Thursday Law Report: Patient could not be compensated for loss of a chance

3 February 2005 Gregg v Scott ([2005] UKHL 2) House of Lords (Lord Nicholls of Birkenhead, Lord Hoffmann, Lord Hope of Craighead, Lord Phillips of Worth Matravers and Baroness Hale of Richmond) 27 January 2005

A WHOLESALE adoption of possible rather than probable causation as the criterion of liability in clinical negligence cases would be so radical a change in the law as to amount to a legislative act.

The House of Lords (Lord Nicholls and Lord Hope dissenting) dismissed the appeal of Malcolm Gregg against the decision of the Court of Appeal that his claim against Dr Scott had been rightly dismissed.

Dr Scott negligently diagnosed as innocuous a lump under Mr Gregg's left arm, when in fact it was cancerous (non-Hodgkin's lymphoma). That led to nine months' delay in Mr Gregg's receiving treatment. During that period his condition deteriorated by the disease spreading elsewhere. The deterioration in his condition reduced his prospects of disease-free survival for 10 years from 42 per cent, when he had first consulted Dr Scott, to 25 per cent at the date of the trial.

The judge found that, if treated promptly, Mr Gregg's initial treatment would probably have achieved remission without an immediate need for high dose chemotherapy. Prompt treatment would, at least initially, have prevented the cancer spreading to the left pectoral region.

However, the judge also found that, although Mr Gregg's condition had deteriorated and in consequence his prospects had been reduced in that way, a better outcome had never been a probability.

Before the negligence Mr Gregg had had a less than evens chance (45 per cent) of avoiding the deterioration in his condition which had ultimately occurred. The delay had not extinguished that chance, but had reduced it by roughly half. The judge assessed that reduction at 20 per cent. That was the extent to which the negligence reduced Mr Gregg's prospects of avoiding the deterioration in his condition which ultimately occurred. On those findings the judge dismissed the claim.

On appeal to the Court of Appeal, the claimant argued, inter alia, that quite apart from any other injury, the reduction in his chances of survival, or loss of a chance, was itself a compensatable head of damage. The Court of Appeal rejected that argument, and the claimant appealed.

Simeon Maskrey QC and Julian Matthews (Sharpe Pritchard) for the claimant; Philip Havers QC, William Edis and David Mankell (Medical Defence Union) for the defendant.

Lord Hoffmann said that there were certainly cases in which loss of a chance was a recoverable head of damage, of which Chaplin v Hicks [1911] 2 KB 786 was a well-known example. The question was whether the principle of that case could apply to a case of clinical negligence such as the present.

The answer can be derived from three cases in the House of Lords: Hotson v East Berkshire Area Health Authority [1987] 2 All ER 909, Wilsher v Essex Area Health Authority [1988] 1 All ER 871 and Fairchild v Glenhaven Funeral Services Ltd [2002] 3 All ER 305.

It should be noted that the rule which Mr Gregg advocated would involve abandoning a good deal of authority. It was the very rule which had been rejected in Wilsher. Yet Wilsher had been expressly approved in Fairchild. Hotson too would have to be overruled. Furthermore, it would mean dismantling all the qualifications and restrictions with which the House of Lords had so recently hedged the exception in Fairchild.

A wholesale adoption of possible rather than probable causation as the criterion of liability would be so radical a change in the law as to amount to a legislative act. Any such changes should be left to Parliament.

Start your day with The Independent, sign up for daily news emails
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?
ebooks
ebooksA special investigation by Andy McSmith
Life and Style
love + sex
Arts and Entertainment
Victoria Wood, Kayvan Novak, Alexa Chung, Chris Moyles
tvReview: No soggy bottoms, but plenty of other baking disasters on The Great Comic Relief Bake Off
Sport
Ashley Young celebrates the winner for Manchester United against Newcastle
footballNewcastle 0 Man United 1: Last minute strike seals precious victory
Life and Style
Tikka Masala has been overtaken by Jalfrezi as the nation's most popular curry
food + drink
Arts and Entertainment
Seth Rogan is one of America’s most famous pot smokers
filmAmy Pascal resigned after her personal emails were leaked following a cyber-attack sparked by the actor's film The Interview
News
Benjamin Netanyahu and his cartoon bomb – the Israeli PM shows his ‘evidence’
people
Arts and Entertainment
80s trailblazer: comedian Tracey Ullman
tv
News
i100
Life and Style
A statue of the Flemish geographer Gerard Kremer, Geradus Mercator (1512 - 1594) which was unveiled at the Geographical Congree at Anvers. He was the first person to use the word atlas to describe a book of maps.
techThe 16th century cartographer created the atlas
Arts and Entertainment
Stephen Tompkinson is back as DCI Banks
tvReview: Episode one of the new series played it safe, but at least this drama has a winning formula
News
i100
Latest stories from i100
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?
Independent Dating
and  

