LAW REPORT: Solicitor breached undertaking over lien

LAW REPORT: 31 October 1996; Bentley and another v Gaisford and another

Bentley and another v Gaisford and another; Court of Appeal (Sir Richard Scott, Vice Chancellor, Lord Justice Roch, Lord Justice Henry) 21 October 1996

Where a solicitor gave an undertaking to his client's former solicitor, to hold documents supplied by the former solicitor "to your order" so as to preserve the former solicitor's retaining lien over the documents against the client's payment of his fees, the current solicitor acted in breach of the former solicitor's lien when he made copies of all the documents and sent them to the client.

The Court of Appeal by a majority (Sir Richard Scott V-C dissenting) allowed an appeal by the plaintiffs, Keith Anthony Charles Bentley and Hewett & Co, against the dismissal by Judge William Crawford QC, sitting as a High Court judge, of their action against the defendants, Robert Edmund Gaisford and Sinclair Roche & Temperley.

John Cherryman QC and David Bailey (Hewett & Co) for the plaintiffs; Peter Gross QC and David Allen (Sinclair Roche & Temperley) for the defendants.

Lord Justice Roch said the plaintiffs had been retained by China Everbright Co (CET) to act for them in an arbitration. CET terminated that retainer and instructed them to send all their documents to the defendants, who had been instructed in their place. The plaintiffs faxed the defendants:

Upon receiving your undertaking to hold the documents/our file to our order in respect of outstanding fees and disbursements, we shall put out papers for collection.

The defendants by fax agreed to hold the documents "to your order". Having read the files, however, Mr Gaisford copied them all and faxed them to CET. He said did this because he was concerned at the way the plaintiffs had dealt with the arbitration and thought it his duty to refer the documentation to his clients and seek their instructions. His understanding of the undertaking was that his firm was only obliged to return the original documents to the plaintffs on their demand.

The judge held that that the obligation was threefold: (a) to preserve the original documents; (b) not to part with possession of them; and (c) to return them promptly on demand. They did not undertake not to copy them, nor that they would not retain any copies made. If the plaintiffs wanted to prevent this, they should have insisted on a different form of undertaking.

That conclusion was based in part on an erroneous assumption that the second solicitor's power to deal with documents handed to him by the first solicitor depended on the extent of the undertaking he had given the first solicitor.

The case law established that where solicitor one transferred documents to solicitor two to hold to solicitor one's order, the lien of solicitor one was preserved, even if solicitor two refused to give an undertaking: see Caldwell v Sumpter [1972] Ch 478. It was sufficient that there should be an intention not to abandon the lien.

What was the form and extent of the lien once the documents had been handed over to solicitor two? The judge held that solicitor two could use the documents in such a way as to render solicitor one's lien totally meaningless. Here the defendants had acted so as to remove completely the client's need to seek to obtain the originals from the plaintiffs.

In Heslop v Metcalfe [1937] 3 My & C 183 at 190, Lord Cottenham LC said:

I think the principle should be, that the solicitor claiming the lien, should have every security not inconsistent with the progress of the cause.

That principle could be applied to cases such as the present. His Lordship did not accept that such a rule would create practical difficulties for solicitor two and the client because neither could be sure what use they were permitted to make of the documents.

His Lordship would hold that in copying every document in every file and sending copies of all those documents to the client, the defendants were in breach of the plaintiffs' lien. A declaration to that effect would be made, but, on the basis that Mr Gaisford thought he was acting properly in his client's interests, this was not a case where it would be appropriate to order compensation.

