism to a GCSE religious studies syllabus, and the launch of the first major national student secular society.
Andrew Copson, director of education and public affairs for the British Humanist Association, has been appointed to the BBC's Standing Conference on Religion and Belief, a new body which replaces the Central Religious Advisory Committee (Crac), which advised on "religion-related policy and coverage".
Mr Copson suggested his appointment may give him the chance to challenge the long fought over Radio 4 religious slot, Thought for the Day. "We need to see an increased contribution from humanists in slots run by the religion and ethics department that are presently confined only to religions," he said.
The new body, which will meet with senior BBC officials several times a year, gathers for the first time on Wednesday. Unlike Crac, which was closed by the BBC Trust at the end of 2007, the Standing Conference on Religion and Belief will be independent from the broadcaster, but it will continue to have the same chairman, Bishop Graham James, at its head.
The BBC played down the significance of the inclusion, concerned that it would alarm religious groups. Despite this, the chief executive of the British Humanist Association, Hanne Stinson, heralded Mr Copson's appointment as a "great step". "Until now humanists have been excluded from any consultative or advisory role in relation to the BBC on a level with religious groups and representatives," Ms Stinson said. "In an open society, those of religious and non-religious beliefs should have a fair input on matters that concern them and the inclusion of humanist representation is a great step towards this."
The philosopher A C Grayling said the news was "incredible", and signified the culmination of a series of successes for secularists. "I would say in recent months we've seen a real change. There have been cracks in the ice over the last few years, but bits of Antarctica are finally floating free now. When you think of the great institution of the BBC finally conceding that a whole viewpoint needs to be heard, that's pretty incredible.
"At long last, here is one token of acceptance that the traditional way of thinking about matters of the spirit and matters of the mind needs to be rethought."
According to Ofcom, the broadcasting regulator, 6 per cent of viewers watch religious programmes on the main TV channels – the lowest proportion of any programme genre. A recent poll found that more than a third of Britons did not feel they belonged to a religion at all.
View all comments that have been posted about this article.
Offensive or abusive comments will be removed and your IP logged and may be used to prevent further submission. In submitting a comment to the site, you agree to be bound by the Independent Minds Terms of Service.
- Print Article
- Email Article
-
Click here for copyright permissions
Copyright 2009 Independent News and Media Limited


Comments
The BBC has been run by secularists (if that is the word?) for years and has had an anti-religion policy for decades. What is news about this? Maybe they are just being honest for a change?
'Thought for the day' has long been a meaningless waste of time, any attempt at religion there being thought being downplayed in case it upset the chattering classes. At no time is Christianity or any other religion shown in a good light as the 'humanists' (or is that the 'closed minds?) don't allow it.
The BBC is run by a London cabal, a small group that think they know what is best for us all. Their 'open minded inclusiveness' stops when something they disagree with appears. How democratic!
A test case might be 'Thought for the Day' (TFTD). Will the BBC recognize that it is no longer appropriate to have a religious propaganda program embedded in what is supposed to be an objective news programme? Or will the BBC at least allow a regular non-religious slot on TFTD in which humanists, atheists, secularists, etc., can speak freely?
This broadcaster doesn't deserve a single click on my desktop.
Most Christians reject certain teachings in the bible. For example, Matthew 15:4 teaches that children who do not honour their parents should be put to death, but even if this was not illegal today, I do not think that many Christians would implement it. In rejecting this teaching, they draw on a morality not derived from the bible. That so many BBC broadcasts on ethical issues assume that superstition has some relevance reflects the refusal of many Christians to acknowledge that morals do NOT need to be based on the Bible. There is a similar problem with other religions. How a multi-faith body ever comes to a consensus on some issues of morality I do not know. I would have thought that the addition of a rational thinker to such a body would almost guarantee an impasse, and result in the suppression of his/her views by the (religious) chairman.
As an atheist, I am not rejoicing yet.
None of them are perfect either.
So, by your logic, ONLY people who are agnostics with regards to the "idea" of God, Thor, Valhalla, Odin, the Flying Spaghetti Monster, Horus, Set, Vishnu, Ao, Rangi, Papatuanuku and Allah should be given places on the committe. In other words, only people who are total fence-sitters with regards to all gods, religions and belief systems.
Or, maybe you are just full of it and a little confused.
Very poor
It is about time that the BBC recognised that most people in the UK aren't religious, and
even those that do attend church do it only "a few times a year".
Roxy