By clicking 'Search' you
are agreeing to our
Terms of Use.

iJobs Job Widget
iJobs General

Recruitment Genius: UI / UX Designer

£25000 - £35000 per annum: Recruitment Genius: This firm are focussed on assis...

Recruitment Genius: General Processor

£7 per hour: Recruitment Genius: A vacancy has arisen for a General Processor ...

Recruitment Genius: Outbound Sales Executive - B2B

£18000 - £22000 per annum: Recruitment Genius: A great opportunity has arisen ...

Recruitment Genius: Online Sales and Customer Services Associate

£14000 - £16000 per annum: Recruitment Genius: Full time and Part time positio...

Day In a Page

War with Isis: Iraq's government fights to win back Tikrit from militants - but then what?

Baghdad fights to win back Tikrit from Isis – but then what?

Patrick Cockburn reports from Kirkuk on a conflict which sectarianism has made intractable
Living with Alzheimer's: What is it really like to be diagnosed with early-onset dementia?

What is it like to live with Alzheimer's?

Depicting early-onset Alzheimer's, the film 'Still Alice' had a profound effect on Joy Watson, who lives with the illness. She tells Kate Hilpern how she's coped with the diagnosis
The Internet of Things: Meet the British salesman who gave real-world items a virtual life

Setting in motion the Internet of Things

British salesman Kevin Ashton gave real-world items a virtual life
Election 2015: Latest polling reveals Tories and Labour on course to win the same number of seats - with the SNP holding the balance of power

Election 2015: A dead heat between Mr Bean and Dick Dastardly!

Lord Ashcroft reveals latest polling – and which character voters associate with each leader
Audiences queue up for 'true stories told live' as cult competition The Moth goes global

Cult competition The Moth goes global

The non-profit 'slam storytelling' competition was founded in 1997 by the novelist George Dawes Green and has seen Malcolm Gladwell, Salman Rushdie and Molly Ringwald all take their turn at the mic
Pakistani women come out fighting: A hard-hitting play focuses on female Muslim boxers

Pakistani women come out fighting

Hard-hitting new play 'No Guts, No Heart, No Glory' focuses on female Muslim boxers
Leonora Carrington transcended her stolid background to become an avant garde star

Surreal deal: Leonora Carrington

The artist transcended her stolid background to become an avant garde star
LGBT History Month: Pupils discuss topics from Sappho to same-sex marriage

Education: LGBT History Month

Pupils have been discussing topics from Sappho to same-sex marriage
11 best gel eyeliners

Go bold this season: 11 best gel eyeliners

Use an ink pot eyeliner to go bold on the eyes with this season's feline flicked winged liner
Cricket World Cup 2015: Tournament runs riot to make the event more hit than miss...

Cricket World Cup runs riot to make the event more hit than miss...

The tournament has reached its halfway mark and scores of 300 and amazing catches abound. One thing never changes, though – everyone loves beating England
Katarina Johnson-Thompson: Heptathlete ready to jump at first major title

Katarina Johnson-Thompson: Ready to jump at first major title

After her 2014 was ruined by injury, 21-year-old Briton is leading pentathlete going into this week’s European Indoors. Now she intends to turn form into gold
Syrian conflict is the world's first 'climate change war', say scientists, but it won't be the last one

Climate change key in Syrian conflict

And it will trigger more war in future
How I outwitted the Gestapo

How I outwitted the Gestapo

My life as a Jew in wartime Berlin
The nation's favourite animal revealed

The nation's favourite animal revealed

Women like cuddly creatures whilst men like creepy-crawlies
Is this the way to get young people to vote?

Getting young people to vote

From #VOTESELFISH to Bite the Ballot