LAW REPORT: Solicitor breached undertaking over lien

LAW REPORT: 31 October 1996; Bentley and another v Gaisford and another

Bentley and another v Gaisford and another; Court of Appeal (Sir Richard Scott, Vice Chancellor, Lord Justice Roch, Lord Justice Henry) 21 October 1996

Where a solicitor gave an undertaking to his client's former solicitor, to hold documents supplied by the former solicitor "to your order" so as to preserve the former solicitor's retaining lien over the documents against the client's payment of his fees, the current solicitor acted in breach of the former solicitor's lien when he made copies of all the documents and sent them to the client.

The Court of Appeal by a majority (Sir Richard Scott V-C dissenting) allowed an appeal by the plaintiffs, Keith Anthony Charles Bentley and Hewett & Co, against the dismissal by Judge William Crawford QC, sitting as a High Court judge, of their action against the defendants, Robert Edmund Gaisford and Sinclair Roche & Temperley.

John Cherryman QC and David Bailey (Hewett & Co) for the plaintiffs; Peter Gross QC and David Allen (Sinclair Roche & Temperley) for the defendants.

Lord Justice Roch said the plaintiffs had been retained by China Everbright Co (CET) to act for them in an arbitration. CET terminated that retainer and instructed them to send all their documents to the defendants, who had been instructed in their place. The plaintiffs faxed the defendants:

Upon receiving your undertaking to hold the documents/our file to our order in respect of outstanding fees and disbursements, we shall put out papers for collection.

The defendants by fax agreed to hold the documents "to your order". Having read the files, however, Mr Gaisford copied them all and faxed them to CET. He said did this because he was concerned at the way the plaintiffs had dealt with the arbitration and thought it his duty to refer the documentation to his clients and seek their instructions. His understanding of the undertaking was that his firm was only obliged to return the original documents to the plaintffs on their demand.

The judge held that that the obligation was threefold: (a) to preserve the original documents; (b) not to part with possession of them; and (c) to return them promptly on demand. They did not undertake not to copy them, nor that they would not retain any copies made. If the plaintiffs wanted to prevent this, they should have insisted on a different form of undertaking.

That conclusion was based in part on an erroneous assumption that the second solicitor's power to deal with documents handed to him by the first solicitor depended on the extent of the undertaking he had given the first solicitor.

The case law established that where solicitor one transferred documents to solicitor two to hold to solicitor one's order, the lien of solicitor one was preserved, even if solicitor two refused to give an undertaking: see Caldwell v Sumpter [1972] Ch 478. It was sufficient that there should be an intention not to abandon the lien.

What was the form and extent of the lien once the documents had been handed over to solicitor two? The judge held that solicitor two could use the documents in such a way as to render solicitor one's lien totally meaningless. Here the defendants had acted so as to remove completely the client's need to seek to obtain the originals from the plaintiffs.

In Heslop v Metcalfe [1937] 3 My & C 183 at 190, Lord Cottenham LC said:

I think the principle should be, that the solicitor claiming the lien, should have every security not inconsistent with the progress of the cause.

That principle could be applied to cases such as the present. His Lordship did not accept that such a rule would create practical difficulties for solicitor two and the client because neither could be sure what use they were permitted to make of the documents.

His Lordship would hold that in copying every document in every file and sending copies of all those documents to the client, the defendants were in breach of the plaintiffs' lien. A declaration to that effect would be made, but, on the basis that Mr Gaisford thought he was acting properly in his client's interests, this was not a case where it would be appropriate to order compensation.

Paul Magrath, Barrister

Arts and Entertainment
Armstrong, left, and Bain's writing credits include Peep Show, Fresh Meat, and The Old Guys
TVThe pair have presented their view of 21st-century foibles in shows such as Peep Show and Fresh Meat
Arts and Entertainment
Keys to success: Andrew and Julian Lloyd Webber
arts + entsMrs Bach had too many kids to write the great man's music, says Julian Lloyd Webber
footballMan City manager would have loved to have signed Argentine
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?
ebooksAn unforgettable anthology of contemporary reportage
Arts and Entertainment
Hand out press photograph/film still from the movie Mad Max Fury Road (Downloaded from the Warner Bro's media site/Jasin Boland/© 2014 Warner Bros. Entertainment Inc.)
films'You have to try everything and it’s all a process of elimination, but ultimately you find your path'
Arts and Entertainment
Imelda Staunton as Dolores Umbridge in the Harry Potter films