Paul Magrath, Barrister

Voices
The Sumatran tiger, endemic to the Indonesian island of Sumatra, is an endangered species
voicesJonathon Porritt: The wild tiger population is thought to have dropped by 97 per cent since 1900
Arts and Entertainment
Beast would strip to his underpants and take to the stage with a slogan scrawled on his bare chest whilst fans shouted “you fat bastard” at him
musicIndie music promoter was was a feature at Carter gigs
News
news
Arts and Entertainment
Story line: Susanoo slays the Yamata no Orochi serpent in the Japanese version of a myth dating back 40,000 years
arts + entsApplying the theory of evolution to the world's many mythologies
PROMOTED VIDEO
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?
News
ebookA unique anthology of reporting and analysis of a crucial period of history
News
Performers dressed as Tunnocks chocolate teacakes, a renowned Scottish confectionary, perform during the opening ceremony of the 2014 Commonwealth Games at Celtic Park in Glasgow on July 23, 2014.
news
Life and Style
Popular plonk: Lambrusco is selling strong
Food + drinkNaff Seventies corner-shop staple is this year's Aperol Spritz
News
Gardai wait for the naked man, who had gone for a skinny dip in Belfast Lough
newsTwo skinny dippers threatened with inclusion on sex offenders’ register as naturists criminalised
News
Shake down: Michelle and Barack Obama bump knuckles before an election night rally in Minnesota in 2008, the 'Washington Post' called it 'the fist bump heard round the world'
newsThe pound, a.k.a. the dap, greatly improves hygiene
Arts and Entertainment
La Roux
music
Arts and Entertainment
Graham Fellows as John Shuttleworth
comedySean O'Grady joins Graham Fellows down his local Spar
News
people
News
Ross Burden pictured in 2002
people
News
Elisabeth Murdoch: The 44-year-old said she felt a responsibility to 'stand up and be counted’'
media... says Rupert Murdoch
Arts and Entertainment
tv
Extras
indybest
Sport
Arsenal signing Calum Chambers
sportGunners complete £16m transfer of Southampton youngster
Independent
Travel Shop
the manor
Up to 70% off luxury travel
on city breaks Find out more
santorini
Up to 70% off luxury travel
on chic beach resorts Find out more
sardina foodie
Up to 70% off luxury travel
on country retreats Find out more
Latest stories from i100
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?
Independent Dating
and  

By clicking 'Search' you
are agreeing to our
Terms of Use.

iJobs Job Widget
iJobs General

Junior / Graduate Application Support Engineer

£26000 per annum: Ashdown Group: A highly successful international media organ...

QA Manager - North Manchester - Nuclear & MOD - £40k+

£35000 - £41000 per annum + competitive: Progressive Recruitment: QA Manager -...

Property Finance Partner

Very Competitive Salary: Austen Lloyd: LONDON - BANKING / PROPERTY FINANCE - ...

Agile Tester

£28000 - £30000 per annum + competitive: Progressive Recruitment: An ambitious...

Day In a Page

The children were playing in the street with toy guns. The air strikes were tragically real

The air strikes were tragically real

The children were playing in the street with toy guns
Boozy, ignorant, intolerant, but very polite – The British, as others see us

Britain as others see us

Boozy, ignorant, intolerant, but very polite
Countries that don’t survey their tigers risk losing them altogether

Countries that don’t survey their tigers risk losing them

Jonathon Porritt sounds the alarm
How did our legends really begin?

How did our legends really begin?

Applying the theory of evolution to the world's many mythologies
Watch out: Lambrusco is back on the menu

Lambrusco is back on the menu

Naff Seventies corner-shop staple is this year's Aperol Spritz
A new Russian revolution: Cracks start to appear in Putin’s Kremlin power bloc

A new Russian revolution

Cracks start to appear in Putin’s Kremlin power bloc
Eugene de Kock: Apartheid’s sadistic killer that his country cannot forgive

Apartheid’s sadistic killer that his country cannot forgive

The debate rages in South Africa over whether Eugene de Kock should ever be released from jail
Standing my ground: If sitting is bad for your health, what happens when you stay on your feet for a whole month?

Standing my ground

If sitting is bad for your health, what happens when you stay on your feet for a whole month?
Commonwealth Games 2014: Dai Greene prays for chance to rebuild after injury agony

Greene prays for chance to rebuild after injury agony

Welsh hurdler was World, European and Commonwealth champion, but then the injuries crept in
Israel-Gaza conflict: Secret report helps Israelis to hide facts

Patrick Cockburn: Secret report helps Israel to hide facts

The slickness of Israel's spokesmen is rooted in directions set down by pollster Frank Luntz
The man who dared to go on holiday

The man who dared to go on holiday

New York's mayor has taken a vacation - in a nation that has still to enforce paid leave, it caused quite a stir, reports Rupert Cornwell
Best comedians: How the professionals go about their funny business, from Sarah Millican to Marcus Brigstocke

Best comedians: How the professionals go about their funny business

For all those wanting to know how stand-ups keep standing, here are some of the best moments
The Guest List 2014: Forget the Man Booker longlist, Literary Editor Katy Guest offers her alternative picks

The Guest List 2014

Forget the Man Booker longlist, Literary Editor Katy Guest offers her alternative picks
Jokes on Hollywood: 'With comedy film audiences shrinking, it’s time to move on'

Jokes on Hollywood

With comedy film audiences shrinking, it’s time to move on