New essay by JK Rowling went live on Pottermore site on Friday


Top Gear presenter is no stranger to foot-in-mouth controversy

Russia Today’s new UK channel began broadcasting yesterday. Discussions so far have included why Britons see Russia as ‘the bad guy’

New UK station Russia Today gives a very bizarre view of Britain

Arts and Entertainment
Keira Knightley and Benedict Cumberbatch at the premiere of The Imitation Game at the BFI London Film Festival
filmsKeira Knightley tried to miss The Imitation Game premiere to watch Bake Off
Enner Valencia
footballStriker has enjoyed a rapid rise to fame via winning the title with ‘The Blue Ballet’ in Ecuador
Arts and Entertainment
A top literary agent has compared online giant Amazon to Isis
arts + entsAndrew Wylie has pulled no punches in criticism of Amazon
Arts and Entertainment
Charlie Sheen said he would

Latest stories from i100
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?
Independent Dating

By clicking 'Search' you
are agreeing to our
Terms of Use.

iJobs Job Widget
iJobs General

Mobile Developer (.NET / C# / Jason / Jquery / SOA)

£40000 - £65000 per annum + bonus + benefits + OT: Ampersand Consulting LLP: M...

Humanities Teacher - Greater Manchester

£22800 - £33600 per annum: Randstad Education Manchester Secondary: The JobAt ...

Design Technology Teacher

£22800 - £33600 per annum: Randstad Education Manchester Secondary: Calling al...

Foundation Teacher

£100 - £125 per day: Randstad Education Chelmsford: EYFS Teachers - East Essex...

Day In a Page

Bryan Adams' heartstopping images of wounded British soldiers to go on show at Somerset House

Bryan Adams' images of wounded soldiers

Taken over the course of four years, Adams' portraits are an astonishing document of the aftermath of war
The drugs revolution starts now as MPs agree its high time for change

The drugs revolution starts now as MPs agree its high time for change

Commons debate highlights growing cross-party consensus on softening UK drugs legislation, unchanged for 43 years
The camera is turned on tabloid editors in Richard Peppiatt's 'One Rogue Reporter'

Gotcha! The camera is turned on tabloid editors

Hugh Grant says Richard Peppiatt's 'One Rogue Reporter' documentary will highlight issues raised by Leveson
Fall of the Berlin Wall: It was thanks to Mikhail Gorbachev that this symbol of division fell

Fall of the Berlin Wall

It was thanks to Gorbachev that this symbol of division fell
Halloween 2014: What makes Ouija boards, demon dolls, and evil clowns so frightening?

What makes ouija boards and demon dolls scary?

Ouija boards, demon dolls, evil children and clowns are all classic tropes of horror, and this year’s Halloween releases feature them all. What makes them so frightening, decade after decade?
A safari in modern Britain: Rose Rouse reveals how her four-year tour of Harlesden taught her as much about the UK as it did about NW10

Rose Rouse's safari in modern Britain

Rouse decided to walk and talk with as many different people as possible in her neighbourhood of Harlesden and her experiences have been published in a new book
Welcome to my world of no smell and odd tastes: How a bike accident left one woman living with unwanted food mash-ups

'My world of no smell and odd tastes'

A head injury from a bicycle accident had the surprising effect of robbing Nell Frizzell of two of her senses

Matt Parker is proud of his square roots

The "stand-up mathematician" is using comedy nights to preach maths to big audiences
Paul Scholes column: Beating Manchester City is vital part of life at Manchester United. This is first major test for Luke Shaw, Angel Di Maria and Radamel Falcao – it’s not a game to lose

Paul Scholes column

Beating City is vital part of life at United. This is first major test for Shaw, Di Maria and Falcao – it’s not a game to lose
Frank Warren: Call me an old git, but I just can't see that there's a place for women’s boxing

Frank Warren column

Call me an old git, but I just can't see that there's a place for women’s boxing
Adrian Heath interview: Former Everton striker prepares his Orlando City side for the MLS - and having Kaka in the dressing room

Adrian Heath's American dream...

Former Everton striker prepares his Orlando City side for the MLS - and having Kaka in the dressing room
Simon Hart: Manchester City will rise again but they need to change their attitude

Manchester City will rise again but they need to change their attitude

Manuel Pellegrini’s side are too good to fail and derby allows them to start again, says Simon Hart
Isis in Syria: A general reveals the lack of communication with the US - and his country's awkward relationship with their allies-by-default

A Syrian general speaks

A senior officer of Bashar al-Assad’s regime talks to Robert Fisk about his army’s brutal struggle with Isis, in a dirty war whose challenges include widespread atrocities